Show Notes
In Episode 8 of NOT GUILTY — The Craig McLachlan Case, the title captures the central conflict: what happens when someone believes their reputation has been tarnished? Vanessa continues the examination of the final charge laid against Craig McLachlan, focusing on his former friend and colleague known as C1. The episode asks a difficult question — what does it mean when a friendship continues for years after events are later described as misconduct? And what, ultimately, prompted allegations that carried such serious and lasting consequences? This episode explores previously unseen context, including text messages sent to close friends that raise questions about C1's timing and intention. Were these messages related to motive? Attention also turns again to the police investigation itself. Why were certain claims not more deeply tested? What happens when supposed eyewitness accounts shift, evolve, or fail to align with other evidence before the court? Episode 8 confronts one of the most contentious issues in the case: the difference between mistake, exaggeration, and deliberate falsehood. When inconsistencies arise under oath, how are they characterised — and who decides whether a moment becomes a credibility issue, an error, or something more serious? More broadly, the episode reflects on the power of narrative. How do public frameworks and cultural slogans influence the way allegations are received, reported, and remembered? And what happens when a legal outcome does not fully displace a narrative that has already taken hold? This is an episode about friendship, credibility, investigation, and the lasting impact of reputational harm — asking whether the full story is ever heard once a public narrative is established.
Watch the accompanying Unfiltered episode in which Craig McLachlan is interviewed by Michael Cain: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFpXYmtGiSM Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
More from NOT GUILTY - The Craig McLachlan Case
In the final instalment of Season 2 of Unfiltered, Vanessa continues with the allegations and criminal charges Craig McLachlan faced in relation to his former friend and Rocky Horror Show castmate, known as C1.
In Episode 7 of Unfiltered, the criminal charges Craig McLachlan faced in relation to his former friend and Rocky Horror Show castmate, known as C1 are explored in-depth.
In Episode 6 of Unfiltered, Michael Cain continues his conversation with Craig McLachlan, delving into the allegations connected to the 2014 production of The Rocky Horror Show, and the cast member referred to as C3.
In Episode 5 of Unfiltered, Michael Cain continues his conversation with Craig McLachlan, examining the charges and allegations made against him by a cast member of the 2014 Rocky Horror Show, referred to as C2. Vanessa delves into the criminal charge of attempted indecent assault, in which C2 claimed that on the final night of the tour, Craig allegedly knelt onstage in the middle of a song and attempted to kiss her. She stated that she then pushed him over in front of a full house of Rocky Horror fans and fellow cast members. Michael asks Craig to respond to this charge which was eventually thrown out of court, as well as further disturbing and serious allegations made by the same cast member. Vanessa invites listeners to consider whether the Magistrate’s description of C2 as “brave and honest” is appropriate, and questions whether the allegations, which were ultimately discredited in court, could be considered perjury. How can demonstrably false claims be dismissed without consequences? A must listen.
“Those doors would open every night revealing Frank N Furter and the audience would go nuts, and I just had to remind myself that the audience is going nuts for Frank N Furter they’re not going nuts for Craig McLachlan.” — C2