When Reality Hits with Brittany Cartwright

Red Flags & Toxic Men with Natalie Cruz

When Reality Hits with Brittany Cartwright

Show Notes

This week on When Reality Hits, reality TV star Natalie Cruz joins the podcast for a brutally honest conversation about everything that went down on Temptation Island and her return to Netflix’s Perfect Match. Natalie opens up about the infamous Grant drama, the viral shower scene, cheating allegations, toxic relationship cycles, online hate, death threats, and the wild reality of seeing your love life edited for television. She also reveals what viewers didn’t get to see behind the scenes, why she says she “did her job well,” and how reality TV completely changed her life. Plus, Natalie talks red flags, love bombing, bad kissers, reality dating show chaos, and why Perfect Match finally let fans see the real her

Please support the show by checking out our sponsors! Merit Beauty: Merit Beauty is offering our listeners their Signature Makeup Bag with your first order at meritbeauty.com ARMRA Colostrum: Go to armra.com/REALITY or enter REALITY to get 30% off your first subscription order Progressive: Quote your car insurance at Progressive.com to join the over 28 million drivers who trust Progressive See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from When Reality Hits with Brittany Cartwright

Oct 16, 2026

Brittany sits down with Dominique Garrett, founder of Bitter Baby Daddy Club, to talk about leaving an unhealthy relationship, navigating single motherhood and co-parenting, setting boundaries, and finding happiness after heartbreak. Dominique also shares how she built a community to support single moms and why sometimes it’s about the wrong partner, but the right child. www.instagram.com/bitterbabydaddyclub/

Oct 9, 2026

This week, Brittany is joined by Janet Caperna to relive their unforgettable girls' trip to Miami! They dish on the wild adventures, the unique characters they met, and the reality stars they partied with. Plus, they open up about why moms deserve a getaway, how they handle Instagram trolls, and answer burning fan questions. Originally aired: 03/28/25

Oct 2, 2026

Brittany sits down with her longtime friend Kristen Doute for a fun and candid catch-up about reality TV, friendship, motherhood, and everything that has changed since their early days in the spotlight. Kristen looks back on the Miami Girl drama, shares what reality TV has taught her about being authentic, and reflects on how much she has grown since her Vanderpump Rules days. The two also swap stories about their friendship, motherhood, embarrassing moments, crazy DMs, and more. Plus, Kristen opens up about becoming a mom, her new podcast, and what’s next.

Sep 25, 2026

Serena Kerrigan joins When Reality Hits to talk all things dating, confidence, and knowing your worth. Serena opens up about the dating lessons she learned from being ghosted, breadcrumbed, love bombed, and chasing emotionally unavailable men, and how that experience inspired her new book, Let's F*cking Date. She and Brittany dive into the “do-over era,” dating in Los Angeles after a long-term relationship, expanding your dating pool, recognizing when someone is actually making an effort, and why you shouldn’t settle for someone who isn’t showing up for you. Plus, Serena shares how her infamous Instagram Live dating show during COVID led to a million-person community, a card game, and ultimately her new book.

Sep 18, 2026

Zack Wickham spills the tea on reality TV, from keeping secrets about upcoming cast appearances to accidentally throwing a wrench into a reality TV timeline. He also looks back on his most embarrassing hair era, shares some of the ridiculous arguments he’s had on vacation, talks about his reputation for being the person everyone tells their secrets to, and reveals the unexpected story behind his new Celsius fridge.

See all episodes →