Show Notes
Sam Barnhart of Bleach joins to help choose the best song on The Anatomy of the Tongue in Cheek. We meet our first heavy hitters.
Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.
Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.
TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro 1:00 The Guest: Sam Barnhart 4:51 The Album: Anatomy 34:45 The Great Sadie Truce of 2026 40:54 2nd Nomination 43:33 3rd Nomination 52:10 4th Nomination 56:12 What's the WORST song on Anatomy? 1:01:29 Debate Begins 1:14:12 Secret Track: What has Sam been doing lately?
More from The Lock-In
We are LIVE from Nashville, Tennessee, and ready to rumble. By the end of this episode, we will crown the ultimate Jesus or My Girlfriend, agree on Relient K's best album, and unveil their greatest song of all time. Welcome back to Two Lefts guest and fan favorite, Whitney Lane Wiley! Special thanks to Bobby Marko and Journey Church for helping make our finale extra special. Comment below to tell us we're wrong! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs. Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs this season. TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro: Addison in Nashville and Whitney returns! 12:34 Ultimate Jesus or My Girlfriend 20:22 Relient K's Best Album 1:16:14 Relient K's Best Song 1:45:04 Closing Thoughts
Relient K opener and friend Grace Semler Baldridge comes through to set the record straight on everything else they ever released, as well as our picks so far. Plus, the Christmas dissertation we've been waiting for. Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs. Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season. TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro 0:38 The Guest: Grace Semler Baldridge 26:41 The Christmas Dissertation 41:13 Grace reacts to our picks 55:59 1st Nomination 57:05 2nd Nomination 1:01:25 3rd Nomination 1:10:35 4th Nomination 1:13:51 Debate Begins 1:16:57 Plugs & Previews
Surprise! Music exec and Relient K old timer Brad Moist says we aren't a real show without The Nashville Tennis EP. Is this an official episode or some sort of bonus thing? We have the same questions about the EP. Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs. Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season. TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro 0:26 The Guest: Brad Moist 22:11 The Album: The Nashville Tennis EP 31:02 A Game: Where Does That Bird Beelong? 44:24 1st Nomination 48:27 2nd Nomination 55:01 3rd Nomination 1:03:17 4th Nomination 1:10:55 Debate Begins 1:33:05 Plugs & Previews
Keep Warm's Kevin Campbell is locked and loaded with takes about Relient K's last album (for now). The three of us agree on exactly one opinion: is Air For Free one of RK's best albums? Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs. Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season. TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro 0:43 The Guest: Kevin Campbell 3:33 The Album: Air For Free 22:56 Jesus, My Life Partner, or Matt Hoopes? 34:30 1st Nomination 41:04 2nd Nomination 47:44 3rd Nomination 56:53 4th Nomination 1:04:37 Debate Begins 1:23:44 Plugs & Previews
Producer Paul Moak knows you hate Collapsible Lung. Brad Wilson has a eulogy for the band we all loved. Both help us decide which song is a contender for Relient K's best song.