Why the agency model is in decline and how independents can win, with Michael Farmer
Creative Agency Account Manager PodcastShow Notes
Welcome to episode 158. I’m joined again by Michael Farmer to unpack what’s really going on in the agency world right now - and what it means for you if you’re running an agency, leading clients, or working in account management.
Michael Farmer is Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Farmer & Company LLC, a New York based strategy consulting firm for major advertisers and their creative and media agencies. He also serves as Professor of Branding and Integrated Communications at The City College of New York (CCNY). He's the author of Madison Avenue Manslaughter, an inside view of fee-cutting clients, profit-hungry owners and declining ad agencies (3rd Edition 2019), and Madison Avenue Makeover: the transformation of Huge and the redefinition of the ad agency business (2023). He has completed a new book, Madison Avenue Revisited, to be published in June 2026.
Here’s what we get into:
- Why Michael’s new book Madison Avenue Revisited is a sharper, more hard-hitting update on what’s driving agency decline — especially the impact of holding company decisions.
- What the current wave of M&A and cost-cutting signals for agency capability, talent, and client outcomes - including the knock-on effects for senior experience in an AI era.
- Why independent agencies could be entering a genuine opportunity window — and how “productising” services and focusing on measurable growth can change the game.
- And a brilliant reframing for account managers: why you should stop thinking like a logistics coordinator and start operating like a management consultant to your clients.
It’s one of those episodes that really challenges how we think about the agency business model. Here are a few key takeaways :
- Agency success can’t just be about delivering output cheaply — the real opportunity is in linking your work to client growth and outcomes.
- The industry’s talent shape is getting distorted: AI may remove more junior execution work, but it raises the need for experienced people who can direct, judge, and advise. - Independent agencies have a chance to differentiate by being explicit about what they stand for — not “low cost,” but “we help you grow, and we’ll prove it.” - And for account managers: you’ll be far more valuable when you bring data, insight, and a point of view — not just project updates and deadlines.
You can keep with Michael Farmer here: http://linkedin.com/in/michaelfarmer www.farmerandco.com
Madison Avenue Revisited: https://amzn.eu/d/07SX5rrI Madison Avenue Makeover: https://amzn.eu/d/0je8R4FA Madison Avenue Manslaughter: https://amzn.eu/d/09U5HbiN
If you’d like to be kept updated with shifts in the agency world as it relates to the account management role - or you’d like to talk to me about client retention and growth training options - head to my website https://www.accountmanagementskills.com
You can also sign up to my newsletter there so you don’t miss new episodes, mini-trainings, and what I’m seeing in the market.
More from Creative Agency Account Manager Podcast
Welcome to Episode 174. This episode is particularly useful if you're wondering how your clients are really adopting AI, and what that means for the future value of agencies.
Welcome to Episode 173. This episode will be genuinely useful if you're an agency owner thinking about how you'll eventually sell your business, or wondering whether AI is actually giving your agency an edge or just helping you do things faster.
Welcome to Episode 172. AI in agencies has moved on significantly from simply experimenting with ChatGPT and saving a bit of time. My guest is Roy Murphy, Co-founder at G3NR8 - AI innovator for brands including Samsung, Arsenal, and Perrigo. Roy helps businesses unlock exponential technologies as a driver of growth, guiding organisations to understand and act on AI through comprehensive training, strategy, and implementation initiatives. He serves as AI Advisor to the in-house agency network Inside Out and has delivered AI training for over 150 brands, including GSK, Lego and the Bank of England. Roy regularly speaks at AI roundtables, podcasts, and industry events, working with HR, communications, marketing, and operations teams to drive meaningful transformation. In this episode, we look at: • what comes next • why agencies need to rethink their business model and service lines • how connecting your existing client data can give account managers much better intelligence • and why agentic workflows could fundamentally change the way we manage and grow client relationships. We also talk about the skills account managers need to stay valuable as AI becomes embedded in everyday agency life. There’s a lot packed into this one. You can connect with Roy Murphy on LinkedIn here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/roymurphy/
Welcome to episode 171. I’m joined by Duncan Arbour, Head of AI Innovation in the Kinetic team at Syneos Health.
Welcome to Episode 170. This is a fascinating one if you work in or with design agencies, or if you’ve ever wondered why brilliant creative work doesn’t always get the influence it deserves inside client organisations.