Summary
Ireland's legal landscape faces scrutiny as discussions arise over whether the country has an excess of lawyers and the implications this has on societal progress. The conversation centers on the influence of lawyers within the legal profession and their role in shaping public policy, often prioritizing process over outcomes. Critics argue that this lawyer-centric approach can hinder effective governance and reform, particularly in areas like construction and public administration, where lengthy legal procedures delay necessary developments.
The dialogue draws comparisons between Ireland's common law system and the more efficient civil law systems found in other European countries, suggesting that Ireland's reliance on legal processes contributes to inefficiencies. Observers note that the political landscape often favors quick legislative fixes—changing laws rather than addressing underlying social issues—leading to a culture where legal solutions are preferred over practical governance.
The discussion also highlights the need for a shift towards a more engineering-focused approach to governance, advocating for a public service that emphasizes results and accountability over mere compliance with legal procedures. This shift would require political leadership willing to decentralize power and enhance local governance capacities, ultimately aiming to create a more responsive and effective state that can better serve its citizens.
Show Notes
Ireland tends to take a legalistic approach to our problems, but is this holding us back? We talk the impacts of taking a legal approach to problems and talk about what changing it might look like.
Hosted by Keire Murphy and Aidan Regan.
Questions or feedback? [email protected]
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@GetShtDonePod Patreon: https://patreon.com/GetShitDonePodcast Substack: https://getshitdonepod.substack.com/ Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
More from Get Shit Done
Last week, we talked about Ireland's public finances, the political wrangling that happens around them every year, and the stories we tell about them that aren't true. But does that miss a more important story - all the things that we could fix without spending any extra money? Are we just throwing money at problems instead of fixing their root cause? Keire talks to Seán Keyes who talks about some things we could fix for free that would have a big impact on Ireland's big problems.
It's budget season, and that means one thing: a lot of analysis saying that Irish public spending is out of control, and that we're spending too much. But Ireland is the lowest spender in the EU, so how can that be true? What's fact and what's ideology in the analysis we all hear? And what's actually wrong with Irish public finances?
Ireland effectively has two economies: the international economy, where wages and purchasing power is higher, and the domestic economy, where wages are lower. Some of the international economy is real, and some of it is fake - but we are highly dependent on it. This creates major social and governance challenges.
Getting shit done means having the people to do it. But the Irish civil service is a bit of a black box. In this episode, we talk about how the civil service works, its strengths and weaknesses, and how it could work better.
Dermot McCarthy has held two of the three most senior roles in the civil service: Secretary General to the Government of Ireland and Secretary General of the Department of An Taoiseach. He played a significant role in the social partnership process, and previously served as the director of the National Economic and Social Council. He retired in 2011.