Your Digital Reputation

67. Jacki Johnson, Board Director & Author | When your story runs ahead of your governance

Your Digital Reputation

Show Notes

For years, leaders have been encouraged to tell better stories. New research from Dr Jacki Johnson now suggests - for some organisations - that may be the most dangerous advice they could act on.

Jacki is an author, board director and a former insurance executive and chief executive, including six years leading IAG New Zealand through the Christchurch earthquake recovery. She has chaired the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative and co-founded the Australian Sustainable Finance Initiative. She then pursued a doctorate on a question she needed to answer: how do listed companies actually create value for all stakeholders?

The answer does not lie in messaging; it's found in governance.

In fact, in her research across the ASX200, of the four archetypes she identified, the group carrying the most risk was one you might least expect: the "strategic storytellers." Those with a strong narrative, but whose communications capability runs ahead of governance.

What makes this risk so hard to spot is that it easily happens through drift, not design. Strategy gets set in the boardroom, the narrative takes shape somewhere else, and that narrative is repeatedly shared "by" executives who never held the pen that wrote it. Each handover makes sense, yet the distance between them is where risk compounds. In Jacki's words, these organisations are "one month away from a question being raised by some stakeholder [asking]: 'How real is this?'"

This episode of the Your Digital Reputation podcast highlights the importance of alignment between governance and communications, and shows how the "digital mirror" - that reflects a company's cracks to the outside world, long before anything formally shatters - is well worth paying attention to. Tune in now to hear Jacki and host Roger Christie provide a fresh perspective on the risks and rewards to consider online.

Jacki's book, When the Mirror Shatters: Moving from Broken Promises to Creating Stakeholder Value, is now available.

TIMESTAMPS: 00:05:23 - Jacki's own "mirror shattering" moment 00:08:09 - The royal commission, and what she had missed 00:11:09 - Twelve practices that separate the high stakeholder value companies 00:17:06 - Why employees are the first to know 00:22:41 - From boardroom strategy to published narrative, and who holds the pen 00:31:17 - The chairman's lounge problem 00:39:07 - The four archetypes, and what value creators do differently 00:45:00 - Why storytelling is not the problem

SUBSCRIBE FOR REGULAR INSIGHTS To sign up to Roger Christie's regular newsletter, head to: https://www.propelgroup.com.au/subscribe

CONNECT WITH ROGER CHRISTIE Have a question, feedback or want to connect with Roger? Head to: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rogerchristie Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from Your Digital Reputation

Oct 13, 2026

Most conventional wisdom about executive profile building starts with being seen, and having an opinion. But what if the smartest strategy was almost the opposite?

Sep 23, 2026

Would you say the main thrust of your communications reflects your competence, or character?

Aug 11, 2026

What is your reputation actually worth?

Jul 21, 2026

Leadership belief forms from everything you do, is often decided on when you're not in the room, and is tested whenever your leadership falls under the microscope - any belief is either lacking and exposed, or present and pays dividends.

Jul 1, 2026

For decades, "communication" was largely a one-way flow, with stakeholders on the receiving end. Whether via a press release, internal comms or investor relations - organisations could essentially set a narrative and expect it to land. The model worked.

See all episodes →