Swiftologist

18: Anthony Fantano Admits He Was Wrong About Everything

Swiftologist

Show Notes

GET TICKETS TO MY TOUR: https://www.evolutionofasnake.com I sat down with Anthony Fantano (The Needle Drop) for one of the most honest conversations about what it actually means to be an internet music critic in 2026…the perks, the pressure, and the parts nobody talks about. We get into everything: how algorithms have reshaped the way critics make decisions, whether paid promotions have poisoned music journalism, and what happens when artists push back. Hard. Plus: the Vince Staples story. The Charlie Puth DMs. Anthony’s revised Addison Rae opinions. Sombr mess. What Charli XCX’s rock album might sound like. Why Taylor Swift’s next move is important, and whether anyone can still be a true gatekeeper in the age of TikTok. If you've ever wondered whether your favorite music reviewer is actually being honest with you, this is the conversation.

More from Swiftologist

Sep 14, 2026

Rebecca Black sits down with me to talk about her new album Age of the Exhibitionist, surviving "Friday" to become a cult DJ, and staying independent without a label — this is Proto Pop. We get into making the album with zero major label backing, opening for Katy Perry's arena tour, why DJing funds her music videos, and the meaning behind "Anaheim Star," "Visions Again," and "Corsetry." We also talk stan culture, post-truth internet discourse, and her pop star Mount Rushmore (Fergie made the cut). Proto Pop is co-produced by Zachary Hourihane & FWB Talent, edited by Tyler Murphy, and styled by Michael Kirreh, with research by Bianca Brock.

Jun 28, 2026

Welcome to Proto Pop: my new long form interview series about what it actually means to be a pop artist right now...not just charts and drama, but the systems, risks and careers underneath it. In Episode 1, ‪@Lizzo‬ sits down with me for an hour‑long conversation about what really happened with B*TCH, flopping in public, and why pop is broken in 2026: If you care about the art (and science) of how pop music works beyond the brain dead stan wars (particularly how it’s marketed, measured and lived in real time) Proto Pop was made for you. This first episode is Lizzo using her own era as a case study in how the machine works (and doesn’t work) anymore.

Jun 9, 2026

Olivia Rodrigo finally sat down for her first real podcast interview — and she had a lot to say. In this emergency reaction, I break down her NYTimes PopCast conversation about new album You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love, the Taylor Swift feud that won't die, and the moment she bristled at being called the villain. Olivia gets candid about songwriting credits, the "frost" with Taylor, why she's stopped caring about internet conspiracies, and the baby doll dress controversy that had Gen Z in a chokehold. I bring my journalist lens to the parts the hosts missed — and the parts Olivia clearly didn't want to touch.

Jun 2, 2026

Justin Bieber. Taylor Swift. Ed Sheeran. Dua Lipa. Katy Perry. I sat down and gave them all my most brutal, unsolicited career advice... and none of them asked for it! In this episode, I break down exactly what 12 of the biggest pop stars in the world need to hear right now: whether they should retire, rebrand, or get completely weird. Some of these verdicts are kind. Some of them aren't. This is MY pop star career audit :)

May 25, 2026

The lead single is the highest-stakes move in pop music. One song decides if you get to level up or if the entire era dies on arrival.I ranked every level of lead single from Career Killers to Origin Myths — and some of these placements will start a fight. From Katy Perry's "Woman's World" (the textbook Career Killer) to Olivia Rodrigo's "drivers license" (the cultural Rorschach test that hard-coded an entire archetype) — this is a complete breakdown of what a lead single actually does to an artist's career. Not chart performance. Not quality. The chessboard moves. Featuring: Taylor Swift, Sabrina Carpenter, Charli XCX, Dua Lipa, Adele, Miley Cyrus, Lady Gaga, Beyoncé, Lorde, Lana Del Rey, Ariana Grande, Britney Spears & more.

See all episodes →