Which Side of History?

Rule of Law Under Siege: Pam Karlan, Rob Bonta, Ruth Marcus

Which Side of History?

Show Notes

Host Jim Steyer tackles the sweeping attempts to undermine the Justice Department. His esteemed guests include California Attorney General Rob Bonta, renowned journalist Ruth Marcus, and Stanford Law Professor Pam Karlan. The panel offers timely insights on the erosion of the rule of law, the weaponization of the Department of Justice, the challenges faced by career civil servants, and the significant cases the U.S. Supreme Court is about to decide.

How serious is the dismantling of the Justice Department? What's the potential damage? And how does this moment in time compare to Watergate?

Listen to this episode of Which Side of History and find out:

00:00 Comparing Watergate to Current Justice Department Issues 00:51 Introduction to the Podcast and Today's Topic 01:34 Discussion with Rob Bonta on Rule of Law Challenges 07:30 Ruth Marcus on Checks and Balances 10:57 Pam Karlan on the Justice Department's Integrity 15:58 Rob Bonta on Political Weaponization of Prosecution 19:14 Historical Context and Future of the Rule of Law 29:15 Role of States in Upholding Democratic Principles 34:18 Lower Courts' Struggles and Reactions 36:36 Early Capitulation of Law Firms 39:13 Supreme Court's Role and Influence 43:30 The Shadow Docket and Key Cases 01:00:37 Birthright Citizenship and Legal Precedents 01:07:18 Concluding Thoughts and Future Implications

The panel was recorded on November 3, 2025 at Stanford University.

More from Which Side of History?

Jan 22, 2026

In this episode of Which Side of History, Stanford University professor and Common Sense Media founder Jim Steyer assesses democracy's uncertain future. His distinguished guests are former National Security Advisor to President Obama Susan Rice, former U.S. Ambassador to Russia Mike McFaul, and Margrethe Vestager, former European Commissioner for Competition. They delve into the threats posed by Russia and China, America's shifting role in global politics, and the decline of democratic values. They also explore the impact of social media, the importance of international alliances, and the need for more regulation for digital platforms.

Jan 21, 2026

Common Sense Media founder Jim Steyer engages with Stanford University President Jonathan Levin and former U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. The conversation delves into the challenges faced by American universities in today's polarized political climate. Key topics include the ongoing role of universities, the importance of maintaining academic freedom, the impact of federal government policies on higher education, and the critical need for diversity and representation in the post-affirmative action era.

Jan 15, 2026

In this episode Stanford University professor Jim Steyer delves into the current state of American government, focusing on the experiences of federal employees amid ongoing political turmoil. His guests include best-selling author Michael Lewis, comedian and TV host W. Kamau Bell, and writer and educator Dave Eggers. They discuss the dedication of civil servants, the impact of political actions on public perceptions, and the broader ramifications for American institutions.

Jan 13, 2026

In this episode Stanford University professor and Common Sense Media founder Jim Steyer explores whether we're witnessing the end of the post-World War II global order.

Jan 6, 2026

Stanford University professor Jim Steyer leads a lively discussion on the influence of big tech on democracy and America's youth. As founder of Common Sense Media, Steyer moderates a debate that features prominent tech journalist Kara Swisher, Pinterest CEO Bill Ready and Zoom Communications CEO Eric Yuan. They explore the consolidation of power in major tech companies, the role of artificial intelligence, and implications for our kids. What are the potential benefits and dangers of AI technologies? Do we need better regulation? Does Big Tech have too much power? How do we balance innovation with safety? Find out more on this episode:

See all episodes →