Show Notes
Developmental editors Anne Hawley and Rachelle Ramirez break down what your first page must promise—and how to deliver it for your ideal reader. From raising the right questions to dodging common traps (info dumps, action-for-action’s-sake), you’ll get practical ways to craft an opening that compels page turns and signals the book you actually wrote. What you’ll learn Why your first page is a promise—and how to make the right one How to define and hook your ideal reader (not “everyone”) When to open with action vs. narration, and why “start in action” is often misapplied Raising mystery and intrigue without confusing the reader The truth about “show, don’t tell” on page one Where the inciting incident belongs (and when it doesn’t) Avoiding info dumps while still orienting the reader When to stop polishing page one—and when to return to it Simple exercises to sharpen your opening (including hand-copying a favorite first page) How to tailor your opening for agents and genre expectations
Timestamps 00:00 — The problem: “My first page isn’t hooky enough” 01:00 — Who’s your ideal reader? Hint: probably you 04:00 — The first page as a promise of the reading experience 05:00 — Do you really need to open in action? 06:00 — Orientation vs. info dump (especially for SFF) 07:30 — Must the inciting incident be on page one? 08:30 — Mystery vs. confusion: walking the line 10:00 — Intrigue through specific, telling details 11:00 — Do protagonists need to be likable? 12:00 — “Show, don’t tell”: what the rule actually means 14:00 — The trap of overworking your opening 15:00 — Write the draft first; promise precisely later 17:00 — The power of your first ~300 words 18:00 — Discovery writing and changing stories 19:00 — Craft exercise: hand-copy your favorite first page 20:00 — Making your promise clear—and pitching the right agents
Try this Pull three novels you love. Hand-copy their first pages. Mark where they raise questions, slip in exposition, and introduce desire or problem. Rewrite your first 300 words to: Gut-check: Does your first page promise the book you actually wrote?
Mentioned Ursula K. Le Guin (on word choice and deliberate narration) Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl (compelling “unlikable” protagonist) “It was a dark and stormy night” (Bulwer-Lytton) as an example of permissible telling
Quote “Your job as a fiction writer is to raise questions. Why I turn the page is because there’s a question in my mind.” Links Subscribe to the Write Anyway newsletter: [email protected] Pages & Platforms and the Happily Ever Author Club If this episode helped you rethink your opening, share it with a writer friend and leave a rating—it helps more writers find the show.
More from The Write Anyway Podcast
Here's a question that might change how you think about your main character: Does your protagonist want to change things—or preserve them?In this episode, Gabriela Pereira of DIYMFA breaks down her Storytelling Superpower framework—a surprisingly simple way to understand what makes protagonists like Elizabeth Bennett and Katniss Everdeen work so well on the page.Plus: why "supporting character" is a better term than "side character," the crucial difference between a villain and an antagonist, and what Shakespeare's Fool can teach you about the characters your protagonist doesn't want to listen to (but really should).
Feeling squeamish about your book—or even asking for blurbs? In this episode, Sue Campbell talks with actor–author–coach Jamie Rose about “Madame X,” the inner voice that sabotages women’s creative work. Come for the mindset shifts and bite-size tools; stay for raw memoir moments, smart launch lessons, and a Steven Pressfield surprise. If you want your launch (and writing life) to feel fun, organic, and fear-resilient, this one’s a must-listen.
Sue Campbell interviews Eli Potter, tech track coordinator for the San Francisco Writers Conference and author of the bestselling book Role Modelship: Multiply Your Impact to Influence AI, about writers’ fears and ethical concerns around AI.In this episode, Eli reveals why being rude to AI will sabotage your results, why writer's block is no longer an excuse, and how writers actually have a massive advantage in an AI-saturated world.Plus: the one question that unlocks AI's real power, why your brain is getting "wired" to AI output (and why that's dangerous), and how to use these tools ethically without losing what makes your writing yours.Whether you're AI-curious or AI-skeptical, this conversation will change how you think about technology in your writing life.
On the Write Anyway podcast, host Anne Hawley interviews epic fantasy novelist Don Elliott about a simple strategy he used to rapidly improve his prose and strengthen his author voice without formal schooling. After focusing for years on story craft, Don realized his line-level writing hadn’t advanced as much, so he studied authors he admires—Mark Lawrence, Patrick Rothfuss, Ursula K. Le Guin, George R. R. Martin, and Joe Abercrombie—to analyze sentence-level choices like length, metaphor use, lyricism, and how emotion is conveyed. He then took a fully edited manuscript and rewrote passages multiple times, trimming stacked metaphors and avoiding naming emotions in favor of evoking them, sharing before-and-after examples. Don recommends daily 30–60 minute rewrite drills—rewriting your own work in an admired author’s style or rewriting their passages in your voice—to build muscle memory, reporting dramatic improvement within a week.
Can you really write a book while raising kids? Creativity coach Susie Meserve says yes — but not in the way you think. In this episode, Sue sits down with Susie to talk about what actually gets in the way of creative moms (hint: it's not just time), why having children made both of them more prolific, and the guilt spiral that so many artist moms never talk about out loud. If you're a caregiver who's told yourself "I'll get back to my writing when things slow down" — this one's for you.