Your Horror Show

"The Night Before..."

Your Horror Show

Show Notes

In our season two finale, Mr Graves shares a holiday horror tale about two small time crooks who get into a nightmarish situation with a man claiming to be old saint nick.

MR GRAVES: Ryan Joseph Murphy PAULEY: Chris Bauso MICKEY: Matt Rukstar SANTA: Art Brown

Written by Ryan Joseph Murphy

Directed by Ryan Joseph Murphy

Sound Design: Brady Flanagan

Intro Music: Edith Mudge

Artwork: Ghostly

Produced by: Gavin Michael Booth, Sade Sellers and Brady Flanagan

CW: Gun violence and explicit language

Transcript Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Your Horror Show

Oct 20, 2026

While Mr. Graves is tending to trick or treaters he shares a story about a mother who will do anything to bring her child back on Halloween night.

Oct 13, 2026

Mr Graves introduces "Redacted"

Oct 7, 2026

Spooky Season is in full swing with Mr. Graves and he gives a rundown of what to expect this month plus he's joined by an unexpected visitor who regales us with a tale called, "The Beepin."

Sep 29, 2026

While teaching some ghouls how to get fit, Mr. Graves a share a story about a couple of gym fanatics who will stop at nothing to be number one.

Sep 15, 2026

Mr. Graves buys some fairytale objects and presents a tale about a man living in house with a mysterious woman he sees outside his window.

See all episodes →