The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Hour 5: C-Mac Blasts Yankees Leadership and Debates Giants QB Pivot

The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Show Notes

Chris McMonigle examines the Yankees' recent press conference, focusing on Hal Steinbrenner's refusal to hold Brian Cashman and Aaron Boone accountable for organizational failures. He also critiques the decision to start J.J. McCarthy over Jameis Winston for the Giants and shares his excitement over the Knicks' championship ring ceremony.

(00:02:10) Yankees Leadership Criticism

(00:05:35) J.J. McCarthy's Giants Debut

(00:11:50) Giants Roster Strategy

(00:16:45) Winston Versus McCarthy Debate

(00:22:05) Brian Cashman's Job Security

(00:26:45) Knicks Ring Ceremony

(00:33:40) Giants Division Opportunity

(00:37:45) Yankees Accountability Crisis

More from The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Oct 24, 2026

Kickoff with Boomer and Valenti: A TNF Thriller, is this the end of the Rams? Picks and preview for all of the Week 7 games, including a potential Super Bowl preview? Where will these big name QB's be next year, and Boomer suggests a Justin Herbert trade that could shake up the NFL!

Oct 24, 2026

From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans return to the Audacy Airwaves to first discuss all the implications to the Jalen Hurts situation in Philly. Stink gives his perspective of dealing with both team and independent doctors. Then, they debate whether Green Bay has found their footing after two very impressive wins. They end the podcast with #QuestionMark.

Oct 23, 2026

Craig and Big Mac evaluate the high stakes for the New York Jets and the Giants' decision to start J.J. McCarthy. They also debunk rumors regarding Jalen Hurts' health and clarify the New York Knicks' championship ring policy for employees.

Oct 23, 2026

Craig and Big Mac break down why the New York Jets face a must-win situation against the Dolphins to save Aaron Glenn’s coaching job. They explore the New York Giants' shift to J.J. McCarthy and Jackson Dart, analyze a controversial defensive effort by the Chicago Bears, and discuss a major NHL trade involving the New Jersey Devils.

Oct 23, 2026

Big Mac and the team address viral rumors surrounding Jalen Hurts’ family health and clarify J.J. McCarthy’s standing on the Vikings' depth chart. They also explore the details of Anthony Richardson's recent traffic stop and debate the biggest snubs from the New York Times' top 100 television shows list.

See all episodes →