Unsolved Mysteries

The Cold-Blooded Murder of Chelsea Small

Unsolved Mysteries

Show Notes

On November 12, 2013, Chelsea Small, 30, agrees to trade shifts with another co-worker at Advance America Cash Advance. Around noon, a man enters and guns down Chelsea, who is working behind her desk. Was Chelsea targeted? Was this a random killing? Or could this be a case of mistaken identity? Security footage and spent shell casings are among the clues to the murderer’s identity, but Chelsea’s killer has yet to be brought to justice.

More from Unsolved Mysteries

Oct 20, 2026

The Unsolved Mysteries podcast is back with all-new original episodes!  Join host Jordan Murphy each week as he explores mysterious murders, strange disappearances, wanted fugitives, unexplained deaths, and updates on past cases. From the original creators of the iconic television series, presented by Audacy. Because someone knows the truth.

Oct 23, 2024

There has been a new development in Season 1: Episode 35, Recruiter on the Run, regarding fugitive John Blauvelt.

Jan 10, 2024

There has been a new development in Season 2: Episode 75 regarding the arrests of Amy and Ross Vilardi.

Oct 18, 2023

There has been a new development in Season 1: Episode 15, regarding fugitive Eric Arceneaux.

Aug 9, 2023

There have been new developments in two of our episodes: Adam Doe (Season 1, Episode 11) has been identified, and Alicia Navarro (Season 2, Episode 69) has come forward.

See all episodes →