Show Notes
Join us for this podcast crossover episode! I’m bringing you our I Read Something Bad discussion about bad Christian art. If you’re into spicy fantasy books and spiritual formation, check out I Read Something Bad Podcast biweekly!
Today your Matron Saints of Spice are tackling the ever-controversial question of why so much Christian art feels thin, didactic, and aesthetically weak—and just plain BAD. We’re getting real about how flattening the Bible into surface-level application points has destroyed our capacity to engage layers in any medium, why making Ruth and Boaz into a love story completely misses the point about welcoming the stranger, and how capitalism turned humans into resources to be used up—which means our entire identity got wrapped up in usefulness instead of Imago Dei. Topics Covered: * The definition of good art as opening perception and making room for the reader versus bad art that reduces experience to propaganda with predetermined conclusions * Why Christian art often fails the hospitality test—inviting someone over just to lecture them about what to believe instead of offering actual coffee and conversation * Post-Reformation history of shifting from visual imagery (icons, stained glass) to language-only emphasis, and how the printing press made accessibility a priority that accidentally flattened everything * The Enlightenment’s need for certainty, empirical knowledge, and being on the same page—which bled into making messages crystal clear at the expense of mystery and layers * How “Facing the Giants” versus “Remember the Titans” shows the difference between heavy-handed Christian messaging and wrestling with justice/humanity through storytelling * Why Ruth and Boaz isn’t a romance about finding your person—it’s about Boaz depicting how Jesus welcomes strangers and provides for the vulnerable (Ruth said “where you go I will go” to NAOMI, people) * The collapse of context and layers in Bible reading, and how treating Scripture as flat application points instead of artistic literature kills our ability to engage depth anywhere else * How usefulness became our framework for existence instead of beauty, and why that’s devastating when your productivity disappears but you’re still made in the image of a creative God Good art invites wonder and makes space for mystery. Bad art tells you exactly what to think and then wonders why you’re not engaged. 🎨✝️📖 Timestamps: 02:00 Defining Good Art: Hospitality vs Heavy-Handed Messaging 06:00 Intimacy and Openness as Framework for Beauty 09:00 Why People Want to Be Told What to Think vs Asking Questions 11:00 Facing the Giants vs Remember the Titans: What We’re Wrestling With 14:00 Stained Glass Windows vs Sharpie Statements: Losing the Layers 16:00 Post-Reformation Shift from Visual to Language-Only Emphasis 20:00 Teen Talent Competitions and Performing for God’s Glory 23:00 When Church Art Became Branded Word Art from Hobby Lobby 25:00 Iconoclasm and What We Lost by Rejecting Visual Beauty 28:00 Ruth and Boaz Isn’t a Love Story About Finding Your Person 3 1:00 Reading the Bible with Layers: Literature, Language, Lifetime, Lenses 34:00 Why Translation Is Always Interpretation 37:00 Ruth After Proverbs 31: She’s the Woman of Valor, Actually 39:00 When Usefulness Disappears and You Lose Your Framework for Beauty 41:00 Imago Dei Isn’t Broken or a Mission to Accomplish—It Just Is 43:00 Capitalism Turned Humans Into Resources to Be Used Up 45:00 Creating Without Goals: The Church Art Studio Experiment 47:00 Redeeming Love Scammed Us (The Bible Story Is Different, Y’all) 50:00 Mount Pilgrim’s Stained Glass: Good Christian Art That Inspires Justice
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit kateboyd.substack.com/subscribe
More from Untidy Faith
In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with KJ Ramsey, trauma therapist and author of The Place Between Our Pains, for a conversation about what happens when the faith language you’ve published books about stops working—and why joy might still be available in the middle of a medical crisis that isn’t resolving. Topics Covered * What happens to us spiritually when every complaint has to come with a caveat, and why that splits us in two * Why being a trauma therapist didn’t spare KJ from trauma, and why she thinks that’s actually good news for the rest of us * How to be in your body when your body is the site of the pain, starting with how you’d talk to a five-year-old who skinned her knee * Why she stopped judging her own silence when she lost the ability to pray or describe God at all * A definition of joy that doesn’t require your life to get better, offered from a seat where things are actively not better Timestamps:01:00 When Hope Functions as a Gag Order04:00 Why It’s Still Hard to Let People See You10:00 Having the Language and Still Being Battered by It15:00 Embodiment When Your Body Doesn’t Feel Safe17:00 Your Body Is a Person, Not a Problem to Fix24:00 When the Words for God Stop Working28:00 Forsaken as Loosened for the Sake of Expansion33:00 Joy as the Presence of Love37:00 For Anyone in Something They Never Would Have Chosen40:00 Finding the Book and KJ’s Work
