Best of the Giants on WFAN: McCarthy gets the start

The New York Giants are set to start J.J. McCarthy at quarterback against the Houston Texans, a decision that has sparked considerable debate among fans and analysts. This move comes as the Giants sit atop the NFC East with a 3-2-1 record, leading some to question the rationale behind switching from Jameis Winston, who has experience and has contributed to the team's success this season.

Critics argue that McCarthy, who has limited NFL experience and struggled during his time with the Minnesota Vikings, may not be the best choice to lead the team in a critical game against a formidable Texans defense. Supporters, however, believe that McCarthy's mobility and potential for big plays could provide a much-needed spark for the Giants' offense, which has struggled to find consistency.

Head coach John Harbaugh is expected to address the media soon, and many are eager to hear his reasoning behind the decision. As the Giants prepare for this pivotal matchup, the focus will be on whether McCarthy can rise to the occasion and prove that he is capable of leading the team to victory, or if the decision will backfire and raise further questions about the team's quarterback strategy moving forward.

J.J. McCarthy has been named the starting quarterback against the Texans, and Craig Carton RIPS the "panicky, ridiculously stupid" move by John Harbaugh to make a QB change while in first place. Plus, Tiki Barber questions if McCarthy is being put in a position to succeed given Houston's defense and his newness to the offense, while Boomer Esiason is not surprised that the switch was made at this time.