Show Notes
What do you do when God seems silent—when prayer feels empty, consolation disappears, and you wonder whether He is listening? In this episode of Saints for the Struggle, we turn to St. John of the Cross for lessons in spiritual dryness, perseverance, and loving God beyond our feelings.
Imprisoned in Toledo by members of his own religious order, John endured months of isolation and mistreatment. Yet his suffering became the setting for poetry and spiritual insights that continue to help souls seek deeper union with God.
This reflection explores his teaching on purification, attachment to spiritual consolation, and the difference between ordinary dryness and the mystical dark night. It also considers unanswered prayer, wounds caused by fellow Catholics, and the quiet fidelity of those who keep choosing Christ through difficult seasons.
The absence of consolation is not the absence of God. Prayer does not become worthless because it feels difficult, and faithfulness cannot depend entirely upon emotional rewards.
IN THIS EPISODE • St. John of the Cross and St. Teresa of Ávila • The Carmelite reform and John’s imprisonment in Toledo • Spiritual dryness and the dark night of the soul • Active and passive purification • Loving God for His own sake • Perseverance when motivation disappears • Unanswered prayer and trust in God • Remaining faithful after betrayal or injustice • Discernment, spiritual direction, and seeking appropriate help • Practical steps when prayer feels empty • Christ’s Passion and our hope of eternal life
Not every difficult season is a mystical dark night. This episode distinguishes spiritual purification from ordinary distractions, exhaustion, and psychological suffering, while encouraging prudent guidance when needed.
00:00 What Do You Do When God Seems Silent? 00:34 When Others Feel Peace—and You Feel Nothing 01:18 “What If God Has Abandoned Me?” 01:51 A Carmelite Prisoner in Toledo 02:31 The Absence of Consolation Is Not the Absence of God 02:48 John’s Early Life and Vocation 03:27 St. Teresa of Ávila and the Carmelite Reform 04:16 Imprisoned by His Own Religious Brothers 04:48 When the Wound Comes from Within the Church 05:40 Nine Months of Confinement 06:54 Poetry and Spiritual Freedom Amid Suffering 07:20 What the Dark Night of the Soul Means 07:58 Active and Passive Purification 08:27 Faith Cannot Depend Entirely on Feelings 09:01 Loving the Giver Beyond His Gifts 09:47 Marriage as an Example of Faithful Love 11:17 When Daily Prayer Feels Fruitless 12:00 Why Dry Prayer Still Matters 12:32 An Athlete’s Lesson in Perseverance 13:31 The Pain of Unanswered Prayer 14:19 God’s Promises and Our Expectations 15:04 Betrayal, Injustice, and Remaining with Christ 16:15 Acknowledging Wrongdoing Without Losing the Faith 16:39 Suffering Does Not Have to Become Your Identity 17:48 Trusting God When We Cannot Understand 19:02 Why We Should Not Romanticize Spiritual Darkness 19:56 Discernment and Spiritual Direction 20:31 When the Initial Excitement of Faith Fades 21:44 “Faithfulness Begins Where Feelings End” 22:52 Augustine and John: Surrender and Perseverance 23:59 Five Practical Steps When Prayer Feels Empty 25:14 John’s Escape and Lasting Spiritual Legacy 26:18 When Suffering Continues 27:18 Eternal Hope and the Mystery of Good Friday 28:22 Three Lessons to Remember 29:35 The Quiet Fidelity of Someone Still Praying 30:42 Encouragement for the Weary Soul 31:25 Remaining Faithful Without Extraordinary Feelings 31:49 “Lord, I Believe in You—and I Am Still Here” 32:14 Darkness Does Not Have the Final Word
If prayer has felt difficult lately, choose one manageable act of fidelity today: a sincere prayer, an act of charity, or the faithful fulfillment of a duty. Bring your struggle honestly before Our Lord.
Explore more Catholic content: https://sensusfidelium.tv/
St. John of the Cross, pray for us.
🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴🔴
More from Sensus Fidelium Catholic Podcast
St. Augustine knew what it meant to want holiness while remaining attached to sin. In this episode of Saints for the Struggle, Steve Cunningham explores Augustine’s conversion and the dangerous habit of telling God, “Not yet.”
Have you committed the very sin you promised God you would never commit again? Have shame, discouragement or repeated failure made you wonder whether confession and another attempt are even worthwhile?
What should you do when someone you love abandons the Catholic faith? The story of St. Monica and St. Augustine offers hope—and a difficult but essential lesson: you cannot force another person to convert, but you can pray, sacrifice, love faithfully, and entrust that soul to God.