Julie's Gone

Episode 2: God's Witnesses

Julie's Gone

Show Notes

It’s always been assumed there were no witnesses from the time Julie Garciacelay went missing. But police failed to talk to neighbours about what they saw the night she disappeared. So they missed vital information early in their investigation.

Nearly five decades later, Casefile Presents found two people who remember something frightening... Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from Julie's Gone

Feb 13, 2026

Not long after this podcast was released last year, Julie Garciacelay's mother, Ruth, died in California. She was 93. Yet, more than 50 years after her daughter vanished, Ruth's DNA could prove crucial in solving the case.

Jul 30, 2025

When Julie and her two sisters were little, their mother bought them a toy piano to share. Julie took to it with passion and became a gifted pianist. Now, her legacy lives on through the piano scholarship Ruth Garciacelay set up, in her daughter’s name, in northern California.

Jul 30, 2025

Veteran detectives believe the crucial clue that can lead to an ancient ‘cold case’ like Julie Garciacelay’s being solved is usually found in the original file.

Jul 30, 2025

In the decade that followed Julie’s murder, 19 other women suffered violent deaths in Melbourne.

Jul 30, 2025

When Ruth Garciacelay realised her daughter really was missing, she flew to Australia from the US. A couple of years later, she returned to Melbourne and had an unnerving encounter with one of the men who’d been with Julie the night she disappeared.

See all episodes →