Two Crime Besties

Episode 98 - Theo Hayez and Other Disappearances near Byron Bay

Two Crime Besties

Show Notes

Summary: In this episode, we delve into the mysterious case of Theo Hayez’s disappearance in Byron Bay, exploring the evidence, theories, and ongoing questions surrounding his case. We also discuss other local disappearances and the possibility of a serial killer operating in the area.

Keywords: Theo Hayez, Byron Bay disappearance, travel mystery, Australian true crime, missing person, travel safety, crime investigation, Byron Bay, The Byron Bay Butcher, serial killer, unsolved cases, foul play, investigation, mystery, true crime

Sources and other links Nightmare in Paradise, 60 Minutes Australia The Lighthouse, The Australian, Podcast

If any of our content is distressing & you need to talk (Australia): Lifeline Phone: 13 11 14 https://www.lifeline.org.au/ Or please seek assistance in your country

Check us out on our socials for images and updates: ⁠Instagram⁠ ⁠Facebook⁠ ⁠Website⁠

Join us on Patreon: If you would like more of us join us for Two Crime Besties: Crime Adjacent over on Patreon! More laughs, more banter, more crime-adjacent chaos. ⁠Patreon.com/twocrimebesties

“Buy Me a Coffee”. If you'd like to keep us caffeinated (or wined 😉) while we prep our next episode, please feel free to click the below link to buy us a coffee. https://buymeacoffee.com/twocrimebesties

Buy your very own Two Crime Besties Merch here: www.twocrimebesties.com/merch

Also check out the LinkTree ihttps://linktr.ee/Twocrimebesties for all our links

Stay curious, crime besties!

Disclaimer: The content of this podcast is intended for mature audiences. The topics discussed may contain sensitive material related to real-life crimes, violence, and distressing events that may be disturbing or triggering. All opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests and do not reflect the views of any organisations or entities associated with the production.

While we strive to provide accurate and factual information, true crime stories may involve speculation, theories, and varying interpretations of events. Some details may be presented in a way that is meant to engage and educate rather than to sensationalise.

Listener discretion is advised.

Chapters: 00:00 Opening banter 06:50 Taylor Swift/Travis Kelce Wedding 16:40 Shoutouts 18:25 Introduction to Theo Hayes' case 24:02 Travel plans and arrival in Australia 31:55 The night of disappearance: Byron Bay nightlife 39:50 Security footage and GPS analysis 44:51 The environment and known risk areas 01:14:50 Potential theories and ongoing investigation 01:31:48 Other Byron Bay Disappearances

More from Two Crime Besties

Oct 19, 2026

Summary: In this episode, we delve into the tragic case of Mica, exploring the manipulative and coercive behaviours of JP, the legal proceedings, and the broader implications of coercive control and murder by suicide laws. We analyse the complex dynamics of abuse, mental health, and justice.

Oct 12, 2026

Summary: In this episode, we delve into the tragic case of Eric's death, the suspicious circumstances surrounding fentanyl overdose, and the subsequent investigation and trial of Kouri, his wife. We explore the evidence, motives, and the impact on the family, highlighting the complexities of crime and justice.

Oct 5, 2026

Summary: In this episode, we delve into the tragic case of Leigh Leigh, exploring the events of her death in Stockton NSW, Australia, the investigation, and the societal issues surrounding victim blaming and justice. Keywords: true crime, Leigh Leigh, victim blaming, justice, Australian crime, murder case, societal issues, podcast recommendations

Sep 28, 2026

Summary: In this episode, we delve into the chilling case of Ivan Milat, Australia's most notorious serial killer, exploring his crimes, the investigation, and the ongoing quest for justice. Join us for a detailed analysis of one of Australia's darkest chapters and what it reveals about criminal profiling and law enforcement efforts.

Sep 21, 2026

Summary: In this episode, we delve into the chilling details of the brutal murder of Colleen Slemmer, exploring the complex background of Christa Pike, her traumatic childhood, motives, the brutal crime, and the subsequent legal proceedings. We also discuss the broader issues of justice, mental health, and the death penalty in the US.

See all episodes →