COLD

Announcing Deceived: The Daybell Story

COLD

Summary

Dave Cauley announces the conclusion of season four of the podcast Cold and shares plans for additional episodes that will address new developments in the Joyce Yost and Cherie Warren cases from previous seasons. He highlights the upcoming release of a new show titled Deceived, focusing on the Daybell story, produced by Ben Kebrick and hosted by Nate Eaton from East Idaho News. Cauley mentions his involvement in the project and describes it as compelling.

The trailer for Deceived reveals the unsettling case of missing children Joshua Vallow and Tylee Ryan, whose disappearance is linked to their mother, Lori Vallow, and her husband, Chad Daybell. The narrative unfolds as Eaton recounts his experiences investigating the case, including confronting the couple in Hawaii. The trailer hints at themes of faith, spiritual manipulation, and the dark undercurrents of family loyalty, suggesting that the story will delve into the bizarre and tragic circumstances surrounding the children's disappearance and the subsequent events. Deceived is set to premiere on October 29th.

Show Notes

COLD host Dave Cawley provides a status update as the latest season draws to a close. Up next in the feed, we'll be sharing episodes of a new true crime show from KSL Podcasts. It's called Deceived: The Daybell Story, hosted by Nate Eaton of East Idaho News and produced by Ben Keubrick (lead producer of COLD season 3). Episodes of Deceived will begin appearing in the COLD podcast feed starting October 29.

More from COLD

Oct 21, 2026

Heidi Holmberg and Tori Riddle face their father in court, taking their power back decades after suffering abuse at Tom Jackson’s hands.

Oct 14, 2026

The waiting game begins as former East Layton police officer Tom Jackson faces new criminal charges over allegations of child sex abuse against his daughters during the 1980s. A rift emerges among Jackson’s family, with some blood relatives refusing to believe he could be capable of such terrible acts.

Oct 7, 2026

The Nancy Baird case file, kept away from prying eyes for decades, is at last released to COLD in 2023. Contained within are surprise revelations about the last people known to have seen Nancy alive.

Sep 30, 2026

Days before his execution, serial killer Ted Bundy denied knowing anything about the disappearance of Nancy Baird. That didn’t stop police and the press from declaring Bundy the killer. That folklore loomed large for Nancy’s son, Brant.

Sep 23, 2026

A young man who demonstrated astonishing “powers” arrived in Utah five years following the disappearance of Nancy Baird. James Hydrick wowed police, including a former officer who investigated Nancy’s case, with his telekinetic abilities.

See all episodes →