Show Notes
In this second episode of Criminal Justice Matters, the podcast series from the Criminal Bar Association of England and Wales, Mary Prior KC, Vice Chair of the CBA explains how serious delays in the courts are jeopardising the entire justice system.
We hear from Paul, a man who spent four years on bail awaiting trial. He talks about the impact on his life, from his family and friends putting him on suicide watch to the loss of his job and being ostracized by many in his community.
The former Resident Judge at Leeds Crown Court, Peter Collier KC, describes how his final years on the bench were characterized by a squeeze on funding from the Ministry of Justice and what that meant for the number of sitting days, the government measure for how much our Crown Courts were open and holding hearings including trials each year.
Crown Court rooms were open for 109,000 sitting days in 2011 but by April 2019 they had been cut to around 82,300 for the financial year which would end in March 2020 which is effectively a 25% reduction. Delays to trials mounted and the backlog rose 25% in just one year before Covid even began.
Jonathan Dunne, a criminal barrister with over 30 years’ experience prosecuting and defending cases involving serious sexual and violent offences, explains why he set up the @CourtsIdle Twitter account to monitor the rapid decline in Crown Court sitting time in England and Wales. A decline which has seen the backlog of criminal cases double regardless of the impact of Covid or the barristers’ strike action.
The current backlog of criminal cases stands at approximately 70,000, more than double the backlog of just 33,000 at the start of 2019. These figures are not mere numbers; they represent tens of thousands of people like Paul whose lives are on hold.
The consequence of years of underfunding is that our criminal justice system is teetering on the brink of collapse.
We, the criminal barristers tasked with prosecuting and defending criminal cases, are working back-to-back on cases to try and maintain fair trials amid mounting delays.
As Mary Prior KC concludes “The human cost of delay is monumental.”
Join us as we continue a real-life journey through criminal justice – because Criminal Justice Matters.
Criminal Justice Matters is produced on behalf of the Criminal Bar Association by Adam Batstone Media & Communications.
For any further information on issues raised in this series contact James Rossiter CBA director of Communications
07985117887
More from Criminal Justice Matters
The statistics on judicial diversity released by the Ministry of Justice in July were stark, showing that only 1.2% of judges across England and Wales are Black. What’s more, that figure has remained static for the past 10 years, and there is currently only one High Court Judge who is black, appointed last year. In this episode Riel Karmy-Jones KC , Chair of the Criminal Bar Association, speaks to three prominent Black Barristers, Laurie-Anne Power KC, Keir Monteith KC and Stephen Akinsanya OBE about the under representation of black criminal barristers and judges, and asks whether thelack of diversity at the criminal bar and in the judiciary strikes at the heart of fairness in our criminal justice system. Keir, Laurie-Anne and Stephen share their personal experiences, and offer explanations as to why even in 2026, despite training and high level commitments to address racism, the problem persists, despite David Lammy, MP, being appointed in 2025 as the first black Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor, who also held the post of Deputy Prime Minister, having previously highlighted the issue in 2017. Riel, Keir, Laurie-Anne, and Stephen all work in serious and complex criminal cases across the country. The episode also contains extracts from a speech made by a black member of the junior bar, Leon-Nathan Lynch. in 2022. If you have opinions or experience of the issues raised in this episode, please do get in touch with the CBA via the website or through social media.
