Summary
The third anniversary of the defeat of The Voice referendum on October 14, 2023, raises critical questions about Australia's attitudes toward race and Indigenous rights. Despite initial polling showing strong support for the proposal, the final outcome revealed a significant misunderstanding among voters regarding the depth of that support. Professors Murray Goote and Tim Rouse, in their new book "The Year Our Voice Broke," analyze the polling data and suggest that many who initially expressed support were not strongly committed to the idea, leading to a disappointing 40% approval on voting day.
The authors highlight a widespread ignorance about how The Voice would function, with only half of voters claiming to understand its mechanisms before the referendum. This lack of clarity, compounded by a lengthy campaign that diverted attention to pressing issues like cost of living, contributed to voter disengagement. Goote and Rouse argue that the government’s failure to adequately explain the proposal left many voters feeling uncertain and unwilling to endorse a constitutional change that seemed to lack clear benefits.
The discussion also touches on the historical context of Indigenous rights in Australia, noting a long-standing aversion to special privileges for Indigenous Australians. The authors reflect on past proposals for constitutional protections against racial discrimination and how these were politically unviable. They suggest that the framing of The Voice as a unique institution for Indigenous Australians may have alienated potential supporters who perceived it as preferential treatment rather than a necessary step toward equality.
In conclusion, while the defeat of The Voice marks a setback for Indigenous rights, Goote and Rouse express a cautious optimism about the future. They suggest that the indifference of the electorate could create opportunities for political action without significant opposition, paving the way for future initiatives that may address Indigenous issues more effectively.
Show Notes
Three years ago, 60 per cent of Australians voted to reject the Voice to Parliament proposal in a referendum. A new book seeks to understand why, through analyses of extensive polling and survey data. Guests: Professor Murray Goot, Macquarie University and Professor Emeritus Tim Rowse, Western Sydney University, co-authors 'The Year Our Voice Broke' (2026)
More from Late Night Live - Separate stories podcast
The UK prepares for its budget, with the cost of living, public services and a struggling economy high on the agenda. Meanwhile, Andy Burnham has reopened the debate over freedom of movement with Europe, and an undercover ITV investigation has raised fresh questions about racism and sexism in Nigel Farage’s Reform UK. Guest: Ian Dunt, I-Paper columnist and regular LNL correspondent Producer: Ali Benton
Bones are an archive of human experience, preserving traces of disease, violence, labour and time. In The Language of Bones, forensic anthropology reveals what human remains can tell us about lives long since ended. From ancient ossuaries and catacombs to modern forensic investigations, skeletons offer clues to the past that written history often overlooks. Guest: Carla Valentine, author, The Language of Bones Producer: Jackie Dent
France’s political crisis is deepening, with a mounting debt burden, a paralysed parliament and growing public anger over the future of the country’s social model. As governments struggle to agree on a budget, Marine Le Pen’s far right is waiting in the wings. Guest: James Waterhouse, BBC Paris Correspondent Producer: Ali Benton
Anna Henderson discusses the ongoing debate over the connection between the tone of political rhetoric and real world acts of violence, since the attack on Independent MP Helen Haines, the motive for which is still under investigation. Federal parliament spent the day allowing time for reflections on the attack, and sending messages of support for Dr Haines. Meanwhile the Ombudsman has criticised the federal government for its use of algorithms in aged care assessments, warning the government has not learned the lessons from Robodebt. Guest: Anna Henderson, chief political correspondent, SBS
Over her 70 year reign, Queen Elizabeth II encountered 13 US presidents - from Harry S Truman to Donald J Trump. The journalist Susan Page details how the Queen wielded her subtle influence over the world's most powerful men. Guest: Susan Page, Washington bureau chief for USA Today, author of 'The Queen and Her Presidents' Producer: Ali Benton