Show Notes
THE NICK SHURN MATTER Broadcast: December 1955 Star: Bob Bailey Format: 5‑part serial (this summary reflects the full arc) ⭐ Episode Summary (Spoiler‑Safe) A brutal Michigan blizzard sets the stage for one of Johnny Dollar's most atmospheric and physically demanding investigations. When a woman named Kathy O'Dare and her young daughter Jill disappear from their home in Bramberry, Michigan, the local sheriff fears they've been abducted by Benny Stark, a violent gunman with a long criminal history. But Johnny Dollar isn't convinced. He believes Kathy fled voluntarily — terrified, armed, and heading into the deep woods she knows better than anyone. As the storm worsens, Johnny must race against time, weather, and a dangerous fugitive to find Kathy and Jill before the blizzard claims them. The case becomes a tense wilderness chase involving abandoned cars, hidden cabins, and a confrontation in the snow that pushes Johnny to the edge of exhaustion. When he finally reaches Kathy, he uncovers the truth behind her flight — and the deadly chain of events that brought Benny Stark to her door.
⭐ Key Elements of the Story A Michigan blizzard that becomes a character in its own right
A missing woman and child with a desperate reason for running
A violent fugitive stalking the woods
Johnny Dollar navigating snow‑choked trails, abandoned vehicles, and freezing darkness
A tense cabin confrontation that reveals the truth
A final showdown with Benny Stark that forces Johnny into a fight for survival
⭐ Why This Episode Works This is one of the most visually vivid Johnny Dollar stories — a survival thriller wrapped inside an insurance investigation. Bob Bailey's performance captures the physical strain of battling the storm, the emotional stakes of protecting a mother and child, and the moral weight of confronting a dangerous man in the wilderness. Listeners get: Strong suspense
A harsh, wintry atmosphere
A human story of fear, protection, and desperation
A dramatic, satisfying resolution
It's a standout in the Bailey era for its pacing, tension, and cinematic feel.
⭐ Characters Johnny Dollar — Freelance insurance investigator
Kathy O'Dare — Missing woman hiding from danger
Jill O'Dare — Kathy's young daughter
Benny Stark — Gunman with a violent past
Mike — Friend of Kathy, emotionally invested in her safety
Deputy Dan Martin — Local law enforcement assisting the search
⭐ Atmosphere Snow. Darkness. Wind. Isolation. This is Johnny Dollar in one of his most physically grueling cases — a story where nature is as deadly as the gunman he's hunting.
⭐ Credits Written and narrated by Jon Hagadorn Produced by 1001 Stories Network LLC Website: www.bestof1001stories.com
⭐ Support the Show If you enjoy 1001 Radio Days and our continuing run of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, please leave a review and share the show. Your support keeps these classic radio dramas alive.
Get all of our shows at one website: WWW.BESTOF1001STORIES.COM REVIEWS NEEDED . My email works as well for comments: [email protected] SUPPORT OUR SHOW BY BECOMING A PATRON! https://.patreon.com/1001storiesnetwork. Its time I started asking for support! Thank you. Its a few dollars a month OR a one time. (Any amount is appreciated). YOUR REVIEWS ARE NEEDED AND APPRECIATED! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
More from 1001 RADIO DAYS
⭐ Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar THE ALVIN'S ALFRED MATTER Original Air Date: July 19, 1959 Starring: Bob Bailey Writer/Director: Jack Johnstone Supporting Cast: Virginia Gregg, Lawrence Dobkin, Harry Bartell, Jack Kruschen Summary Johnny Dollar is assigned to investigate the suspicious death of Alvin Alfred, a quiet, seemingly harmless man who was found dead under circumstances that don't add up. Alvin carried a modest life‑insurance policy, but the company believes foul play may be involved — and that someone close to him may have engineered his death for profit. Johnny's investigation uncovers a tangle of deceit involving a manipulative woman, a forged signature, and a carefully staged accident designed to look natural. As he digs deeper, Johnny realizes Alvin Alfred was targeted precisely because he seemed like the last man anyone would murder. The case becomes a study in how greed can turn the most unassuming life into a deadly opportunity.
⭐ Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar THE BOLT OUT OF THE BLUE MATTER Original Air Date: July 26, 1959 Starring: Bob Bailey Writer/Director: Jack Johnstone Supporting Cast: Virginia Gregg, Carlton G. Young, Ralph Moody, James McCallion Summary Johnny Dollar is dispatched to the storm‑swept Massachusetts coast after Thelma Jane Weatherby reports that her uncle, retired sea captain Amos Weatherby, is in mortal danger. She believes her former fiancé, Roger Burton — a man Captain Amos once exposed as a "wife killer" — has returned to make good on his threat of revenge. As a violent storm rolls in, Johnny discovers Burton's elaborate murder setup: an old stone blockhouse once used as a sailing‑ship jail, now housing power company transformers. Burton plans to lure the captain inside and electrocute him by throwing a remote switch that energizes a metal railing. But nature intervenes. A lightning bolt strikes the tower's rod, surges down the wire, and detonates the installation — killing Burton instantly and leaving Johnny shaken but alive. With the threat ended, Johnny files his expense account (totaling $171.50) and signs off with his trademark closing: "End of report… Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar."
1. "The Jack Madigan Matter " Release Date: October 21, 1950. [1] Cast: Stars Edmond O'Brien as Johnny Dollar. [1] Basic Summary: The Assignment: Johnny is hired by a panicked local bail bondsman who finds himself in an impossible legal jam. The Disappearance: Two crucial federal witnesses scheduled to testify against a notorious, dangerous gangster named Jack Madigan have completely vanished into thin air. The Stakes: The bondsman was pressured into putting up the bond money for them by Madigan's associates. Johnny must navigate a dark web of underworld intimidation to locate the witnesses before Madigan can silence them for good. [1, 2, 3]
. "The Sudden Wealth Matter " Release Date: December 13, 1959. Cast: Stars Bob Bailey as freelance insurance investigator Johnny Dollar. Basic Summary: Johnny is called from Hartford to investigate a rash of sudden, suspicious life insurance policy cancellations. He tracks the thread to a corrupt, sweet-talking broker who is targeting unsuspecting locals. The broker convinces these individuals to liquidate their stable insurance assets to invest in a sketchy stock market scheme that falsely promises to "double their money" in less than three weeks. Johnny must expose the financial fraud and the sheer greed driving the operation before the racketeer vanishes with the victims' life savings. [1, 2, 3]
⭐ 1001 RADIO DAYS Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar SHOW NOTES — "The Story of the Big Red Schoolhouse Matter" & "The Dead First Helpers Matter" This week at 1001 Radio Days, we bring you two powerful back‑to‑back investigations from the early Edmond O'Brien era of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar — stories that showcase the grit, danger, and moral complexity that made the 1950 run one of the most compelling in the series.