Show Notes
In this second Dealcraft episode, six remarkable women and men discuss how they dealt with critical moments in their most challenging business and public sector negotiations. After each example, I’ll suggest insights that will help you handle critical moments in your toughest deals. Here’s who you’ll meet:
Charlene Barshefsky, elite private sector lawyer and former US special trade representative, dealing with a threatening ultimatum in China;
Rex Tillerson, who headed ExxonMobil and served as the U.S. Secretary of State, earlier in his career facing a key moment in a middle eastern business deal, when the other side began to hurl insults and tear up two years of progress;
Blackstone’s Steve Schwarzman responding to a make-or-break negotiating impasse with a Japanese company when Blackstone was still a fragile startup;
An English property developer facing apparently extortionate demands by the owner of the final, must-have parcel;
How Henry Kissinger, when secretly negotiating with Zhou Enlai, finally cracked the killer issue that for years had blocked any relationship between the U.S. and China; and
Christiana Figueres, Costa Rican diplomat and the key UN figure in the 2015 Paris climate negotiations, persuading the very reluctant Saudis to come on board.
About Jim Sebenius
A systematic approach to handling challenging negotiations is in the book I wrote with David Lax, 3D Negotiation. More about my background is here plus information about the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School—a consortium of Harvard, MIT, and Tufts—and the Future of Diplomacy Project at Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center. Contact me here.
Resources Mentioned in Episode 2
Many of my academic colleagues have written excellent papers on various aspects of critical moments in negotiation. You can find many of these articles in two special issues of the Negotiation Journal devoted to this topic. The first of these issues is in Vol. 20, No. 2 (April 2004). In this issue, among many excellent pieces, I especially like the introduction: Carrie Menkel-Meadow; Critical Moments in Negotiation: Implications for Research, Pedagogy, and Practice. Negotiation Journal 2004; 20 (2): 341–347, as well as this article: Gillian M. Green, Michael Wheeler; Awareness and Action in Critical Moments. Negotiation Journal 2004; 20 (2): 349–364.
In the second issue of the Negotiation Journal devoted to critical moments, Vol. 36, No. 2 (Spring 2020), I refer you especially to the introduction: Daniel Druckman and Joel Cutcher‐Gershenfeld; Introduction to Special Issue: Critical Moments in Negotiation II. Negotiation Journal 2020; 36 (2): 85–90. I also like the piece by Lawrence Susskind; Ten Propositions Regarding Critical Moments in Negotiation. Negotiation Journal 2004; 20 (2): 339–340.
Acknowledgements
I am deeply grateful to Harvard for giving me permission to use audio excerpts from interviews I’ve conducted over the years with various Great Negotiator honorees and U.S. Secretaries of State, often with colleagues and friends such as Robert Mnookin of Harvard Law School and R. Nicholas Burns, formerly of Harvard’s Kennedy School.
Materials courtesy of the Great Negotiator Award Program at the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School. Copyright © President and Fellows of Harvard College.
Materials courtesy of the American Secretaries of State Program, a joint effort of the Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School, the Program on the Future of Diplomacy at Harvard Kennedy School, and Harvard Business School. Copyright © President and Fellows of Harvard College.
More from Dealcraft: Insights from Great Negotiators
While we’re in-between Dealcraft seasons, we’re sharing an episode of Managing the Future of Work, the chart-topping and critically-acclaimed podcast from Harvard Business School. Each episode, HBS professors Bill Kerr and Joe Fuller talk to CEOs, technologists and experts grappling with the forces (like automation and demographic shifts) that are reshaping the nature of work. You’ll hear thought-provoking conversations with notable guests, including IBM’s Chief Human Resources Officer Nickle LaMoreaux on how Big Blue is adopting AI, and LinkedIn’s SVP and Chief People Officer Teuila Hanson on workforce diversity.
In the final episode of Season One of Dealcraft: Insights from the World's Great Negotiators, I’ll offer you several fresh negotiation insights plus a look back over the dealmakers and diplomats from whom we've heard during these last twelve weeks. Each of these negotiators has given us a master class in one or more of the “dimensions” that make up the “3D Negotiation” framework that David Lax and I have developed over the last three decades:
Sadly, Colin Powell is best remembered in many quarters for deploying his immense personal prestige in giving what became his infamous speech at the United Nations. This speech purported to reveal evidence that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction, thereby building support for the disastrous U.S. invasion of that country. Powell did not want to give this speech on the rushed timetable demanded by President George W. Bush along with neoconservatives Vice President Dick Cheney and others. Having “lost” this timing negotiation with the president, the die was cast. We probe this episode for insight into how a more sophisticated approach to his “negotiation” with the president might have led to a very different outcome, in the process seeking to extract positive lessons from painful negotiating failures.
In 2015, before a rapt Harvard audience, Colin Powell recounted his poignant and incredible life story and career with me and my colleagues Bob Mnookin and Nick Burns. Interwoven into his remarkable accounts were lessons drawn from profound success and deep failure in negotiation. In this week's episode of Dealcraft: Insights from the World's Great Negotiators, I share three short examples of success from these conversations with Powell:
When facing any negotiating counterpart, especially a very tough one, it is wise to learn as much as possible about their background, likely approach, and tactics that can turn the interaction to your advantage. This episode uses Vladimir Putin as a prototypical hardball opponent and shows just how much one can usefully learn by speaking with others who have extensively and personally negotiated with this challenging Russian leader. Via interviews with former U.S. Secretaries of State Colin Powell, Condoleezza Rice, Hillary Clinton, John Kerry, and Rex Tillerson (who also carried out many negotiations with Putin when Tillerson was a top ExxonMobil executive), this episode gives valuable insights into dealing effectively with Putin, but more generally demonstrates a key element of preparation for tough deals.