[EP 412] Metallica: The Best, Worst & Most Overrated Albums with Martin Popoff
Booked On Rock with Eric SenichShow Notes
Metallica’s journey from underground thrash pioneers to the biggest metal band in the world is one of the most remarkable stories in rock history. In this episode of Booked On Rock, acclaimed rock author and historian Martin Popoff returns to discuss his new book, Metallica: Album by Album, and take a critical look at the records that defined—and sometimes divided—the band’s audience.
We go album by album through Metallica’s career, from the raw aggression of Kill ’Em All and the breakthrough songwriting of Ride the Lightning to Master of Puppets, …And Justice for All, and the massive commercial transformation of 1991’s Metallica (The Black Album). Martin explains why he prefers Ride the Lightning to Master of Puppets, questions whether the Black Album deserves its towering reputation, and discusses how Cliff Burton’s death changed the band’s story.
We also tackle the controversial Load and Reload era, Bob Rock’s influence, the much-maligned St. Anger, Metallica’s return to thrash on Death Magnetic, and the band’s later work on Hardwired… to Self-Destruct and 72 Seasons. Martin offers his takes on Lars Ulrich’s drumming, Kirk Hammett, James Hetfield’s extraordinary riff writing, Metallica’s willingness to change, and whether some of those changes crossed the line into “selling out.”
Plus, Martin reveals his picks for Metallica’s best and worst albums, most underrated and overrated records, best post-Black Album material, and the five songs he’d give someone discovering Metallica for the first time.
If you’re a Metallica fan—or simply fascinated by how four musicians took thrash metal from the underground to stadiums around the world—this is a deep dive into more than four decades of Metallica history.
Purchase a copy of Metallica: Album by Album
Visit Martin Popoff's website
----------
🎧 Listen/Watch Ad-Free on Patreon Support Booked On Rock and get every new episode completely commercial-free with the Backstage Pass. Join here: https://www.patreon.com/cw/BookedOnRock
🛒 Old Glory - Iconic music and sports fan merch 💰 Get 15% OFF | Promo Code: BOOKEDONROCK https://oldglory.com/discount/BOOKEDONROCK
Booked On Rock is part of The Boneless Podcasting Network
BookedOnRock.com
The Booked On Rock Store
The Booked On Rock YouTube Channel
Follow The Booked On Rock with Eric Senich: BLUESKY FACEBOOK INSTAGRAM TIKTOK X
Find Your Nearest Independent Bookstore
Contact The Booked On Rock Podcast: [email protected]
The Booked On Rock Music: “Whoosh” by Crowander / “Last Train North” & “No Mercy” by TrackTribe
More from Booked On Rock with Eric Senich
Howard Stern’s relationships with rock stars produced unforgettable interviews, unlikely friendships, and plenty of fallout. Author Greg Prato returns to Booked On Rock to discuss his book, The Great American Nightmare: An Oral History of the Howard Stern Show, and Stern’s influence on rock music.
What if one of the most influential drumbeats in music history came from a musician who never received the recognition—or compensation—he deserved?
How did Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, and Alice in Chains transform Seattle’s underground music scene into a worldwide rock revolution?
Can a song really change the world? Author Andrew Clarke joins Booked On Rock to explore the stories behind some of rock music’s most influential songs and how they became connected to political upheaval, social change, cultural rebellion, war, protest, and entire generations.
Who was “Mr. Jones,” and how did Monica Potter help save “Mrs. Potter’s Lullaby”? Author Geoff Harkness returns to Booked On Rock to explore the surprising stories behind Counting Crows’ songs, drawing from his book Counting Crows: The Story of Every Song.