Forgive Me!

3.10 || Mental Gymnastics

Forgive Me!

Show Notes

Olivia and Emily have a frank conversation over late-night pancakes at Pat’s Diner. Produced by Rogue Dialogue Productions (roguedialogue.com) Written and directed by Jack Marone and Bob Raymonda Cast:

Josh Rubino as Fr. Klem

Casey Callaghan as Fr. Ben

Graham Rowat as Pat

Emily Elizabeth as Olivia

Caroline Mincks as Emily

Michael Larkin as Joe

Sarah Rhea Werner as Darla

Jeffrey Nils Gardener as Clinic Escort

Bob Frame as Roger

Michael Antico as Brett

Bob Raymonda as Protestor

Adam Raymonda as Protestor

Jack Marone as Protestor

Sensitivity reading by Jay Griffin. Script editing by Jordan Stillman. Dialogue editing by Bob Raymonda. Sound design and score by Adam Raymonda. Logo by Sam Twardy (www.samtwardy.com) Follow @ForgiveMeShow on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Find a transcript of the episode here. Donate to the Midwest Access Coalition here. For early access to episodes and bonus content, become a patron at patreon.com/roguedialogue Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Forgive Me!

Oct 16, 2026

Tom takes on a seemingly impossible challenge in order to prepare for the birth of his daughter.

Oct 16, 2026

Fr. Ben & Fr. Klem attend the unveiling of the new Armada of Amerigo building and bump into Bishop Marino.

Oct 11, 2026

This season on Forgive Me, Fr. Ben gets back to basics.

Oct 9, 2026

Forgive Me! Season 4 will return on Friday, October 16 with a 2 episode premiere. In the meantime, take a trip back through our series’ history in order to catch yourself up before we’re back! Or, you know, get caught up even if you’ve never heard us before. You do you.

Oct 4, 2026

Hello St. Patrick Parishioners! Adam here! Season 4 of Forgive Me is almost ready to be released out in the world. We’re gearing up for the launch of the season by releasing some episodes of Confessions with Klem, a previously Patreon-exclusive mini series that accompanied Season 3 of the show. This series follows everyone’s favorite nihilistic donut-loving priest Klem into the St. Patrick's confessional to chat with a variety of parishioners we have and have not met before.

See all episodes →