Episode 19: The Amityville Horror: The Haunting, The Hoax, and the House
Actually... Forgotten Stories for Curious MindsSummary
The infamous Amityville Horror story, rooted in a tragic family murder, continues to captivate and horrify. On November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered six members of his family in their Long Island home, a crime that shocked the nation. DeFeo initially claimed that an unknown assailant was responsible but later confessed to the killings, leading to his conviction in 1975. The DeFeo family, once perceived as prosperous and typical, was marred by allegations of domestic strife and connections to organized crime, which added layers of intrigue to the case.
Following the murders, the house became notorious when George and Kathy Lutz moved in, claiming to experience a series of supernatural disturbances during their brief 28-day stay. Their account, popularized in Jay Anson's book "The Amityville Horror," sparked widespread fascination and skepticism alike. Critics have pointed out inconsistencies in the Lutzes' story, with many details lacking independent verification. Investigations revealed that neighbors reported no unusual activity, and the supposed paranormal phenomena, such as cold spots and strange odors, were never substantiated by physical evidence.
The narrative surrounding Amityville evolved into a cultural phenomenon, fueled by a successful film adaptation and the involvement of paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. However, the authenticity of the Lutzes' experiences remains hotly debated, with some, including DeFeo's defense attorney, suggesting that the haunting was fabricated for profit. Despite the changes made to the house over the years, including alterations to its exterior, the Amityville story endures, illustrating how real tragedy can be transformed into entertainment, often overshadowing the very real lives lost within its walls.
Show Notes
In 1974, six members of the DeFeo family were murdered inside a house in Amityville, New York. Just over a year later, a new family moved in – and fled after only 28 days, claiming something terrifying was living there with them. What followed became one of the most famous haunting stories in American history, complete with demonic encounters, paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren, bestselling books, and a Hollywood horror franchise. But how much of The Amityville Horror actually happened? We take a deep dive in this episode and find out!
Show Notes:
Amityville "Ghost Boy" Photo: https://www.historyvshollywood.com/reelfaces/amityville-ghost-boy.php
EXCELLENT Book about the Investigation into the Events at the Amityville House, The Amityville Horror Conspiracy by Stephen Kaplan https://link.amazon/B00QMeSV9
The Night the DeFeos Died: Reinvestigating the Amityville Murders by Ric Osuna https://link.amazon/B00QMeSV9
Documentary by Daniel "Danny" Lutz, one of George and Kathy's children (which I wrongfully said was a book in the episode...sorry about that!)My Amityville Horrorhttps://link.amazon/B0isfiCSd
More from Actually... Forgotten Stories for Curious Minds
For more than a century, the Ouija board has fascinated, frightened, and mystified millions. But what if one of the world's most infamous supernatural objects started out as something far less sinister...a clever business opportunity? From the rise of Spiritualism in nineteenth-century America to a mysterious naming session, bitter business rivalries, and a tragic factory accident, the true history of the Ouija board is stranger than you might expect. In this episode of Actually... Forgotten Stories for Curious Minds, we uncover the surprising origins of the talking board, explore the science behind its seemingly mysterious movements, and discover how an ordinary parlor game became a symbol of supernatural terror. And as for the name Ouija? Well, according to legend, the board actually...chose it itself. Say what?? You'll have to tune in for the rest! :)
So how much of what we think we know about the Salem witch trials is actually true? In Part 2, the conclusion of our two-part series, on the Salem Witch Trials, we're heading into the courtrooms of 1692, where invisible evidence could send someone to the gallows, proclaiming your innocence could make things worse, and even a respected grandmother wasn't safe from accusation. We'll uncover the real stories behind some of Salem's most infamous executions, meet the man who refused to enter a plea, and discover why one woman remained imprisoned even after being found not guilty. But the story doesn't end when the executions stop. From judges who refused to apologize to a group of eighth-graders who helped correct a 329-year-old injustice, we'll explore how Massachusetts spent centuries trying to undo what Salem accomplished in a matter of months. And we'll ask one final question: When an entire community participates in an injustice, who is responsible for making it right? Don't forget to listen to Part 1 to get the backstory on how this all started! Show Notes for Part 2: Learn more about the wacky world of "poppets" here: https://www.learnreligions.com/all-about-magical-poppets-2562563
Everyone knows the story of the Salem witch trials. A group of girls behaved strangely, frightened villagers cried witchcraft, and innocent people paid the price. Right? Except…that's not quite how it happened. In Part One of this two-part series, we're going back to 1692 to uncover what really set the Salem witch trials in motion - such as a community divided and under pressure, a controversial minister, an enslaved woman named Tituba, a VERY questionable cake recipe, and a justice system willing to accept invisible evidence as fact. How did a handful of accusations become a deadly conspiracy? And why did questioning the accusers eventually make you a suspect yourself? The truth is far more complicated - and far more disturbing - than the version most of us learned in school. Part Two arrives Thursday...make sure you tune in to both to hear the full story!
In 1897, a young West Virginia woman died suddenly, was buried quickly, and might have been forgotten. The doctor called it natural causes. Her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, wasn’t convinced. Then she made an extraordinary claim: her daughter had returned from the dead – and named her killer. On this episode of Actually, we explore the tale of the Greenbrier Ghost – a haunting story of a suspicious death, a determined mother, a murder case that took an unexpected turn in court, and a story that refused to stay buried.It’s remembered as the case a ghost helped solve. But what happened when that supernatural story met the very earthly business of proving a crime?Tune in to find out this and more...
Was your living room once a “death room”? And did old American houses in the Northeast really have special doors for carrying out coffins? They’re the kind of stories that make a haunted walking tour memorable. But behind those wonderfully creepy explanations lies a stranger – and surprisingly human – history. Actually kicks off spooky season with “The Room Where Death Used to Live,” exploring home funerals, Victorian mourning customs, and how America’s relationship with death changed the spaces we call home. Along the way: a mysterious side door, a magazine editor with strong opinions, and a very persistent story about how the living room got its name. Before you give your couch a suspicious look, give it a listen. And stay tuned for the second episode of the week which is dropping THIS THURSDAY!