Horse Show Bestie

Overcoming Show Pen Nerves, Coming Back After Loss, and Riding in College with Catherine Goffard

Horse Show Bestie

Show Notes

Besties, this episode is giving horse show hangover, late-night John Justin energy, and the kind of post show conversation that somehow makes you laugh, tear up, and feel personally called out all at once. Scott is joined by Catherine Goffard fresh off an incredible APHA World Show, where she and Calvin (Obsessed to be Best) celebrated a showmanship win, reserve finishes, and a Western riding breakthrough that was years in the making. Before they dive into the ribbons, they chat about world show exhaustion, Catherine's night-shift nursing schedule, and why 2 a.m. practice rides are just part of life. Catherine shares her journey from Green Bay horse girl to TCU equestrian athlete, reflecting on how college catch-riding taught her confidence, adaptability, and the value of being part of a team that genuinely cheers for each other's success. That team-first mindset carries through the entire conversation. The pair also unpack Calvin's World Show, bringing along a talented but still-green all-around horse, and the mental challenge of Western riding. Catherine talks honestly about learning to trust, soften, and let go of control, plus the breakthrough ride that came from believing in her preparation. And yes, Calvin's now-famous snack of the arena decorations definitely gets a mention. The heart of the episode is an honest conversation about anxiety, confidence, and trusting both yourself and your horse. Catherine shares practical sports psychology tools she still relies on, including power posing, box breathing, grounding techniques, and focusing on the things she can control when the pressure is high. She also opens up about losing her once-in-a-lifetime horse, Gilly, and how Calvin represents not a replacement, but a new chapter built on patience, healing, and learning to trust again. It's a touching reminder that our greatest horses continue shaping us long after they're gone. By the end, this episode celebrates everything that makes horse showing unforgettable: the exhaustion, the laughter, the barn family, the inside jokes, and the horses that change our lives. It's full of practical mindset takeaways and a reminder that confidence is built one ride at a time, and no one has to do it alone.

Sponsors NAC Equine: www.nac-equine-services.com Crysta Brown Horsemanship www.cbhorsemanship.com

More from Horse Show Bestie

Oct 6, 2026

Besties, welcome to something new! Scott is flying solo for this mini episode with a very horsey weekend recap, some show-pen perspective, and his first-ever DIY full-body clip on Chip. He kicks things off with the California Championship Quarter Horse Show and a reminder that the things we build up in our heads are often much less intimidating once we actually experience them. The competition is real, the amateurs are talented, and you still belong there. Then it’s clipping time. Scott shares what he learned tackling Chip’s first full-body clip, from prepping the coat and navigating tricky skin folds to accepting that a few clipper lines are absolutely not worth spiraling over. There’s also a questionable dinosaur mane, strong opinions about mayonnaise, a post-clip bath, and some thoughts on upcoming fall shows and possibly heading to Western Nationals. A quick reminder from Scott: confidence usually shows up after you start, not before. Go to the show. Try the thing. Clip the horse. The lines will grow out. Support Our Sponsors NAC Equine: https://www.nac-equine-services.com/ Crysta Brown Horsemanship: www.CBhorsemanship.com

Sep 23, 2026

Besties, what if the judge in the middle of the pen isn’t sitting there waiting for you to mess up? What if they’re actually riding every step with you, hoping you give them something good to reward? In this episode, Crysta sits down with judge, trainer, and longtime horsewoman Nancie Wright to talk about what really happens on the other side of the judge’s card. Nancie shares how just ten childhood riding lessons turned into a lifetime with horses, how mentors and unexpected opportunities helped her build a career, and why she eventually fell in love with judging. Then we get into some of the biggest horse show myths. Going first does not automatically ruin your chances. Judges have not secretly decided they don’t like your horse. And sadly, the $5,000 jacket is not a cheat code for winning. Nancie breaks down what judges are actually looking for in patterns and rail classes, why the rule book is one of the best free training tools we have, and how to use your scores as a roadmap instead of a report card on your worth. She also explains why a correct zero is worth celebrating, how judges reward quality one maneuver at a time, and why your job is simply to put the best ride you can in the pen that day. And because we are Horse Show Bestie, we also talk about the part of showing that has nothing to do with ribbons. Helping the new exhibitor fix their number. Lending a saddle pad. Helping a kid with their mane. Answering the question they were nervous to ask. Basically, being the person who makes someone want to come back. Because everybody starts somewhere. And maybe the judge isn’t rooting against you after all. Maybe they’re hoping you give them something really good to write down. ✨ Support Our Sponsors NAC Equine: https://www.nac-equine-services.com/ Crysta Brown Horsemanship: www.CBhorsemanship.com

Sep 14, 2026

Besties, it’s time to talk bits. Because apparently, there is a lot more going on in that little piece of metal than “my horse likes this one.” Scott and Crysta sit down with legendary bit maker Chuck Letchworth to talk about what a bit actually does, why the first signal matters, and why better communication, not more pressure, is what creates a softer, more confident horse. Chuck breaks down the details that actually change what a horse feels, from shank angle and purchase to mouthpiece shape, curb material, width, and balance. He also gets into why choosing a bit simply because it worked on your last horse is probably not the strategy we thought it was. Then we get into the training behind the equipment: giving a horse time to understand a new bridle, rewarding the smallest correct response, making lead changes part of everyday life, and why intimidation is not a substitute for training. Scott learns a very important lesson about the missing rope on his trail bit, Crysta finally gets answers about square mouthpieces, and both hosts leave with a slightly different perspective on what their hands are actually saying. If you’ve ever stood in front of a tack-room wall wondering why one bit costs more than your first car, why your horse braces before you even make contact, or whether the problem is actually the bit, this episode is for you.

Sep 8, 2026

This week, we’re talking horses, money, social media, and the occasional existential crisis. 💅🏼 We get into what actually makes a horse valuable, why good trainers and breeders are worth paying for, and the not-so-glamorous realities of investing in horses. We also dissect riding videos, hand position, back cinches, safety, and the risks that come with showing and training. And because apparently horses aren’t enough to keep us busy, we talk mental health, self-care, and learning to advocate for yourself when life gets a little too much. Basically: horse girl problems, but with receipts.

Aug 11, 2026

Horse Show Bestie is back with a little bit of horse show chaos, a little existential questioning, and a healthy amount of “why are we like this?” Crysta and Scott get into everything from childhood experiences, religion, community, and finding your place in the horse world to how the horse training industry has changed over time. They talk about the importance of grassroots events like fairs and livestock shows, the mentors who shape us, and why having a supportive equestrian community matters more than we sometimes admit. Then, naturally, things turn into horse show logistics. Scott recaps his latest show experience, including the preparation, competition, prizes, and all the glamorous realities of getting horses where they need to go. They also get into European hauling culture, international horse show travel, and why traveling with horses is basically an extreme sport with a trailer. Crysta shares stories from Rotterdam and a recent clinic, while the two compare notes on busy schedules, their horses, and the strange phenomenon of desperately wanting a break from the horse world while simultaneously making the horse world your entire personality. Basically: horses, travel, competition, community, personal growth, and two besties trying to have a life outside of the horse show.

See all episodes →