Show Notes
In this episode of Big Shot, we're honored to host business mogul Peter May. But his path to managing more than $7 billion is not what you might expect. What started as a career as an accountant at the prestigious KPMG quickly became something much different once Peter crossed paths with Nelson Peltz, igniting a dynamic partnership that spanned decades. Together, they founded Triarc Companies and pioneered innovative funding strategies, revitalizing numerous struggling businesses. They eventually sold the company and founded Trian Partners, a multi-billion dollar investment firm. Peter's commitment to philanthropy extends beyond financial contributions, as he invests his time and expertise. Notably, his impactful work with Mount Sinai Health Systems and Operation Exodus showcases his dedication to making a difference. Join us as Peter generously imparts invaluable insights and practical wisdom applicable to all aspects of life.
In This Episode We Cover:
(07:28) What it was like growing up during the Cold War in Long Island
(12:12) How his father was a great role model
(14:33) Peter’s time at The University of Chicago
(16:25) How Peter was inspired by his father’s saying, “Do more than what’s expected of you”
(22:24) The Jewish value of education
(24:53) How Peter was able to avoid being drafted to Vietnam
(30:59) Getting started as an accountant at KPMG
(32:40) How Peter met Nelson Peltz
(34:24) The importance of adding value
(36:11) The origins of Home Depot
(38:16) How Peter and Nelson Peltz went into business together
(41:00) When Peter and Nelson took their company public
(44:25) What happened after Peter and Nelson sold Flagstaff foods
(49:20) Peter and Nelson’s funding strategy emerges
(50:42) How MPM group consulting got its start
(51:57) What constructive capitalism is
(54:10) How Peter and Nelson bought Triangle Industries
(1:00:29) How Peter and Nelson transformed Triangle and made it profitable
(1:03:18) The purchase of America Can and National Can
(1:17:03) The meaning of Nelson’s phrase “I’d rather be rich than right”
(1:18:53) Why Peter doesn’t look back much
(1:20:14) Why chutzpah is so quintessential to the Jewish entrepreneurial experience
(1:22:23) Why Peter doesn’t feel like he’s made it still
(1:23:30) About “engaged philanthropy” and how Peter helped turn around Mount Sinai Health
(1:30:15) Peter’s advice to the next generation
(1:33:26) About Operation Exodus
(1:36:33) Peter’s legacy—
Referenced:
Green tea benefits: https://www.firebellytea.com/blogs/all/green-tea-benefits
Firebelly Tea: https://www.firebellytea.com/
The University of Chicago: https://www.uchicago.edu/en
Pogroms: https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/pogroms
Nelson Peltz: https://www.forbes.com/profile/nelson-peltz/
Arthur Anderson: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Andersen
KPMG: https://kpmg.com/
Emerson Radio: https://www.emersonradio.com/
Bernard Marcus: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard_Marcus
Mike Milken: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Milken
Saul Steinberg: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saul_Steinberg
Victor Posner: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_Posner
Alcoa: https://www.alcoa.com/global/en/home/
Mount Sinai Health System: https://www.mountsinai.org/
Engaged philanthropy: https://engagedgiving.org/philosophy
Operation Exodus: https://operationexodususa.org/
—
Where to find Peter May:
Mount Sinai Health: https://www.mountsinai.org/about/board-leadership/peter-may
Wendy’s: https://www.wendys.com/who-we-are/board-directors/peter-may
Where To Find Big Shot:
Website: https://www.bigshot.show/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@bigshotpodcast
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bigshotshow
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bigshotshow/
Harley Finkelstein: https://twitter.com/harleyf
David Segal: https://twitter.com/tea_maverick
Production and Marketing: https://penname.co
More from Big Shot
Isaac Larian is the founder and CEO of MGA Entertainment, the company behind Bratz, L.O.L. Surprise!, Little Tikes, and dozens of other iconic toy brands. But long before he built one of the largest private toy companies in the world, Isaac was a Jewish kid growing up in Tehran, where he faced antisemitism, bullying, and poverty. After arriving in America alone at 17 with just $753 in his pocket, Isaac worked the graveyard shift washing dishes while putting himself through college. He later built a successful electronics distribution business, became one of Nintendo's largest distributors, and eventually shifted into toys, where he created some of the most successful doll brands of the last two decades. In 2026, Isaac was inducted into the Toy Industry Hall of Fame in recognition of his transformative impact on the industry and his role in creating global brands including Bratz and L.O.L. Surprise!. In this episode of Big Shot, Harley Finkelstein and David Segal sit down with Isaac to discuss the experiences that shaped his relentless drive, the lessons he learned from failure, and the persistence that helped him build MGA Entertainment. They talk about his years in electronics, how he broke into Nintendo, why getting cut off led him into licensing, the creation of Bratz, the battle with Mattel, and why he believes fortune favors the bold.
