The Politics of Evidence-Based Policymaking (Professor Paul Cairney)

How to Communicate Policy Research beyond the Academy

The Politics of Evidence-Based Policymaking (Professor Paul Cairney)

Show Notes

This is a short talk at the University of Queensland in Brisbane (24 October 2018) called Theory and Practice: How to Communicate Policy Research beyond the Academy

The blog post - Theory and Practice: How to Communicate Policy Research beyond the Academy - should be written in a way that allows you to read along (or at least see the pictures/ powerpoint slides I mention). It begins:

'Here is the powerpoint that I tend to use to inform discussions with civil servants (CS). I first used it for discussion with CS in the Scottish and UK governments, followed by remarkably similar discussions in parts of New Zealand and Australian government. Partly, it provides a way into common explanations for gaps between the supply of, and demand for, research evidence. However, it also provides a wider context within which to compare abstract and concrete reasons for those gaps, which inform a discussion of possible responses at individual, organisational, and systemic levels. Some of the gap is caused by a lack of effective communication, but we should also discuss the wider context in which such communication takes place.

I begin by telling civil servants about the message I give to academics about why policymakers might ignore their evidence:

There are many claims to policy relevant knowledge.

Policymakers have to ignore most evidence.

There is no simple policy cycle in which we all know at what stage to provide what evidence

...

In such talks, I go into different images of policymaking, comparing the simple policy cycle with images of ‘messy’ policymaking, then introducing my own image which describes the need to understand the psychology of choice within a complex policymaking environment.

Under those circumstances, key responses include:

framing evidence in terms of the ways in which your audience understands policy problems

engaging in networks to identify and exploit the right time to act, and

venue shopping to find sympathetic audiences in different parts of political systems.

[see the post for more words, and to see the pictures]

More from The Politics of Evidence-Based Policymaking (Professor Paul Cairney)

Jan 18, 2021

Here is a brief talk that I gave at the University of Queensland in Brisbane (25 October 2018). It accompanies a blog post Evidence-based policymaking and the new policy sciences [and powerpoint ppt]:

Jan 18, 2021

Based on the blog post Policy Concepts in 1000 Words: the intersection between evidence and policy transfer

Jan 18, 2021

Recorded in front of a live studio audience (of undergraduate social policy students). This lecture ties well to the short explainer Policy Concepts in 1000 Words: ‘Evidence Based Policymaking’ but I also wrote a separate post to accompany this talk ‘Evidence-based Policymaking’ and the Study of Public Policy:

Jan 15, 2021

Speaker: Dr Paul Cairney, Professor of Politics and Public Policy, University of Stirling, Scotland, UK

See all episodes →