
The Real American Frontier | Part 2 | The homesteaders trad wives would rather forget about (with Megan Kate Nelson)
Broad HistoryShow Notes
In part 2 of our exploration of the American frontier, Megan Kate Nelson introduces two women who belie the homesteader image conservative "trad wives" like to harken back to. Polly Bemis was a Chinese immigrant who built a life and a community in Idaho, despite intense prejudice and stringent anti-Chinese immigration policies. Ella Watson was a self-made homesteader and small rancher, a so-called cattle queen who got on the wrong side of cattle barons in Wyoming and paid the price. Read more: How Chinese women were barred from the American dream
★ Support this podcast ★
On this episode:
Isabelle Roughol - Host
Megan Kate Nelson - Guest
What do you think?Read & comment at broadhistory.com Reply on Bluesky
Email me: [email protected] Jump to:
(00:00) - Megan Kate Nelson part 2 (updated 29/7)
(00:35) - Start of interview
(01:03) - Introducing Polly Bemis
(02:20) - The majority-Chinese American West
(06:11) - Polly Bemis traveled without moving
(08:29) - Chinese women were the first targets of US anti-immigrant policy
(09:07) - The aggressive anti-Chinese immigration policies of the United States
(11:29) - How big government made the West for white men
(12:59) - Ella Watson's broken American dream
(13:41) - The cattle queens
(22:19) - A high tolerance for risk
(23:46) - Why correcting the Frontier myth matters today
(26:22) - How trad wives utilise the American Frontier
(29:38) - What moment in history should we revisit from women's perspective?
(33:47) - Outro
Get the book 🇺🇸 Buy the book 🇬🇧 Shop the UK bookshop (Megan Kate Nelson's The Westerners is only available in the US) (Affiliate bookshop.org links support Broad History and indie bookstores.)Click here to view the episode transcript.
More from Broad History
To listen to this episode in full, join at broadhistory.com/membership. Historian Malcolm Gaskill helps us understand the "wrong but sincere" 17th-century folks behind witchcraft accusations and busts some myths about witches and the witch hunts. Where do the pointy hat and broomstick come from? Who was accused of being witches? How many trials even took place and how often were people convicted? What was people's relationship to the supernatural and why did they see witches where we (mostly) no longer do? 🇺🇸 Pre-order Worlds of Fear and Wonder in the US 🇬🇧 Pre-order Worlds of Fear and Wonder in the UK (Affiliate bookshop.org links support Broad History and indie bookstores.) Click here to view the episode transcript.
Republican motherhood is a fundamental concept of the early American republic. Women's political power, it argues, is exercised not at the ballot box but in their own separate sphere, where they raise good little patriots. Carol Berkin concludes our series with a look at the long impact of the American revolution for women and connects the dots with the United States' current political landscape, 250 years on.
Mercy Otis Warren was what the Revolution called a "female politician" – a woman who cared about and discussed politics, a wholly new archetype for American society then. Her poems, plays and pamphlets – and ultimately her 3-volume history of the revolution – established her as a key political thinker of the movement for independence. But she walked a fine line: she never meant to "transgress the boundaries of (her) sex" and always thought of herself as a wife and mother first. To discuss her life and women's part in the political philosophy of the revolution, I'm joined by Mercy's biographer, Rosemarie Zagarri. Read the books 🇺🇸 Buy Rosemarie Zagarri's books in the US A Woman's Dilemma: Mercy Otis Warren and the American Revolution: https://bookshop.org/a/79408/9781118775011 Revolutionary Backlash: Women and Politics in the Early American Republic: https://bookshop.org/a/79408/9780812220735 🇬🇧 Buy Rosemarie Zagarri's books in the UK A Woman's Dilemma: Mercy Otis Warren and the American Revolution: https://uk.bookshop.org/a/9178/9781118775011 Revolutionary Backlash: Women and Politics in the Early American Republic: https://uk.bookshop.org/a/9178/9781666133929 (Affiliate bookshop.org links support Broad History and indie bookstores.)
Phillis Wheatley Peters was transported to America as an enslaved 7-year-old. She quickly became a literary prodigy and an international celebrity – the unofficial first poet laureate of a new nation, says her biographer Vincent Carretta. Together we explore her life, her legacy and recent findings that transform our understanding of the final years of her too-short life. 🇺🇸 Get the books: (Affiliate bookshop.org links support Broad History and indie bookstores.)
When Elizabeth "Mumbet" Freeman overheard the opening of the new Massachussetts constitution in 1780 – "all men are born free and equal" – she knew the words had to apply to her, too. Elizabeth was the first enslaved woman to sue for and win her freedom in a US court. To talk about arguably the most impactful woman in this series and the true meaning of freedom and the American promise, I'm joined by Errin Haines, co-founder and editor-at-large of The 19th*.