Workers Comp Matters

“Many ills may strike, but one must answer.” Medical Causation Standards in Workers' Compensation Claims

Workers Comp Matters

Show Notes

Causation and Workers’ Compensation? It’s complicated, and it varies by state. The concept is that to qualify for Workers’ Comp there must be a direct link between the injury (or illness) and the workplace. But how do you prove what’s a direct result of the workplace and what was the result of a prior injury or condition?

Here’s where it gets confusing. Every state has its own rules. There are varying degrees of required proof, pre-existing conditions, mental trauma, contributing causes, and it can be a challenge to sift through each jurisdiction’s standards.

Hosts Judson and Alan Pierce dissect how pre-existing conditions complicate work-related injury claims. It’s not always as clear as it seems, and state-by-state regulations create even more confusion. Add in workplace psychological stresses and it goes even deeper.

If you have thoughts on Workers’ Comp law or an idea for a topic or guest you’d like to hear, contact us at [email protected] or [email protected].

Mentioned in This Episode:

“AMA Guides® to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment: An Overview”

“AMA Guides to Disease and Injury Causation,” by J. Mark Melhorn

More from Workers Comp Matters

Oct 20, 2026

Artificial intelligence is all around us, in courtrooms, law offices, insurance claims processing, medical practices, and just about everywhere else. But what happens when AI makes its way into an actual Workers’ Compensation case. Today’s guest, Judge Frank McKay, is an appellate judge and a director of the Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation. This is a fascinating conversation on the cutting edge of Workers’ Comp management.

Sep 10, 2026

It’s been 25 years since 9/11. In this special episode, we revisit our conversation with Kenneth Feinberg, the architect of the federal compensation plan for victims and their families. As he asks in his book on the subject, “what’s life worth?”

Aug 31, 2026

Let’s go way down south to Alabama. As we know, Workers’ Compensation systems can vary from state to state. In this episode, we’ll explore the Alabama system with Birmingham-based Workers’ Comp attorney David Nomberg, a partner in the Nomberg Law Firm.

Jul 28, 2026

Let’s talk about work-related joint injuries and replacements. Sebastian Negrusa, Ph.D., joins Judson and Alan to share the Workers’ Compensation Research Institute’s (WCRI) new report, “Recent Trends in Joint Replacement Among Workers’ Compensation Claims.”

Jul 1, 2026

In this fascinating episode, explore how the Exclusive Remedy Rule works in the real and evolving world of Workers’ Compensation law. A recent case in Washington State, the Teela Bauer case, challenges the traditional exchange of employer civil protections for worker compensation in the case of workplace harm.

See all episodes →