In this episode of the Criminal Justice Matters podcast from the Criminal Bar Association of England and Wales, Kate Bex KC and Chris Henley KC talk to the Vice-President of the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division, Lord Justice Edis. In his 45 year career at the Bar Lord Justice Edis has held many distinguished roles including; Head of Chambers at Atlantic Chambers in Liverpool, Senior Treasury Counsel of the Central Criminal Court from 2008 until 2014, High Court Judge in the King’s Bench Division. As Senior Presiding Judge, he was closely involved in restarting jury trials following the Covid 19 pandemic. He has been Vice Chair of the Sentencing Council since August 2025 and he was appointed to the Court of Appeal in 2021. In the podcast Lord Justice Edis sets out his thoughts on the efforts being made to tackle the backlog of cases in the Crown Court, and describes the different use of listing practices in some circuits which are beginning to reap rewards in terms of cutting the backlog. The podcast touches on the increased of use of Artificial Intelligence in the courts and the arguments for and against AI. The increased use of cameras in court is discussed and what impact that may have on the criminal justice system and the public’s perception of it. And Lord Justice Edis reflects on the negative impact of dwindling ‘conviviality’ among legal professionals and talks about his experiences as a keen cricketer, representing his Chambers in matches played with and against his colleagues. Criminal Justice Matters is produced and edited on behalf of the Criminal Bar Association by Adam Batstone Media & Communications
In this episode of the Criminal Justice Matters podcast from the Criminal Bar Association of England and Wales Simon Spence KC and Kate Bex KC speak to the award-winning actor and long-term supporter of the Criminal Bar, Martin Shaw. From appearing in The Professionals in the 1980s, Judge John Deed in the 2000s and Inspector George Gently in the 2010s, Martin has often starred in leading roles relating to the criminal justice system. While he says this was more by accident than design, he does have a long-standing belief in fairness and the importance of justice. He says his career has left him with a deep respect for those working at the Criminal Bar and a desire to depict the system accurately. As a direct consequence of his work, Martin is a long-time supporter and advocate for the Kalisher Trust, which helps young people from diverse backgrounds to make a career at the Criminal Bar.
In this latest episode of the Criminal Justice Matters podcast from the Criminal Bar Association of England and Wales, Francis FitzGibbon KC and Sarah Vine KC lead a discussion on the Courts and Tribunals Bill, which is being debated in Parliament. They are joined by Harriet Wistrich, Chief Executive of the Centre for Women’s Justice and Fiona Rutherford, Chief Executive of Justice. The conversation focuses on two key elements of the proposed legislation; the reduction of the right to choose trial by jury in cases which carry a sentence of less than three years and the implications for women complainants in rape and serious sexual offence cases whose cases are subject to some of the most lengthy delays within the criminal justice system.
In this episode of the Criminal Justice Matters podcast fromthe Criminal Bar Association of England & Wales, the Member of Parliament for Hull East, Karl Turner, a former Shadow Attorney General, discusses the Government’s proposals for reform of jury trials with CBA podcast hosts Kate Bex KC and Simon Spence KC. Karl Turner is a Labour MP and a former practising criminalbarrister who has spearheaded a cross party campaign within Parliament to maintain the existing system of right to trial by jury. The podcast sets out Karl’s vocal opposition to the Government’s stated policy of curbing jury trials, which would impact around half the existing cases in the Crown Court backlog. Karl's campaign has placed him at odds with his party colleagues and personal friends including the Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Deputy Prime Minister David Lammy. The podcasts explores the need to reinvest across thecriminal justice system and addresses a range of fundamental inefficiencies behind the case backlogs and delays that impact large parts of England and Wales. The podcast references the case backlog at Kingston UponHull Crown Court, which is notable for being one of the few Crown Courts to have managed its backlog over the past year. The case backlog in Hull reduced 9.4% to 537 over the 12 months to September 2025, compared to an increase of 9% to79,619 across England and Wales over the same period. Hull’s backlog began to rise sharply in 2019 before Covid and rose again during and post Covid. By September 2025 Hull’s case backlog was 39% higher than its low of 385 in June2019, while across England and Wales, there has been a 133% rise in the national backlog over the same six-year period. The average waiting times from charge to trial conclusion at Hull Crown Court are also considerably better than the national averages for both remand and bail cases. The CBA has no party-political leaning or affiliation andlistens to MPs and Peers of all political persuasions, engaging without fear or favour on issues that impact upon the functioning of the criminal justice system. Criminal Justice Matters is edited and produced on behalf ofthe Criminal Bar Association by Adam Batstone Media & Communications. . The views expressed by all contributors are their personal opinions on the topicsdiscussed.