Show Notes
VAR always produces a spirited debate, and today's episode is no different. Though Stefan has data that proves that VAR is highly effective, Ashish pushes back arguing that it's still used too subjectively, and that perceptions around its accuracy are a problem. What do you think?
More from The Soccernomics Podcast
There was some big news for The Soccernomics Podcast earlier this week: we won a Bronze at the Signal Awards in the sports genre! No show can win an award without an audience - so thank you all for being a part of this honor. But independent podcasting is tough. As Ashish shares in this message, it's hard to enjoy the win for long while trying to do everything possible to keep this podcast going. And in that sense, we still need your help. If you like what we're doing and haven't already, please get involved with our Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/TheSoccernomicsPodcast The button for monthly membership options are towards the top right, while the one-time contribution options are down at the bottom of the home page. Talk to you soon!
Last week, the UK's Independent Football Regulator (IFR) came out with its 'State of the Game' report which said that 94% of football clubs in the country are technically insolvent, and the majority on the edge of financial disaster. But we're here to let you in on a little secret. Despite the being on the edge of financial ruin, football clubs almost never die. Stefan explains why... ...we also explain that unlike football clubs, The Soccernomics Podcast actually will die without continued support from you (sorry, but the segue was too easy)! We're incredibly grateful to everyone who has contributed to our Patreon so far. But if we're thinking long-term (which we are) we're going to have to keep asking for continued support. Check out our monthly membership and one-time contribution options below: https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheSoccernomicsPodcast
Join The Soccernomics Podcast FC here: https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheSoccernomicsPodcast It's a big day at The Soccernomics Podcast. We're almost 40 episodes in, and we've loved connecting with all of you over the last five months. It's been incredible to find an audience that loves what we do. Until now this podcast has been self-funded in terms of money, time and labor. We'd like to keep it going for as long as we can, but we've reached the point where we can't do that with your help. By launching The Soccernomics Podcast FC, we're offering different tiers of monthly membership, as well as one-time contribution options. By joining, you'll help us keep this going, but also be part of building a community. As you'll see from our Patreon Link below, the different offerings will give you different perks, including but not limited to ad-free listening, bonus episodes, newsletters, trivia competitions and fantasy football. We explain it all, and why we need your help in today's episode. Join The Soccernomics Podcast FC here: https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheSoccernomicsPodcast As mentioned in the episode, the first ten members in each tier can get 10% off for the first month. Use the code 53F85 to claim the offer. To maximize your support, please subscribe via web browser rather than the mobile app! (Mobile apps take more fees!)
Simon Kuper drops in to play peacemaker between Stefan and Ashish. Tune in to hear his views on the Manchester City fallout, and whether FIFA President Gianni Infantino has weathered the storm after his failed World Cup sell-off plan. Note: This episode was recorded before the Times of London revealed Gianni Infantino has been receiving an undisclosed second salary at FIFA. As a reminder you can vote for us at The Signal Awards until October 15! https://vote.signalaward.com/PublicVoting#/2026/shows/genre/sports
As we expected, we got quite a lot of messages and emails about Stefan's controversial position on Manchester City. And despite pushing back on that position last week, Ashish has also come back thinking he should have pushed even harder. Stefan, for his part, isn't really budging. The stage is set for the most combative episode of The Soccernomics Podcast so far... Tell us what you think at [email protected] And don't forget to vote for us at The Signal Awards before October 15! https://vote.signalaward.com/PublicVoting#/2026/shows/genre/sports