Show Notes
On 15 September 2023, armed police forced their way into a house in the Essex village of Great Baddow. Inside, Virginia McCullough calmly told officers she was a double murderer, and showed them where to find her parents' bodies. She had kept them both hidden for more than four years. In this episode, forensic psychologist Kerry Daynes examines how a full-time carer stole from, deceived and killed the elderly parents who depended on her. She also explains how the killer then managed to keep up the pretence that her victims were still alive.
In this episode The police raid and the extraordinary bodycam footage of McCullough's arrest and confession Life in a close-knit village, and how Virginia appeared to those around her How she gained control of her parents' finances, and where the money went The fake texts and phone calls to her sisters, and the phone records that exposed them The GP surgery staff whose "professional curiosity" led to a welfare check The planning and events of June 2019 How she hid the bodies and carried on as normal The court case, the judge's sentencing remarks, and the life sentence with a minimum term of 36 years
Kerry's psychological insights Why McCullough seemed so calm and matter-of-fact when police arrived, and what lay behind her closing remark to the officers How lies, debt and an out-of-control gambling addiction can trap someone Why Kerry sees this story as one of domestic abuse: financial abuse, gaslighting and, finally, lethal violence Why McCullough's claim that she felt "trapped" by caring for her parents doesn't hold up
Featuring Kerry Daynes, forensic psychologist and presenter Graham Bartlett, crime author and former Detective Superintendent Matt Lee, journalist, Essex Live Debbie Pollard and Rachel Murray, who ran the village flower shop Content note: This episode deals with murder, financial and domestic abuse of elderly people, and addiction. Listener discretion is advised.
OFFERS FROM OUR PARTNERS Can YOU tell when someone is lying? Dr Cliff Lansley can. He's the world-renowned expert behind the Six Channels Analysis System (SCAnS), a model Kerry uses when studying criminal behaviour. His team at EmotionIntell has created SCAnS Online, a course that teaches the skills of human behaviour analysis. It features real-world case studies and tutoring from Cliff, and you can complete it at home at your own pace. Listeners get 10% off the normal price at emotionintell.com/theprofiler. Enter the discount code theprofiler.
Go deeper with Audible If you enjoy exploring the psychology behind these cases, Audible has a huge selection of true crime books, including a couple of Kerry's own. Sign up for a free 30-day trial at theprofiler.co.uk/audible and help support the podcast in the process.
Stay in touch Website and weekly email: theprofiler.co.uk Follow Kerry Daynes on all social media platforms, or via her Substack, which has articles to go with nearly every Profiler episode If you enjoy the show, please follow or subscribe, leave a five-star rating or review, and share it with fellow true crime fans The Profiler with Kerry Daynes is a Shearwater Media and Heromedia production. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
More from The Profiler with Kerry Daynes
In December 1996, the Midlands was gripped by what looked like a "road rage" murder. Lee Harvey, 25, was stabbed to death on a quiet country lane. His fiancée, Tracie Andrews, bruised and battered, appeared before the cameras to describe a crazed stranger with "mad, starey eyes." But the story began to fall apart. In this episode, forensic psychologist Kerry Daynes examines how Andrews built a seemingly perfect cover story, performed it for the nation, and was then found out.
On the night of March 3rd, 2021, during the Covid lockdown, 33-year-old Sarah Everard was walking home from a friend's house in south London. She never arrived. Days later, detectives raced the last person seen with her to one of their own: a serving Metropolitan Police officer named Wayne Couzens. In this episode, forensic psychologist Kerry Daynes pieces together Sarah's final journey and examines the failings that let her killer hide in plain sight inside Britain's biggest police force.
In January 2006, police in Hopkinton, Massachusetts found the bodies of 27-year-old Rachel Entwistle and her nine-month-old daughter Lillian. They were lying in bed, arm in arm, shot at close range. Rachel's British husband, Neil Entwistle, was already 3,000 miles away. In this episode, forensic psychologist Kerry Daynes profiles a man who seemed to have it all, but who had actually built his life on lies.
In November 2011, 84-year-old Betty Guy died at her home in Johnston, Pembrokeshire. Her daughter, Penny John, called 999 to say her mother had passed away after a battle with cancer. A doctor certified natural causes, and Betty was cremated four days later. Nobody suspected a thing. Then, four years later, police received a call out of the blue. An ex-partner of Betty's grandson, Barry Rogers, claimed he had admitted to suffocating his grandmother with a pillow. Other former partners told detectives the same story. In this episode, forensic psychologist Kerry Daynes looks at how what should have been the perfect crime unravelled. She also asks what the evidence reveals about the two people at its centre, and why Rogers couldn't keep quiet about it.
This episode features world-renowned body language expert Dr Cliff Lansley, director of the Emotional Intelligence Academy. For his online course on human behaviour and how to spot the signs of deception go to www.emotionintell.com/theprofiler