The Library of Mistakes

EP 62: Kaboom! Does history show that market valuations for AI are nuts?

The Library of Mistakes

Show Notes

LIVE RECORDING Welcome to a special episode of the podcast recorded live at the Library of Mistakes and featuring a debate between two distinguished former investment practitioners – Andrew Milligan and Sandy Nairn.

The question they debate is: 'Does history shows that current market valuations for AI are nuts?'

Andrew, with his experience as a global strategist over many years, believes their value might be overextended, while Sandy, with his keen knowledge of technology, believes AI could herald a seismic change that might justify some of the excitement.

Listen in and join in the fun, ably hosted by Robbie Mochrie and compered by David Clarke, with plenty of lively contributions from the floor.

You can also watch this debate on our YouTube channel, as well as many other fascinating lectures.

More from The Library of Mistakes

Oct 19, 2026

Join Robbie Mochrie, organiser of our upcoming Weekend Of AI, in conversation with Eve Poole (author of Robot Souls) and Vladimir Maltsev (an ecomomist at the Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow). Eve and Vladimir are two of the expert speakers taking part in this exciting three-day event. In this episode, they offer provocative insights into what the rapid advance of AI may mean for students in particular. Recommended listening!

Oct 14, 2026

Join Russell Napier in conversation with FT journalist Robin Wigglesworth discussing his fascinating new book on the history of bonds – A Fabulous Debt: The Epic Story of How Bonds Built the Modern World.

Oct 9, 2026

Join Robbie Mochrie, organiser of our upcoming Weekend Of AI, in conversation with Chris Stokel-Walker (tech journalist and author of several books, including How AI Ate The World) and Ellie Howard (a commercial and financial operator who specialises in building and scaling technology businesse). Chris and Ellie are two of the expert speakers taking part in this exciting three-day event. In this episode, they offer fascinating insights into what the rapid advance of AI may mean for finance, business and society at large. Recommended listening!

Sep 11, 2026

It's back-to-school time for everyone at Library of Mistakes, Future Asset and Leavers' Money Skills. David Clarke, CEO of Didasko (which runs these three wonderful charities) is back from his summer holidays and brimming with enthusiasm as he looks forward to our autumn events. But first, we're excited to introduce you to our new Librarian, Emily Holmes. Discover what's already caught Emily's eye on the Library of Mistakes bookshelves, what her plans are and why she's no stranger to an ice cream scoop. Presented and produced by Fraser Allen & Leila Johnston. www.libraryofmistakes.com

Aug 17, 2026

Many of our listeners are interested in what financial history can tell us about the returns of financial assets – and particularly of equities. We are therefore delighted as Sandy Nairn and Michael O’Connell join Russell Napier to discuss their new paper for the University of Strathclyde – ‘What Does Shareholder Wealth Creation Tell Investors?’. Michael is an Accountancy and Finance Researcher at the University of Strathclyde. Sandy is Executive Director of Global Opportunities Trust plc, and was previously Chairman of Templeton Global Equity Group and Chief Investment Officer of Scottish Widows Investment Partnership. You can download the full report here: www.libraryofmistakes.com/blog/what-does-shareholder-wealth-creation-tell-investors

See all episodes →