The ESPN Footy Podcast

Red Time: Peaking too early is a footy myth; Carlton’s strange problem

The ESPN Footy Podcast

Show Notes

This week on Red Time, JB and Coxy debate whether ‘peaking too early’ is real as Fremantle continues its dominant start to the season. The boys also discuss Carlton's unusual draft dilemma, why the AFL got spooked into changing the ARC score review process, and whether clubs should stop selling home games. Plus, should Essendon hire the best coach available, or the person best placed to galvanise a struggling club?

00:00:00 - Intro

00:01:17 - Josh Treacy didn’t get the memo

00:02:07 - Start, Bench, Drop: Winning is doing Carlton no favours right now

00:07:55 - The AFL got spooked into changing the ARC process

00:13:15 - There’s no such thing as ‘peaking too early’

00:18:34 - The right coach isn't always the 'best' coach

00:23:32 - Four premiership points are worth more than a cash injection

00:27:25 - Hot Stat Checklist, powered by StatMate

00:31:30 - Don’t Be Surprised If… Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The ESPN Footy Podcast

Sep 27, 2026

The duality of footy ... the 2026 AFL Grand Final was a harrowing, living nightmare for Fremantle fans and players, but unbridled ecstasy and jubilation for Lions players and fans as they completed the threepeat. We break it ALL down here.

Sep 23, 2026

This week on Red Time, JB and Mason preview the 2026 Grand Final as Freo prepare to take on Brisbane for a shot at the club’s first premiership. Coxy also discusses his unique Grand Final experience, Freo’s finals form, Brisbane’s attacking firepower, and what it takes to handle the biggest game of the season. Plus, the boys debate in-game activations with the AFL preventing ‘Wharfie Time’ from being used, the pre-finals bye, Taylor Walker’s perfect retirement move, and more.

Sep 21, 2026

This week, there's almost too much to talk about! From Friday night's amazing comeback and Hayden Young's clutch effort for the Dockers, to the Jarman Impey decision, Lachie Neale ban, James Sicily's conduct, and Nick Watson ... that's before we even preview the Grand Final!

Sep 16, 2026

This week on Red Time, JB and Coxy dive into the biggest talking points, including whether prelims are actually harder to win than Grand Finals, the AFL’s potential plans to shorten matches, and what Zak Butters’ arrival means for the Bulldogs. Plus, the boys debate Pat Voss’ set-shot time management, the timing of last week’s Wharfie Time activation, and look ahead to this week’s huge finals clashes with the Hot Stat Checklist.

Sep 14, 2026

On the ESPN Footy Podcast, the team breaks down Fremantle and Brisbane's wins and grade the seasons of Adelaide and Geelong. Plus Champion Data's preliminary final previews, Chris Scott punching the 'wall', Zak Butters, a day Grand Final and a LOT more!

See all episodes →