The Athletic FC Podcast

What If... We erased the Messi-Ronaldo era?

The Athletic FC Podcast

Summary

Wayday at Wayfair offers significant discounts of up to 80% on home goods, encouraging consumers to take advantage of the sale before it ends on October 26th. The promotion aims to help customers refresh their living spaces or tackle overdue home projects.

In a recent episode, the discussion shifts to the impact of football legends Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo on the sport. The hosts explore hypothetical scenarios in which neither player existed, focusing on who might have won the Ballon d'Or during that time. They highlight alternative winners such as Fernando Torres, Xavi, and Iniesta, while also contemplating how the absence of these two stars could have altered the football landscape, including the dynamics of clubs like Barcelona and Real Madrid.

The conversation also touches on the individualistic nature of modern football, suggesting that the dominance of Messi and Ronaldo has overshadowed other talents and shaped the way fans engage with the sport. The hosts speculate on how football might have evolved differently, potentially leading to a more team-oriented approach to the game. As the episode concludes, they consider who might win the Ballon d'Or this year, with Harry Kane emerging as a favorite, though they acknowledge the unpredictability of the award.

Show Notes

With the Ballon d'Or fast approaching, this week’s episode of ‘What If’, Emma is joined in the studio by The Athletic’s Tim Spiers, Dan Kilpatrick and Jack Pitt-Brooke to pick apart the unfathomable… What if Messi and Ronaldo didn’t exist?

Who scores their goals? Who’s career skyrockets? And topically, who wins their Ballons d’Or?

Plus, we discuss who we think will be just the 5th player outside of the two main men to win the Ballon d’Or since 2008.

Host: Emma Paton Panelists: Jack Pitt-Brooke, Dan Kilpatrick, Tim Spiers Executive Producers: Adam Jones, Max Curwen Bingley Producer: Mike Stavrou Videographer: Grayson Moody Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from The Athletic FC Podcast

Oct 23, 2026

It’s a jam packed show this week as Kate Mason is joined in the studio by tacticos Liam Tharme and Rob Green to discuss all the weekend’s goings on, including a fierce London derby as Chelsea host rivals Spurs.

Oct 22, 2026

Manchester United’s ownership is in the firing line again, with players accusing leadership of negligence and just two wins so far all season.

Oct 21, 2026

Tuesday saw PSG and Barcelona lock horns at the Parc des Princes as Luis Enrique’s side came out victors despite injuries to key players Ousmane Dembele and Khvicha Kvaratskhelia.

Oct 20, 2026

It's a bumper week in the Champions League with arguably the best four teams in Europe — PSG, Barcelona, Bayern Munich and Arsenal — all facing each other. But who is actually the best side in Europe right now?

Oct 19, 2026

Brighton thumped nearest rivals Crystal Palace on Sunday, taking their tally to an astonishing 34 goals in all competitions already this season.

See all episodes →