The Creation Podcast

The Soulless Hominid Theory: A Fatal Flaw in Old Earth Creationism | The Creation Podcast: Episode 94

The Creation Podcast

Show Notes

Welcome to the second episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old earth ideology into their beliefs, adopting uniformitarian or evolutionary pieces into their worldview. While this is often done in an effort to appeal to science, it can cause major logical, scientific, and theological issues.

The conversation surrounding human origins has always been an intriguing one. One of the most debated subjects is the nature of the beings labeled ‘hominids,’ particularly Neanderthals. Biblical Creationists firmly place Neanderthals in the ‘human’ category—descendants of Adam and Eve, thus bearing God’s image. Most evolutionary biologists today also agree with Neanderthals being mostly human, leaving their genetic mark on our DNA through interbreeding.

Some old earth creationists suggest something quite different. They claim that Neanderthals were nothing more than animals—truly bipedal animals that are able to make and use tools, paint, and bury their dead—but animals nonetheless.

Is there any truth to this idea? Were they just animals? Or were they fully human, bearing the image of God? In today’s episode, we’ll dig into “The Mystery of the Soulless Hominids,” ex... More...

More from The Creation Podcast

Jul 29, 2026

Geologist Dr. Tim Clarey spent 13 years digging into rock layers from every continent on Earth, and what he found doesn't match what most people were taught in school. This conversation lays out the evidence that confirms the biblical timeline and events.

Jul 14, 2026

Trey sits down with Dr. Michael Boyle to talk about his time in mainstream science, what ultimately led him to the Institute for Creation Research, and how that journey reshaped his worldview. They also dive into Dr. Boyle's fascinating research on blind cavefish.

Jun 17, 2026

In this episode of the Creation Podcast, host Mary Clair sits down with Dr. Randy Guliuzza, president of the Institute for Creation Research, to expose a flaw at the very foundation of Darwinian theory: the personification of nature.

Jun 3, 2026

People know the Institute for Creation Research for its scientists and research — but behind everything they do is a team of people building real relationships with the donors who make it all possible. Today, host Mary Clair Kelly sits down with James Gadberry, Director of Development and Donor Relations, and Regina Krieg, Director of Planned Giving, to share their personal faith journeys and the remarkable stories that have shaped their time at ICR.

May 20, 2026

Netflix has released a new “documentary” series called The Dinosaurs… Today Trey sits down with Dr. Tim Clary — PhD geologist and director of research at ICR with over 40 years in the field — to expose what the four-part documentary gets wrong, what it deliberately ignores, and what the actual fossil record shows, before revealing why the biblical account of creation and Noah's Flood offers a far more consistent and compelling explanation for what we actually find in the ground.

See all episodes →