Chewed UP

Pumpkin Pie or Cheesecake? Clinton Kelly Says Have Both

Chewed UP

Show Notes

Clinton Kelly whips up an easy pumpkin swirl cheesecake that'll make you forget your Halloween candy regrets. On this spooky episode of the Chewed Up Show, hosts Clinton Kelly, Carla Hall, and Michael Symon create a stunning pumpkin swirl cheesecake using cream cheese, pumpkin puree, and warm pumpkin spice flavors baked in a graham cracker crust. The hosts kick things off with a hilarious Halloween candy swap, then move into the kitchen to prepare this simple but impressive fall dessert. Between baking, they play "Pumpkin Spice or Pumpkin Lies"—a game where Michael challenges Clinton and Carla to guess whether unusual pumpkin spice products are real or completely made up. The finished cheesecake is served with softly whipped cream and tastes even better than it looks. Subscribe to the Chewed Up Show on YouTube for new episodes every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Find recipes, behind-the-scenes content, and more at allchewedup.com. 🙌 Special Thanks to Our Sponsors: Sponsored by ButcherBox. ButcherBox delivers 100% grass-fed beef, organic chicken, wild-caught seafood and more, all sourced to standards they can actually tell you about. Go to butcherbox.com/chewed to get $20 off your first box, plus chicken breast in every box for life or filet or New York strips for a year with free shipping always. Sponsored by Frontgate → Premium home, kitchen, and entertaining essentials — including Michael Symon's collection featured on the show.https://frontgate.com Sponsored by FreshDirect → Fresh groceries delivered straight to your door.https://www.freshdirect.com Produced by Simple Alien → https://www.simplealien.com/ Camera, Audio and Crew provided by TV Boy → https://tvboynyc.com/ Get recipes and more at https://allchewedup.com, and follow Chewed Up on your favorite podcast platform.

More from Chewed UP

Oct 26, 2026

Is your garlic killing the flavor? Michael Symon has STRONG opinions—and that jar in your fridge might be his first target. 🎃 We're kicking off Day 1 of Chewed Up's Halloween Week with Garlic 101, outrageously buttery garlic mashed potatoes, and a few kitchen habits Michael wants you to bury for good.

Oct 21, 2026

Carla Hall reveals the exact science behind perfect cream puffs—and why precision is everything in baking. Join Clinton Kelly, Carla Hall, and Michael Symon as they demystify pâte à choux dough, master the panade technique, and create show-stopping cream puffs filled with malted vanilla bean pastry cream. You'll learn why weighing ingredients in grams changes everything, how to avoid common baking mistakes, and the visual cues that signal success. Whether you're a savory cook intimidated by baking or a home baker looking for consistency, this episode breaks down the exact steps to replicate restaurant-quality results at home. The hosts also share their favorite things to make with pâte à choux and discuss the philosophy behind precision in the kitchen.

Oct 19, 2026

Clinton, Carla, and Michael go head-to-head in a blind taste test of five boxed mac and cheese brands to crown the ultimate winner. Then Clinton shares his go-to recipe for stovetop mac and cheese that's easier than you'd think. On this episode of Chewed Up, hosts Clinton Kelly, Carla Hall, and Michael Symon taste their way through five different boxed mac and cheese options without knowing which brands they're eating. After ranking them, they're shocked to discover which came out on top. Later, Clinton demonstrates his simple three-cheese stovetop mac and cheese recipe using Colby, cheddar, and Gruyère—proving that homemade versions are just as quick and convenient as the boxed stuff. Thanks to FreshDirect for sponsoring this episode. FreshDirect delivers fresh groceries straight to your door. Visit FreshDirect.com to order today. New episodes of Chewed Up drop every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Subscribe now and head to AllChewedUp.com for recipes, behind-the-scenes content, and more. 🙌 Special Thanks to Our Sponsors: Frontgate → Premium home, kitchen, and entertaining essentials — including Michael Symon's collection featured on the show.https://frontgate.com FreshDirect → Fresh groceries delivered straight to your door.https://www.freshdirect.com Subscribe to Chewed Up Show for new episodes every Monday, and Wednesday. Head to allchewedup.com for recipes and exclusive content. Produced by Simple Alien → https://www.simplealien.com/ Camera, Audio and Crew provided by TV Boy → https://tvboynyc.com/ Want to Watch? → Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/3Z9NDuHH7XP03FXQIhHlQ3 → YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@ChewedUpShow Want to Listen? → Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/3Z9NDuHH7XP03FXQIhHlQ3 → Apple https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/chewed-up/id1840993910 → Amazon https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/1fc5d229-459b-4334-8970-ce0d6f925982/chewed-up

Oct 14, 2026

Watch as Carla Hall makes a show-stopping cinnamon coffee cake while Clinton Kelly and Michael Symon share their biggest rants—from left-lane driving etiquette to cyclist behavior.

Oct 12, 2026

Carla Hall recreates her grandmother's beloved oatmeal cookie sandwich with cream cheese buttercream filling—a forgotten favorite that tastes like a gourmet homemade version of those iconic childhood snacks. On this episode of Chewed Up Show, hosts Michael Symon and Carla Hall explore nostalgic food without Clinton Kelly, who's under the weather. They discuss the science of baking the perfect cookie—crispy exterior, chewy interior—and why using salted butter and brown sugar makes all the difference. From Little Debbie memories to unexpected flavor pairings, Michael and Carla chat about how food triggers our most powerful memories and why some recipes deserve a comeback. The episode also features fan mail on electric stove cooking tips, Michael's premium knife collection, and a debate about whether TV was better before streaming. Plus, see what they're giving away at the end!

See all episodes →