Irwin Winkler has spent more than six decades in Hollywood, producing films that have earned 52 Academy Award nominations and helped define generations of moviegoers. His credits include Rocky, Raging Bull, Goodfellas, The Right Stuff, and The Irishman, but the path that led to those films was anything but predictable. In this episode of Big Shot, hosts Harley Finkelstein and David Segal sit down with Irwin to look back on the twists, turns, relationships, and moments of good fortune that shaped his remarkable career. From the William Morris mailroom to launching an agency with Robert Chartoff, from representing Julie Christie to hearing Sylvester Stallone pitch Rocky, Irwin shares the stories behind a life spent at the center of the movie business. Along the way, he reflects on the people who changed his life, the opportunities he almost missed, and the unexpected chain of events that led from a kid growing up in Brooklyn to one of the most successful producers in Hollywood history. — In This Episode We Cover: (00:00) Intro (03:13) Growing up in Williamsburg, Brooklyn (07:11) Moving to the Sea Gate in Coney Island (08:26) Irwin's first attempt at NYU (10:22) Why he enlisted in the Army (10:55) Back to NYU after the Army (12:00) How he got interested in working for a talent agency (14:20) From summer mailroom gig at William Morris to full-time job (18:45) Climbing the ranks at William Morris (23:18) Leaving William Morris to work with Bob Chartoff (29:14) How Julie Christie helped launch his producing career (39:47) Meeting Sylvester Stallone and hearing the Rocky pitch (48:53) Rocky's reception and the reshoot that saved the film (51:48) How he started working with Martin Scorsese (53:54) Managing productions and safeguarding creatives (57:01) How Rocky II helped get Raging Bull made (59:45) Funding movies then vs. now (1:01:47) Irwin’s thoughts on AI and CGI (1:03:14) The role of luck, hard work, and partnerships in his success (1:07:12) The story of meeting Jack Warner and the Six-Day War (1:10:21) Irwin's perspective on Jewish success in business and entertainment
Barry Diller started in the mailroom at the William Morris Agency, but he had no interest in becoming an agent. He didn’t hustle the way others did. Instead, he spent his time in the file room, reading everything he could and learning how the business actually worked. By his own account, he likely would have been fired if not for one thing: his connection to Danny Thomas. In this episode of Big Shot, Barry sits down with Harley and David to reflect on the path that took him from that mailroom to running studios, building networks, and shaping modern media. He shares how his ambition came later, not as something he chased but something he discovered, and how his career was shaped as much by timing and luck as by intention. Along the way, Barry walks through the decisions that defined his career, from rising quickly through ABC and becoming chairman of Paramount at 32, to building the Fox network alongside Rupert Murdoch, and later taking control of IAC and acquiring companies like Expedia. This is a conversation about instinct, timing, and the willingness to walk through the door when it opens. — In This Episode We Cover: (00:00) Intro (03:32) Barry’s early heroes and influences (05:16) Where his ambition came from (06:50) Getting his start in the mailroom at the William Morris Agency (08:53) What he learned from reading client files at William Morris (12:10) Working as an assistant at William Morris (14:00) How he got a job at ABC (16:32) Barry’s thoughts on serendipity (19:20) Developing The Movie of the Week and miniseries at ABC (22:32) Becoming chairman of Paramount at 32 (26:44) Working with Charles Bluhdorn (28:20) Why he still feels like he hasn’t made it (30:00) Building the Fox network and bringing Rupert Murdoch on board (34:06) How he took control of IAC (38:07) The story behind buying Expedia (40:47) Barry’s leadership philosophy (41:37) M&A strategy at IAC (44:43) How Eastern European Jews built Hollywood (47:36) Barry’s relationship to Jewish culture — Where To Find Barry Diller: • Website: https://www.iac.com/leadership/barry-diller Where To Find Big Shot: • Website: https://www.bigshot.show/ • YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@bigshotpodcast • TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bigshotshow • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bigshotshow/ • Harley Finkelstein: https://twitter.com/harleyf • David Segal: https://twitter.com/tea_maverick • Production and Marketing: https://penname.co
