The Ms. Rachel Monologue & The 22-Hour Jew, Trans TV Writer Our Lady J
Being Jewish with Jonah PlattShow Notes
She converted to Judaism yesterday! Jonah Platt interviews transgender activist, Emmy-nominated TV writer-director (Transparent, American Horror Story, Pose), and musician Our Lady J (Yona Speidel), less than 24 hours after she formally converted to Judaism. She describes her 12-year path, the beit din with three rabbis, her written reflection on Isaiah 56 and intersex identity, her mikvah immersion, and why she chose the Hebrew name Yona. She recounts growing up in a Mennonite household, losing trust in organized religion amid homophobia during the AIDS crisis, and later returning to spirituality through Judaism. The conversation addresses unconscious antisemitism, queer-community susceptibility to “they” conspiracies, and rising antisemitism in LGBT spaces after October 7. She discusses BDS (The Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement) pressure on Transparent, later learning German courts found BDS antisemitic, and argues for fact-based definitions of Zionism, while saying she is pro-Palestinian and pro-Israeli.
Topics discussed include:
The emotional experience of completing the Beit Din and mikvah after a 12-year spiritual journey Guidance from three rabbis during the conversion process The significance of Isaiah 56 and its message welcoming eunuchs, and those who might not have a binary identity of sex or gender Growing up in an ex–Old Order Mennonite Christian background and early perceptions of Jews The evolution of Lady J’s identity through names like Justin, Jonah, and Yona, and their biblical significance Influence of Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld, pioneer of trans medicine in Berlin (1909), on understanding antisemitism and queer history How Nazi book burnings in the 1930s destroyed Hirschfeld’s research at the Institute of Sexology The intersection of antisemitism, transphobia, and homophobia throughout European and modern history The rise of antisemitism within the LGBTQ community following October 7 and shifting attitudes toward Israel Lady J’s experience working on Transparent (Amazon Prime Video) Referencing activist Larry Kramer and ACT UP in discussions of queer organizing and Zionist parallels The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on spiritual reflection, including cross-country travel and research in Berlin archives Jewish values of perseverance illustrated through Torah learning, including lessons about continuing even when struggling
Thank you to this episode's sponsor: Jewish Communal Fund
MENTIONS Ms. Rachel draws ire over appeals for Gazan children Why Is Everyone Talking About Ms. Rachel Right Now? YouTube star Ms. Rachel should be investigated for spreading Hamas propaganda Who is the Bibas family? In the Sudan sick and starving children continue to waste away Violations against children have tripled in the Congo Russia’s kidnapping of Ukrainian children Iranian children killed by Iranian security forces in crackdown of protests 12 Israeli Druze children killed in Hezbollah rocket attack
Lady J First day of Judaism post Our Lady J’s Film and TV Credits The Mikvah The Beit Din (Rabbinic Court) and Conversion Rabbi Iggy ‘Transparent’ Writer Our Lady J: Hollywood ‘Needs to Put Stories Into the Hands of Trans People’ What is intersex? What is a eunuch in the Bible? Mennonite History Snapshots of an Epidemic: An HIV/AIDS Timeline Lady Chablis Queer Jews Forced into a Different Closet: Antisemitism and Conditional Acceptance “Through Science to Justice”: The Story of Magnus Hirschfeld, a Gay Jewish Trailblazer Lady J Zionism Instagram post The TV series Transparent Germany Declares: BDS is Antisemitic Miller Intro to Judaism Jay Sanderson BJJP Episode Rabbi Tarlan Rabizadeh, Mandana Dayani, and Matthew Nouriel BJJP Episode Jonah and the Whale - Bible Story Meaning Jacob Wrestles with the Angel Is MAGA really pro-Israel? The Holiday You’ve Never Heard Of: Why Shmini Atzeret Matters Why Are Grasshoppers (Locusts) Kosher for Some Jews? What’s So Wrong with Mixing Wool & Linen? Ask the Expert: Kosher Wine
More from Being Jewish with Jonah Platt
In the first episode of our Jewish American Summit series, Jonah sits down with Steve Hilton, Republican candidate for California governor, for a candid conversation about antisemitism, Jewish safety, and the future of the Golden State.
What does it mean to be unapologetically Jewish in an industry that has often encouraged people to hide their identity?
NEW SEGMENT! In the first installment of our new segment “Being Jewish In…” we explore the hostile environment facing Jewish authors, agents and editors in the world of Publishing with acclaimed author and digital publisher Meg Keene, newly appointed editor of the eponymous Meg Keene Books, a new imprint focused on publishing Jewish stories by Jewish authors.
Can a CEO speak out against antisemitism without becoming the story?
On the third anniversary of October 7th, Jonah delivers a powerful and deeply personal open letter to his non-Jewish friends, colleagues, and allies about what it means to stand with the Jewish people. In this special solo episode of Being Jewish, Jonah reflects on the past three years of rising antisemitism, fractured friendships, and the growing isolation of Jewish communities. He addresses the dangerous normalization of anti-Jewish rhetoric, the misunderstanding of Zionism and Jewish identity, and the painful silence of those who have chosen to look away.