Conversations with John Lane - Episode 5: Is the Conciliar Church a new Church? Are the Paul VI Roman Rite sacraments valid?
Conversations on the CrisisShow Notes
This episode continues Louie Verrecchio’s extended conversation with John Lane, focusing on the long‑standing question “Where is the Church?” and how Catholics have grappled with this since the Second Vatican Council. Lane presents a curated set of historical quotations—from Frank Sheed, Cardinal Ratzinger, Archbishop Lefebvre, Cardinal Burke, Cardinal Suenens, Msgr. Gherardini, and Romano Amerio—showing that confusion about the Church’s identity, continuity, and visibility has been voiced for more than fifty years from both within and without the conciliar sect. The discussion explores the emergence of what Lefebvre called the “conciliar church,” and whether it constitutes a distinct society separate from the Catholic Church. They examine the limits of Archbishop Lefebvre’s attempts to reconcile contradictory realities, the principle of non‑contradiction in ecclesiology, and the difficulties involved in identifying who is a member of the Church. Finally, they discuss the validity of the new sacramental rites, the limitations of the arguments of conservations as to why they must be valid and the principles traditionalist often fail to adopt when considering sacramental validity.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit greatcatholicpodcasts.substack.com
More from Conversations on the Crisis
John joins Louie to tackle viewer questions focusing on the No Una Cum position challenging the claim that naming a false pope in the canon renders a Mass non‑Catholic or that Catholics holding the sedevacantist position are forbidden to attend such masses. Drawing on theology, canon law, and historical cases—from St. Vincent Ferrer to the English Reformation—Lane argues the issue is a modern novelty, not a traditional teaching. He explains why presence at such a Mass does not imply consent to error, why the faithful are not required to resolve papal legitimacy in confusing times. He also discusses his position in relation to groups like the SSPX, FSSP and the broader crisis in the Church. As Lane puts it, “It’s a non‑issue… and it can only be built up to appear to be an issue by vague rhetoric" and emotional arguments that cloud right reason.
Louie concludes the series with the second of a two-part discussion of Vatican II's Pastoral constitution on the church in the modern world, Gaudium et Spes and contrasts it with Catholic teaching alongside host Kevin Davis. Follow along with the original text available at: https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19651207_gaudium-et-spes_en.html You can find Louie at akacatholic.com
Louie begins a two-part discussion of Vatican II's Pastoral constitution on the church in the modern world, Gaudium et Spes and contrasts it with Catholic teaching alongside host Kevin Davis. Follow along with the original text available at: https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19651207_gaudium-et-spes_en.html Francis I's speech to economists mentioned by Louie can be found at: https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/speeches/2014/july/documents/papa-francesco_20140712_seminario-economia.html
Louie concludes a two-part discussion of Vatican II's declaration on religious freedom Dignitatis Humanae and contrasts it with Catholic teaching alongside host Kevin Davis. From the Catholic Family Podcast. Follow along with Louie by reading the document available here: https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_decl_19651207_dignitatis-humanae_en.html You can find Louie at akacatholic.com
Louie begins a two-part discussion of Vatican II's declaration on religious freedom Dignitatis Humanae and contrasts it with Catholic teaching alongside host Kevin Davis. You can find the text being discussed here: https://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_decl_19651207_dignitatis-humanae_en.html You can find Louie at akacatholic.com