In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Kat Armas for a conversation about what “empire” actually means once you strip away the buzzword—and why decolonizing your bookshelf and diversifying it are not the same project. Topics Covered * How empire shifted from a ruler over his own people to an ambition that metastasized, and why the US is an imperial state even without an emperor * Why the Bible’s language is so imperial, including Heaven itself, and what that tells us about the people writing it * Who gets to decide what counts as wisdom, and what changes when you notice wisdom in Scripture is a woman shouting in the street * Why empire has no imagination (it’s been running the same tired playbook since Rome) but we do * The Quechua hummingbird story that reframes what meaningful resistance actually looks like Timestamps:01:00 Why “Empire” and “Decolonize” Became Buzzwords04:00 A Working Definition of Empire07:00 How Imperial Ideology Gets Woven Into Faith13:00 The Bible Isn’t an Anti-Imperial Manifesto16:00 What Cuban American Formation Reveals That Western Readings Miss21:00 Empire Begins as Story, Then Calcifies Into Systems26:00 Imagine Smaller: The Hummingbird Drop31:00 Empire Doesn’t Just Live Out There, It Lives In Us37:00 Why Liturgy Is Subversive42:00 Finding Kat’s Work
In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Anna Rollins, author of Famished: On Food, Sex, and Growing Up as a “Good Girl,” for a conversation about the shared script underneath purity culture and diet culture—and why knowing the promise is false doesn’t make it stop working on us. Topics Covered * The pattern Anna kept finding in her own private writing before she had a name for it, and what scarcity, smallness, and shrinking appetite had to do with each other * Why “control your appetite and you’ll be safe” persists even for women who see through it, and the very real thing it’s rooted in * What internalized fundamentalism looks like once the original system is gone, including inside body positivity * How to tell rigidity from conviction, and where each one shows up in the body * What “reclaiming appetite” actually looks like on a normal Tuesday, and why it’s rarely about food Timestamps:01:00 Noticing the Pattern in Her Own Writing03:00 Why the Promise Is Durable Even When You Know Better06:00 Fundamentalism That Follows You Into New Systems11:00 Wellness Language as Code and the Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders13:00 Telling Rigidity from Conviction18:00 Shame, Guilt, and Where the Hope Lives20:00 Why Healing Body Shame Shifts Your Relationship With God24:00 Reclaiming Appetite on a Normal Tuesday31:00 For Anyone Still in the Middle of It35:00 Finding the Book and Anna’s Work
In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Kristin Mockler Young, author of The Other Side of Certainty, for a conversation about what certainty is actually doing for us—and why the thing we were handed as faith might have been a tool for detachment all along. Topics Covered * The cynical-but-true reason certainty appeals to people who don’t know what to do with hard emotions or injustice * Why a faith that shatters and a faith that holds questions often come down to how the hard thing arrived * What people gain when they trade black-and-white belief for something roomier, and the loss almost nobody escapes * How certainty gets tangled up with identity and belonging, and why your people find it easier to let you go than face their own dissonance * The question Kristin is still sitting in, and why she’s not rushing to resolve it Timestamps:01:00 What Certainty Is Actually Doing for People04:00 The Difference Between Rooting Yourself in God and in What You Know About God09:00 What You Gain and What You Lose14:00 The Disorienting Moment You Notice the Cracks16:00 Authority vs. Power and How We Got Out of Balance17:00 How to Practice Curiosity When You Weren’t Trained For It20:00 Sitting in Not-Knowing Without Rushing23:00 The Question Kristin Hasn’t Resolved25:00 Finding the Book and Kristin’s Work
In this episode of the Untidy Faith Podcast, I sit down with Tyler Hill for a conversation about what changes when you start your story with belovedness instead of brokenness—and why the exhaustion so many of us carry comes from chasing something we’ve had in our pocket the whole time. Topics Covered * The breathwork session that gave Tyler a visceral image of the womb, and what it revealed about his very first knowing * Henri Nouwen’s three biggest lies (I am what I have, what I do, what others say) and how they become the raw material for a false self * Why belovedness isn’t spiritual bypassing, and what Tyler learned about it from people in prison who can’t hang their hat on their morality * The unexpected first spiritual practice Tyler prescribes, and why it involves $100 and an outfit you actually love * What’s hardest to let go of when you awaken to your true self, and it isn’t the theology Timestamps:03:00 The Six Months When Everything Fell Apart05:00 “Nothing to Prove, Nothing to Lose” and Why It Felt Like a Lie11:00 Baseball Tyler and the Making of a False Self18:00 The Practical Cost of Living from the False Self22:00 Belovedness That Isn’t Cheap Grace or Positive Thinking26:00 On-Ramps That Don’t Feel Like Obligation30:00 The Burning Bush and the Practice of Curiosity38:00 What You Have to Let Go Of46:00 Why Belovedness Requires a Feminine God47:00 How to Know You’re Living It, Not Just Believing It53:00 Finding Tyler’s Work and Monday Morning Blessings