Plus One with Lisa and Morgan

Jen Herrera Richter Plus Andy Richter

Plus One with Lisa and Morgan

Show Notes

Jen Herrera doesn't wait around for life to happen. She started a business, travelled the world, chose to become a single mom and when she was matched with Andy Richter on a dating site, she took a swipe at romance.

On this week's episode of Plus One with Lisa and Morgan, Jen details her life as a plus one to Conan O'Brien's hysterical sidekick, how she navigated a worldwide journey to become a mom and despite her successful career in music management and production, she knows when to stay in her lane.

Andy joins the conversation to tell his side of their love story — from the moment he realized he could be completely himself to becoming dad to her daughter, Cornelia. He also opens up about Dancing with the Stars, what his own career has taught him about being a “plus one,” and why finding love with someone who didn’t need him, made their relationship all the more meaningful.

(00:00) Welcome to Plus One

(04:41) Meet Jen Richter

(05:30) Jen & Andy Met on Hinge

(08:25) Did Jen Know She Matched With Andy Richter?

(09:00) Two Men Asked Jen Out for Valentine’s Day

(10:01) Jen Chooses Andy — And Breaks the News in Person

(12:21) Why Jen Knew Andy Was Different

(14:31) Meeting Conan & Entering Andy’s World

(17:04) Jen’s Decision to Become a Mom on Her Own

(20:04) The Unexpected IVF Journey That Took Her to Argentina

(23:12) Finding Out She Was Pregnant in Japan

(24:50) Jen’s Career Behind Iconic Music Videos

(27:20) Family, Heritage & Becoming Fiercely Independent

(30:50) Andy Richter Joins the Conversation

(31:48) Andy on Dancing with the Stars

(35:00) Andy’s New Generation of Fans

(37:03) Becoming a Dad Again

(38:08) How Andy Became Cornelia’s Dad

(41:34) Andy’s Side of Their Hinge Love Story

(43:00) The Moment Andy Knew He Was Falling in Love

(44:24) Their Very Practical “Proposal”

(46:29) Andy on Love, Family & Taking Care of Yourself

(48:01) When Andy Richter Is the Plus One

(50:00) What Being Conan’s Sidekick Taught Andy

(51:14) What Andy Loves Most About Jen

(53:04) Andy Gets Emotional Talking About Becoming Cornelia’s Dad

(54:18) The Parenting Moment Jen Found “Sexy”

(58:00) Jen on Living Life Her Own Way Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Plus One with Lisa and Morgan

Oct 20, 2026

You may not know the name David Krumholtz, but you know his work. From Oppenheimer to Numbers to the Santa Clause to 10 Things I Hate About You, David’s acting career has spanned decades. What you aren’t familiar with is his biggest supporter and who he credits with actually saving his life. This week on Plus One with Lisa and Morgan, Vanessa Krumholtz reveals her secret side hustle, the intimacy of real estate and how a hilarious Super-bowl party misunderstanding has yet to be resolved.Later, David joins for an honest conversation that touches on addiction, the work it takes to be human and how he became an actor by accident. Buckle up. This is a don’t miss wild ride episode of Plus One with Lisa and Morgan.

Oct 13, 2026

Ever wonder how magicians pull off their tricks or dream of dancing in NYC or even what's it like to be a stand up comedian?

Oct 6, 2026

In this week’s episode of Plus One with Lisa and Morgan, meet a woman who at 5 years old helped shape American History.

Sep 29, 2026

Only a fool would count out Jennifer Birmingham Lee. The sweet southern gal charms everyone she comes in contact with, especially her husband, The Good Doctor star Will Yun Lee.

Sep 22, 2026

What happens when the guy who performed in your bar becomes an international comedic juggernaut?

See all episodes →