Secret Habit: Porn Recovery for Christian Men

152. I Have Tried Everything To Quit Porn. Now What? | Nick Stumbo, Pure Desire

Secret Habit: Porn Recovery for Christian Men

Show Notes

What if the reason you haven't found lasting freedom from pornography isn't because you haven't tried hard enough, but because you've been trying to recover without the right plan? In this powerful conversation, Shawn sits down with Nick Stumbo, Executive Director of Pure Desire Ministries, to talk honestly about pornography recovery, sexual integrity, shame, community, healing, and what it actually takes to build a life of lasting freedom. Ultimately the conversation focuses on this idea of how to prevent a relapse from porn. Nick knows this journey personally. After struggling with pornography himself, Nick experienced the transforming power of counseling, community, and a structured recovery process. His story eventually led him into ministry with Pure Desire, where he now helps equip churches, leaders, men, and women to walk through sexual brokenness toward hope, healing, and freedom. And this conversation goes far beyond simply telling men to "try harder." Nick explains why having good recovery tools matters, but why tools alone aren't the plan. Tools become powerful when they're placed inside a larger framework of community, honesty, self-awareness, and intentional action. You'll hear Nick talk about: Why trying harder often isn't enough for porn recovery Why so many men remain trapped in shame and isolation The role of community in lasting sexual integrity Why recovery needs to become a way of life, not simply a longer streak of sobriety How to recognize the patterns that lead toward relapse The importance of having a clear recovery plan Nick's three-part approach to recovery: healthy living, an escape plan, and a plan for what happens after relapse Why counseling and groups can work together so powerfully How churches can become places of healing rather than shame What Nick has learned through his own journey of recovery and sixteen years with Pure Desire Why there is still hope if you've tried everything and nothing seems to work One of the most powerful moments comes when Nick reframes the idea of "I've tried everything." Maybe you haven't tried everything. Maybe you've tried everything alone. If you've been struggling with pornography, sexual temptation, unwanted sexual behaviors, or repeated relapse, this conversation will give you a bigger picture of what recovery can actually look like. You don't have to white-knuckle your way through this. You can learn a new way of life. And you don't have to do it alone.

Ready to create your own Personal Recovery Plan? If you're tired of guessing about what to do next and want to build a recovery strategy around your story, your patterns, and your unique struggles, visit secrethabit.ca/personalrecoveryplan We'll sit down together, make sense of what's really going on, and create a clear plan for moving forward.

Connect with Nick & Pure Desire Learn more about Nick's work, Pure Desire's resources, groups, books, and training at Pure Desire Ministries. Puredesire.org

About Nick Stumbo Nick Stumbo is the Executive Director of Pure Desire Ministries and a third-generation pastor. After confronting his own pornography addiction in 2010, Nick and his wife, Michelle, found hope and healing through Pure Desire's counseling and group ministries. Since then, Nick has dedicated his life to helping the Church become a place of healing and freedom. He is the author or co-author of Setting Us Free, Safe: Creating a Culture of Grace in a Climate of Shame, and Hope, Healing and Freedom: A Pathway Beyond Pornography and Betrayal. He is also a Pastoral Sex Addiction Professional (PSAP). Nick and Michelle live in Nashville, Tennessee, with their four children.

Disclaimer: Secret Habit provides coaching and educational content, not psychotherapy, psychological counselling, medical care, or mental-health treatment. Our content is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for professional care. Results are not guaranteed.

More from Secret Habit: Porn Recovery for Christian Men

Oct 23, 2026

Why Do I Crave Porn Even Though I Don't Want To Watch It? In this episode of the Secret Habit Podcast, Shawn Bonneteau explores the role dopamine and anticipation can play in pornography addiction, and why the craving for porn can become powerful long before you ever watch it. You may tell yourself that you want porn because it feels good, but Shawn challenges you to look deeper. What are you actually expecting pornography to give you? Comfort? Control? Escape? Reassurance? A sense of being wanted? Porn can become a familiar place to run when your heart is hungry, even though what it promises rarely matches what you experience afterward. Shawn also explains why the anticipation of porn can become such a powerful part of the cycle. The build-up can be intense, but once the moment passes, many men are left with disappointment, shame, regret, and the realization that porn didn't give them what they were hoping for. This is why Shawn keeps coming back to the idea of Heart Hunger. Understanding what your heart is actually looking for can give you a very different place to start in porn recovery than simply trying to resist another urge. In this episode, we explore: Why dopamine and anticipation can make porn cravings feel so powerful Why porn can feel like certainty, comfort, or control What you may actually be looking for beneath a porn craving Why pornography often overpromises and underdelivers How shame and regret become part of the cycle Why understanding your Heart Hunger can change your recovery strategy How to begin replacing unhealthy coping with healthier ways of caring for your heart

