Should I Marry a Murderer? (Netflix, 2026) with Mary Payne from Pink Shade

Mary Payne Gilbert from Pink Shade joins me to discuss the 2026 Netflix documentary: Should I Marry a Murderer? Dr. Caroline Muirhead meets the man of her dreams and falls in love quickly, only to discover he and his twin brother are involved in the tragic death of cyclist Tony Parsons. We discuss:

Caroline’s Erratic Behavior: What motivated this intelligent, beautiful woman to keep returning to this bad situation? Was it just his hotness or something more?

Sandy and Robert McKellar’s Role in Tony Parson’s Death: Exactly what went down that night in 2017 when the McKellar brothers came across Tony Parsons on a dark, deserted road?

Witness Protection: The protections afforded to witnesses in the UK seem wildly different than those in the US. We discuss viewing this documentary through an American lens.

JOIN MURDER CLUB Want more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.

Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatched

Newsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.com

SUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCH

Merch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.com

Cameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcher

Reality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.com

CONNECT WITH US

Instagram: @murdershewatchedpod

Facebook Group: Couch Detectives Community

YouTube: Watch the recaps

Email: [email protected]

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices