Summary
In this series, Julie Bendel discusses the rise of extreme transgender ideology and its impact on society, particularly focusing on the implications for women and children. She has campaigned for forty years against men's violence toward women and highlights her concerns about how current developments in gender politics intersect with her feminist activism.
Bendel interviews Dr. Asher Hunky, a psychiatrist who has specialized in treating adults with gender dysphoria through psychotherapy since 2000. Dr. Hunky shares his experiences within the psychiatric field, addressing the stigma and accusations of transphobia he has faced for his views.
Dr. Hunky emphasizes the need for critical thinking and the importance of understanding the underlying issues faced by individuals who express gender dysphoria. He argues that many of these individuals might be grappling with other psychological problems, such as autism or trauma, and that labeling their feelings as being in the "wrong body" can lead to harmful solutions. He likens the treatment of gender dysphoria to anorexia, noting that both disorders involve a significant disconnect between a person's perception and reality.
The discussion also touches on the role of social workers and educational institutions in influencing children's gender identities. Dr. Hunky raises concerns about how young people may be led into believing they are not their biological sex, particularly if they do not fit societal norms related to gender expression.
Bendel and Dr. Hunky highlight the normalization of surgical interventions for transgender individuals, critiquing the lack of rigorous psychological assessments and the potential long-term consequences of these procedures. They express skepticism about the narrative that transitioning, whether through hormones or surgery, is a universally positive experience.
The conversation delves into the implications of parental involvement in these choices, with Dr. Hunky noting the pressures parents face and the implications of labeling dissent as transphobia. Various statistical trends regarding referrals to gender clinics are discussed, raising questions about the motivations behind children seeking transition.
Both Bendel and Dr. Hunky advocate for a more cautious approach toward gender identity issues, arguing for more thorough investigations into the mental health conditions that often accompany gender dysphoria rather than quick affirmations through medical intervention. They call for a societal shift that prioritizes evidence-based treatments and encourages open discussions about these complex issues without fear of backlash.
Overall, the series critiques the current state of gender identity discourse, emphasizing its ramifications on mental health, societal norms, and the well-being of children.
Show Notes
Growing up in remote North Wales was a formative experience for consultant psychiatrist Dr Az Hakeem. Being an outsider served him well when he faced homophobia as a clinician and then false accusations of transphobia. The author of DETRANS: When Transition is Not the Solution tells Julie why he thinks so many clinicians have let down vulnerable children and young people. Writer: Julie Bindel Producer: Samantha Smith Artwork: Nicole Jones Actor: Joe Fattorini Animations: Sarah Vaci (Lordy) SOURCES OF INFORMATION, ADVICE, AND SUPPORT The final report of the Cass Independent Review is referenced throughout the series. You can read it here. The LGB Alliance has a support line if you are 13 – 24 and want to explore your feelings and discuss your experiences in a warm, judgment-free space. The live-chat service is open between 3pm and 6pm on Tuesdays and between 4pm and 7pm on Thursdays. Send them an email at any other time and they’ll get back to you within 48 hours. Our Duty is an international support network for parents who wish to protect their children from gender ideology. They’ll put you in touch with other parents who want to protect their children from harm.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit juliebindel.substack.com/subscribe
More from JULIE IN GENDERLAND
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit juliebindel.substack.com
I meet more parents in despair as their teenage children are egged on by clinics and institutions to a lifelong pathway of drugs and surgery. Writer: Julie Bindel Producer: Samantha Smith Artwork: Nicole Jones Actor: Joe Fattorini Animations: Sarah Vaci (Lordy) SOURCES OF INFORMATION, ADVICE, AND SUPPORT The final report of the Cass Independent Review is referenced throughout the series. You can read it here. The LGB Alliance has a support line if you are 13 – 24 and want to explore your feelings and discuss your experiences in a warm, judgment-free space. The live-chat service is open between 3pm and 6pm on Tuesdays and between 4pm and 7pm on Thursdays. Send them an email at any other time and they’ll get back to you within 48 hours. Our Duty is an international support network for parents who wish to protect their children from gender ideology. They’ll put you in touch with other parents who want to protect their children from harm.
As a teenager, Sam* suffered lesbophobic bullying. Then Sam’s dad got a leaflet from the school urging him to accept his daughter as a boy who might need medication and, one day, surgery. The pair tell me what happened next. *pseudonym Writer: Julie Bindel Producer: Samantha Smith Artwork: Nicole Jones Actor: Joe Fattorini Animations: Sarah Vaci (Lordy) SOURCES OF INFORMATION, ADVICE, AND SUPPORT The final report of the Cass Independent Review is referenced throughout the series. You can read it here. The LGB Alliance has a support line if you are 13 – 24 and want to explore your feelings and discuss your experiences in a warm, judgment-free space. The live-chat service is open between 3pm and 6pm on Tuesdays and between 4pm and 7pm on Thursdays. Send them an email at any other time and they’ll get back to you within 48 hours. Our Duty is an international support network for parents who wish to protect their children from gender ideology. They’ll put you in touch with other parents who want to protect their children from harm.
In this episode, I investigate how schools have become a breeding ground for ideologically-driven ideas which have encouraged children and young people to believe in the false notion that they can change sex. Parents tell me about the extent of legal confusion and hostility to parents who’ve challenged pseudoscience in the classroom. Writer: Julie Bindel Producer: Samantha Smith Artwork: Nicole Jones Actor: Joe Fattorini Animations: Sarah Vaci (Lordy) SOURCES OF INFORMATION, ADVICE, AND SUPPORT The final report of the Cass Independent Review is referenced throughout the series. You can read it here. The LGB Alliance has a support line if you are 13 – 24 and want to explore your feelings and discuss your experiences in a warm, judgment-free space. The live-chat service is open between 3pm and 6pm on Tuesdays and between 4pm and 7pm on Thursdays. Send them an email at any other time and they’ll get back to you within 48 hours. Our Duty is an international support network for parents who wish to protect their children from gender ideology. They’ll put you in touch with other parents who want to protect their children from harm.
Julie Bindel heads to Brighton to meet parents and campaigners in conflict with their local authority over its policies on single sex spaces. They’re asking “what now?” following a change of government and the landmark Cass report which blew apart the scandal of an unwarranted social and medical experiment on children. Writer: Julie Bindel Producer: Samantha Smith Artwork: Nicole Jones Actor: Joe Fattorini Animations: Sarah Vaci (Lordy) SOURCES OF INFORMATION, ADVICE, AND SUPPORT The final report of the Cass Independent Review is referenced throughout the series. You can read it here. The LGB Alliance has a support line if you are 13 – 24 and want to explore your feelings and discuss your experiences in a warm, judgment-free space. The live-chat service is open between 3pm and 6pm on Tuesdays and between 4pm and 7pm on Thursdays. Send them an email at any other time and they’ll get back to you within 48 hours. Our Duty is an international support network for parents who wish to protect their children from gender ideology. They’ll put you in touch with other parents who want to protect their children from harm.