Lew Wolff didn’t set out to become a successful developer or a professional sports team owner. He didn’t grow up around business, and by his own account, he stumbled into real estate almost by accident. But over the course of a decades-long career, he would go on to reshape downtown San Jose, partner with 20th Century Fox, and take ownership stakes in teams like the Oakland Athletics and Golden State Warriors. In this episode of Big Shot, Lew sits down with Harley and David to reflect on the unconventional path that led him there. He shares how the sudden death of his father forced him to grow up quickly, how a chance decision in college set him on a career in real estate, and how one unexpected opportunity led to a role at Fox and a headline that would change everything overnight. Along the way, Lew explains why he built his career around partnerships, how he thinks about choosing the right people to work with, and why he has always prioritized relationships over short-term profit. He also reflects on his time in professional sports, including the story behind Moneyball, the challenges of public scrutiny, and the behind-the-scenes dynamics that shaped the future of the A’s. — In This Episode We Cover: (00:00) Intro (02:25) Lew’s early years growing up in the Midwest (05:54) How his father’s death changed his path (10:28) Growing up Jewish in St. Louis (11:43) His first job and move to Los Angeles (14:34) Starting his own firm and selling to Booz Allen (17:18) His work with 20th Century Fox (24:39) Balancing the San Jose development with his work at Fox (27:20) How his studio office helped attract clients (29:21) How Bud Selig led him to buy a stake in the Oakland A’s (38:18) Lew’s philosophy on partnerships and how to choose them (42:54) Buying and selling his stake in the Golden State Warriors (45:46) The kind of work he enjoys and what he credits for his success (50:42) The story behind Moneyball (54:19) Why he stays focused on the future (55:20) Why he prioritizes relationships over profit (58:57) How he handled negative press as owner of the A’s (1:03:48) How the Giants blocked the A’s from building a new stadium (1:08:59) How he learned to let things go (1:12:51) Lew and Bud’s attempt to integrate their fraternity (1:15:07) His thoughts on Jewish entrepreneurship (1:18:38) What he’s most proud of — Where To Find Lew Wolff: • Website: https://www.wolffurban.com/ Where To Find Big Shot: • Website: https://www.bigshot.show/ • YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@bigshotpodcast • TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bigshotshow • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bigshotshow/ • Harley Finkelstein: https://twitter.com/harleyf • David Segal: https://twitter.com/tea_maverick • Production and Marketing: https://penname.co
Joseph Schaefer arrived in Canada from Poland in the 1930s and built his career in Montreal’s garment district at a time when the industry ran on instinct, relationships, and trust. He had an eye for fashion, a gift for reading people, and a way of doing business that set him apart early. In this episode of Big Shot, Joseph joins hosts Harley and David to reflect on how he found his way into the garment trade and helped shape what Chabanel would become. He shares how he built partnerships that lasted decades, why he never lost a partner, and how he gave others ownership long before equity was common practice. This is a story about a different era of entrepreneurship—one where deals were built on reputation, capital came through relationships, and success depended on understanding both the product and the people behind it. Joseph also reflects on what’s changed, why that kind of success is harder to replicate today, and the role his values and faith played in how he built his life and business. — In This Episode We Cover: (00:00) Intro (01:06) Early days after immigrating to Canada (03:10) How Joseph got his start in entrepreneurship (07:38) Learning the craft with help from his sister (09:55) When he brought on salespeople (11:27) How he built Chabanel (14:20) Joseph’s approach to capital and equity (18:16) How Joseph won over banks (22:24) Why Joseph’s success wouldn’t be repeatable in today’s market (25:45) How Joseph managed partnerships (29:00) Joseph’s legacy (31:52) Joseph’s advice for young entrepreneurs (32:50) His relationship with the Bronfmans (35:20) The role of faith in his life — Where To Find Big Shot: • Website: https://www.bigshot.show/ • YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@bigshotpodcast • TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@bigshotshow • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bigshotshow/ • Harley Finkelstein: https://twitter.com/harleyf • David Segal: https://twitter.com/tea_maverick • Production and Marketing: https://penname.co