Lunchtime Live

How often are charity shops being used as dumping grounds?

Lunchtime Live

Summary

Charity shops in Ireland are facing challenges as they increasingly become dumping grounds for unwanted clothing, particularly items of poor quality. Reports indicate that many donations consist of stained or damaged clothing that charities must pay to dispose of, raising concerns about how people treat these shops. The discussion highlights a shift in donation practices, with some individuals opting to sell better-quality items on platforms like Vinted instead of donating them, leaving charity shops with less desirable goods.

Cathy Donaghy, an Irish journalist and charity shop enthusiast, expresses disappointment at the decline in the quality of items available in these shops, noting that many donations now consist of fast fashion pieces that lack uniqueness and durability. Pat Kane, Chief Sustainability Officer at Antares, agrees, emphasizing the importance of donating items that are clean and in good condition. Both guests call for a more respectful approach to donations, urging people to consider whether the items they give are suitable for resale.

The conversation also touches on the broader impact of fast fashion on the second-hand market, with social media contributing to a culture of disposable clothing. Despite these challenges, both guests share their positive experiences and valuable finds from charity shops, encouraging listeners to appreciate the potential treasures that can still be discovered.

Show Notes

Do we find more tat nowadays in charity shops? Is fast fashion filling them now, and are we treating them as dumping grounds for unwanted or broken pieces? Joining Andrea to discuss this is Kathy Donaghy, Journalist, author and columnist, and Pat Kane, sustainability advocate and Chief Sustainability Officer at Antaris.

More from Lunchtime Live

Oct 23, 2026

Breakfast Briefing Presenter Shane Beatty joined Andrea with a roundup of some of the stories from across the country this week.

Oct 23, 2026

Limerick City and County Council are in hot water as they posted a video promoting Christmas in the city. Why? It was generated by artificial intelligence. This comes as Fontaines D.C. also stated yesterday that they did not know AI was used in their music video for hit song 'Marianne.' This begs the question: does AI have any place in the creative industry? Joining Andrea to discuss is Steven Mangan, Creative Director of Ringers, Artist Niall O'Loughlin and more.

Oct 22, 2026

Is your kitchen counter full of appliances, or are you always looking for neat gadgets that can be stored away? This week, The Home Squad are here to chat about kitchen appliances that matter! Joining Andrea to discuss is Jenny Sheehan, Co-Host of ‘Rip it up: The Renovations Podcast’ (@workerscottage on Instagram) and Jenny Butler, Interior Architect & Design Director of Jennifer Anne Interior.

Oct 22, 2026

Under new rules set to come in, Airbnb guests will no longer have to do the annoying cleaning jobs before check out. They can no longer be asked to empty bins, strip beds and do the dishes... So, is this a positive step or more work for hosts? Andrea is joined by an Airbnb host to discuss.

Oct 22, 2026

There has been a significant wave of online discussion and public debate following this campaign by Cuan called ‘We Consent’, which is about personal boundaries. The debate continues from both sides, with some believing that grandparents have every right to hug their grandkids, and that this is ‘woke gone wrong’, with others asking why shouldn't kids be asked whether they consent to hugging their grandkids or not? What do you make of it all? Joining Andrea to discuss is Tony Griffin, author of 'Teenagers Book of Life', Broadcaster Claire Ronan, Nessa Hill, Barrister and CEO of Neurodiversity Ireland and more.

See all episodes →