Oct 19, 2026

Why does my porn addiction keep escalating? Maybe you started with something you thought was relatively harmless, but over time you found yourself looking for more, acting out in ways you never expected, or crossing boundaries you once believed you never would. In this episode of the Secret Habit Podcast, Shawn Bonneteau sits down with Greg Oliver of Awaken Ministries for an honest conversation about pornography addiction, escalation, childhood experiences, marriage, erectile dysfunction, and the deeper work of recovery. Greg shares from his own story and explains how early experiences can shape the beliefs, emotions, and patterns that later influence addictive behavior. He also challenges the idea that you need to have experienced one dramatic event for your story to matter. Many people carry developmental experiences that shaped how they learned to handle emotions, safety, connection, and stress. The conversation also gets practical about what helped Greg move forward: recovery community, therapy, learning, healing, and taking the struggle seriously before it escalates further. Greg's own story is a reminder that asking for help earlier can matter. In this episode, we explore: Why porn addiction can escalate over time Why some men keep crossing boundaries they never expected to cross How childhood experiences can shape adult coping patterns Why you don't need a dramatic story for your past to have affected you The connection between pornography, anxiety, sexual performance, and shame Why recovery requires more than simply trying to stop How community and qualified support can change the recovery process

Oct 16, 2026

Why do I turn to porn when I'm angry? Anger is often treated like something we simply need to get rid of, but what if anger is actually telling you something important about what is happening beneath the surface? In this episode of the Secret Habit Podcast, Shawn Bonneteau explores the relationship between anger and pornography recovery. Drawing from Jay Stringer's work in Unwanted, Shawn looks at why anger itself is not necessarily sinful and how it can become a source of valuable information when you're triggered. The question isn't only, “Why am I angry?” It's also: What do I need? What am I trying to control? What feels threatened? What am I expecting? And what is my anger revealing about my heart? Shawn explores how anger can become constructive or destructive and how needs like control, entitlement, significance, and justice can shape the way we respond. This episode is especially useful if you notice that anger, frustration, conflict, or feeling powerless often precedes pornography temptation. In this episode, we explore: Why anger itself is not necessarily a sin How anger can become sinful What anger can reveal about your deeper needs How control and entitlement can fuel anger Why anger can become connected to pornography temptation How anger can be used constructively Questions to ask yourself when you're triggered

Oct 12, 2026

How do I know if God is actually speaking to me? That can be a difficult question, especially when you're trying to make decisions, walking through relational turmoil, dealing with strong emotions, or simply wondering why God seems silent. In this episode of the Secret Habit Podcast, Shawn Bonneteau and Helena share what they have been learning about hearing from God, learning to recognize His voice, and developing a deeper relationship with Him. This conversation gets especially personal as Shawn shares about seasons where he felt like God wasn't speaking and how that exposed deeper beliefs, emotions, and expectations in his relationship with the Lord. Rather than treating hearing from God as a mysterious experience reserved for a select few, this episode explores what it can look like to keep seeking, keep knocking, become more honest with God, and learn through relationship and discipleship. We also talk about the difference between your relationship with God and your fellowship with God, why your view of God can be shaped by your experiences with authority figures, and why other people can play an important role in helping us understand what God may be doing in our lives. In this episode, we explore: How do I know if God is speaking to me? What can I do when God feels silent? How emotions and past experiences can affect the way we hear God The difference between relationship with God and fellowship with God Why learning God's voice is a process How Scripture, prayer, and discipleship fit together Why we don't have to walk our spiritual journey alone How God can use difficult seasons to reveal things in our hearts If you've been asking, “God, are you speaking to me?” this episode is an invitation to keep seeking Him rather than assuming He's absent.

Oct 9, 2026

Can pornography contribute to brain fog, anxiety, low focus, and feeling mentally drained? In this episode of the Secret Habit Podcast, Shawn Bonneteau sits down with Dr. Trish Leigh, a neuroscience expert who studies the brain, pornography consumption, dopamine, anxiety, and compulsive behavior. Dr. Trish brings a practical neuroscience perspective to a question many men are asking: “Why don't I feel like myself anymore?” She explains how pornography and other high-stimulation digital habits can affect the brain's reward systems, stress response, motivation, focus, and ability to settle into a calm state. One of the most interesting ideas in the conversation is Dr. Trish's description of the “silent tsunami” of porn addiction. She explains how patterns can begin beneath the surface and eventually show up as cravings, poor focus, anxiety, stress, and other difficulties that may seem unrelated to pornography. She also explains why self-awareness is so important. Instead of only asking, “Why did I relapse?”, we can start looking at what was happening beforehand. Stress, relationship conflict, poor sleep, and other experiences may be part of the pattern that eventually leads to pornography use. The conversation also explores dopamine, serotonin, and oxytocin and why your brain needs more than constant stimulation. Dr. Trish explains the difference between chasing dopamine and developing a healthier balance that supports calm, focus, satisfaction, connection, and motivation. Shawn also shares part of his own story, including his experience of continuing to struggle with erectile dysfunction even after quitting pornography, and how learning more about what was happening beneath the surface changed the way he understood recovery. In this episode, we explore: How pornography can affect focus, motivation, and mental clarity Why dopamine can become part of a compulsive pornography cycle What stress has to do with pornography cravings and relapse Why self-awareness matters in porn recovery The difference between dopamine, serotonin, and oxytocin Why calm and focused states matter for a healthy brain How pornography can affect sexual functioning and erectile dysfunction Why understanding your brain can give you better information for recovery How neuroscience and a deeper understanding of your inner world can work together If you've been wondering why you feel foggy, anxious, unfocused, or constantly pulled toward pornography, this conversation will give you a different way to look at what may be happening beneath the surface. Take the next steps with your recovery

See all episodes →