PodSchool

Have we over complicated podcasting? | Chat with PodCraft's Matthew McLean

PodSchool

Show Notes

Podcasting has never been a simple “hit record” and you’re done kind of game but the introduction of video has definitely added a new layer of complexity. The trick is remembering why you’re doing it and who you’re creating for, even when the industry is noisy with trends, hype, and “must‑do” advice. I recently sat down with Matthew McLean, co‑host of Podcraft, to unpack the state of podcasting right now. From the ongoing debate about whether we should even be calling it “podcasting” anymore, to how video, monetisation and platform politics are reshaping the space. We also dive into practical tools and tactics that are helping creators right now, and share why we both think podcasting still has a powerful future if you focus on the fundamentals. What we cover in this conversation: Is the term 'podcast' dead? Why some industry voices are pushing for a rebrand and why many creators (us included) aren’t convinced Why changing the name ignores the strength of the term 'podcast' and its long and impressive history

Video vs. Audio‑Only Content Why video is valuable but not a dealbreaker for growth The hidden complexity of adding full‑length video to your workflow (and why it’s okay to start audio‑only) Why consistency trumps video for long‑term audience building

Monetisation Challenges with Video Why dynamic ad serving doesn’t work on major video platforms How video‑first strategies can unintentionally block traditional podcast ad revenue streams When baked‑in ads make sense and when they don’t

Platform Control & Algorithm Shifts How YouTube and Spotify are shaping video podcasting for their own monetisation goals Why relying on a single platform’s algorithm is risky for podcasters

Championing Audio‑First Audio as an escape from screens and the pace of short‑form, addictive content Why long‑form, relationship‑driven podcasting is still a competitive advantage

Tools & Workflow Essentials ChatGPT for content ideas (without losing your own voice) Adobe Enhance for audio cleanup Canva for quick visual creation Why reliable gear you know well often beats the latest shiny tech

The Growing Complexity of Podcasting How the industry has changed from the “simpler days” Balancing innovation with making podcasting accessible for new creators

Hope you enjoy the conversion and make sure you... Check out: PodCraft & The Podcast Host Check out: The Indie Podcasters Survey EPISODE CREDITS: Hosts: Rachel Corbett & Matthew McLean LINKS & OTHER...

More from PodSchool

Dec 14, 2025

If you’re thinking about starting a podcast next year, this episode is about slowing down before you press record. I share the key questions you need to ask yourself before launching, why success in podcasting looks very different depending on your goals, and why a thoughtful, well-crafted show will always outperform something rushed or trend-chasing. This episode is for anyone who wants to create a podcast they’re proud of, not just something they “give a crack” and abandon six months later. In this episode, I cover: Why success in podcasting isn’t one-size-fits-all How to define success metrics that actually work for your life and goals Why high-quality, well-considered shows are more important than ever Whether it’s “too late” to start a podcast (spoiler: it’s not) The questions every new podcaster should answer before they begin

Dec 7, 2025

This episode is a year in review for podcasters who feel like they have spent 2025 being told video is everything and AI will save them. I break down what actually mattered this year, where creators are feeling burned out and what you need to focus on in 2026 so your show is sustainable and worth listening to. What you’ll learn: Why video isn't a silver bullet for podcast growth How to think about YouTube and Spotify video without impacting your audio growth or revenue Smart ways to use AI as an assistant, not a replacement for your voice and ideas Why your audio feed and existing listeners are still the heart of your podcast Why long term consistency will always beat short term spikes and how that should shape your plans for 2026

Nov 30, 2025

Should you release all your podcast episodes at once or drip them out weekly? Binge-dropping feels efficient but it can seriously stunt your podcast audience growth. In this episode, I break down why releasing everything in one go almost always performs worse than a steady weekly rollout and the rare situations where a binge drop does make sense. What you’ll learn: Why binge releases kill your biggest growth engine: consistency How weekly drops boost discoverability, auto-downloads and listener trust Why “Why now?” matters when promoting your show When it’s actually fine to release everything at once The question to ask yourself before choosing a release strategy

Nov 23, 2025

Can paid ads grow your podcast audience? A year ago I would’ve said “no, don't bother.” But after seeing a few campaigns actually convert this year, I’ve changed my answer to… a little. In this episode, I break down why paid ads usually flop, when they can work, and the one thing you absolutely must track before spending a cent. What You’ll Learn Why paid ads rarely convert for podcasters When they can work (and the 3 conditions that matter most) The biggest mistake people make with podcast ads How targeting, creative and tracking make or break your results Why you should never run ads until your podcast foundations are rock solid

Nov 16, 2025

If you’re used to traditional media like TV or radio, it’s easy to assume your podcast will only reach local listeners but that’s not how it works. In this episode, I share how podcasting instantly makes you a global creator, what limits (if any) exist when it comes to reach and why monetisation is usually still local even if your audience isn’t. What you’ll learn: Why your podcast is automatically international the moment you hit publish The difference between radio/TV and podcast distribution How Apple Podcasts and other storefronts curate their local content Why ad monetisation still tends to happen within your home market The mindset shift you need when you realise your audience can come from anywhere

See all episodes →