The Demon House: Latoya Ammons’ Real Exorcism Battle Against 200 Demons | True Horror Story
Chasing the Dark: Where True Crime Meets the ParanormalShow Notes
What happens when darkness doesn’t just haunt a house… it claims a family?
In November 2011, Latoya Ammons moved her three young children into a quiet rental on Carolina Street in Gary, Indiana, hoping for a fresh start. Instead, they walked into what many call the most documented case of demonic possession in modern history: the infamous Demon House. Black flies swarmed the porch in freezing winter. Footsteps climbed empty stairs at midnight. Children levitated, walked backward up walls in front of horrified witnesses, spoke in guttural voices no child should have, and convulsed with unnatural strength. A 9-year-old boy described his own murder to an unseen entity. Objects moved on their own. Shadows watched. And Latoya herself felt something ancient and malevolent coil inside her—weakness, shaking, heat from within—while the house slammed doors and dripped impossible oil in response. Police investigated. DCS took emergency custody. A priest performed multiple exorcisms—three major rites authorized by the Diocese of Gary, including one in Latin—while estimating over 200 demons tormented the family. Officers guarded the rituals. Equipment failed. Photos captured silhouettes that weren’t there. Even skeptics became believers. This is the true story behind the “Demon House” that Zak Bagans bought, filmed, and demolished for his 2018 documentary—the chilling real events that inspired Netflix’s The Deliverance and countless true horror discussions. From black mold theories to full demonic infestation, we dive deep into the documented terror: witness statements, police reports, priest accounts, and the family’s fight to reclaim their lives. Listener discretion advised, this episode contains disturbing accounts of possession, child trauma, exorcisms, and unexplainable phenomena that may unsettle even the bravest souls. If you love true crime with a paranormal twist, real exorcism stories, haunted house investigations, demonic possession cases, or the scariest true horror from Gary Indiana, this episode of Chasing the Dark will keep you up long after it ends. Subscribe now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss an episode as we chase the shadows others fear to face. Follow @ChasingtheDark21 on social media for updates, behind-the-scenes, and community chills. Sweet dreams… or whatever’s left of them.
Sources : Primary: “The Exorcisms of Latoya Ammons” by Marisa Kwiatkowski, Indianapolis Star (IndyStar), January 25, 2014 (updated/republished 2023–2025) – the original investigative article that went viral and sparked the case’s fame. Additional: Wikipedia “Ammons haunting case” (cross-referenced with primary sources); All That’s Interesting overview; US Ghost Adventures summary; IndyStar follow-ups on Zak Bagans’ Demon House (2018 documentary); Netflix The Deliverance inspiration
More from Chasing the Dark: Where True Crime Meets the Paranormal
In 1589, Peter Stumpp became infamous as the Werewolf of Bedburg, one of the most disturbing figures in European werewolf history. Accused of horrific crimes and alleged supernatural transformation, his case became a chilling intersection of true crime, werewolf legends, witchcraft accusations, and sixteenth-century German history. But who was Peter Stumpp really? Was he a brutal killer, or did fear, torture, and the beliefs of his time help create a monster whose story would survive for centuries? Welcome to Chasing the Dark, where true crime meets the paranormal. Journey back to 16th-century Germany as we investigate the infamous Bedburg werewolf trial, the sensational 1590 pamphlet that spread Stumpp’s story, the brutal justice of the era, and the line between documented history and supernatural legend. IN THIS EPISODE • Peter Stumpp and the Werewolf of Bedburg • The 1589 werewolf trial and its shocking accusations • Werewolf folklore and witchcraft fears in historical Germany • The infamous 1590 pamphlet • Interrogation, execution, and the justice system of the time • Historical evidence versus supernatural claims ⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: This episode discusses historical allegations of murder, violence, torture, and execution. ABOUT CHASING THE DARK Explore true crime, paranormal encounters, dark history, unexplained mysteries, supernatural legends, and chilling stories that refuse to stay buried. Follow the show on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, YouTube, and other major podcast platforms. Find us on social media: @chasingthedark21. SPONSORED BY PHARAON https://www.pharaon.com MUSIC CREDITS Mystical Piano Atmosphere — Universfield https://pixabay.com/music/modern-classical-mystical-piano-atmosphere-231511/ Emotional Piano with Violin — Universfield https://pixabay.com/music/modern-classical-emotional-piano-with-violin-195365/ Dark Crime Piano Drama — Universfield https://pixabay.com/music/solo-piano-dark-crime-piano-drama-498841/ Melancholic Halloween Piano — Universfield https://pixabay.com/music/solo-piano-melancholic-halloween-piano-161524/ Horror — Leberch https://pixabay.com/music/mystery-horror-252905/ Pain — BosonBeats - No Copyright Music Music provided by: BosonBeats - No Copyright Music Listen: https://youtu.be/cZFua_m7yAg HISTORICAL SOURCES British Library — The Damnable Life and Death of Stubbe Peeter (1590): https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/the-damnable-life-and-death-of-stubbe-peeter-a-werewolf-1590 Berlin State Museums — Historical execution print: https://id.smb.museum/object/1058085 Utrecht University Library — Contemporary German pamphlet: https://dbc.library.uu.nl/handle/20.500.14918/9110 Bedburg Historical Society — Bedburg Castle: https://www.geschichtsverein-bedburg.de/permanent/BedburgSchloss.html Baukunst NRW — Historic Kaster town center: https://baukunst-nrw.de/index.php/objekte/3137-historischer-ortskern-bedburg-kaster Historical accounts document the accusations and trial, but supernatural transformation has not been established as fact. Follow, rate, review, and share Chasing the Dark with someone who loves true crime, werewolf legends, and dark history.
Joshua McCabe Bailey was more than a name in a murder case. He was a friend, a brother, a son, and someone whose life mattered deeply to the people who knew him. In this episode of Chasing the Dark: Where True Crime Meets the Paranormal, I sit down with Whitney, who was a friend of Josh and knew him personally before his tragic death. Whitney’s brother was also one of Josh’s close friends, giving her a unique perspective on the person Josh was and the impact his death had on those around him. We talk about who Joshua McCabe Bailey was in life, the circumstances surrounding his murder, what happened after his death, and the lasting impact on the people who knew and loved him. Josh’s case was later featured on the true-crime television series Twisted Killings, bringing his story to a wider audience. But this conversation goes beyond the television episode and the details of the case. Whitney shares her memories of Josh and helps us look beyond the murder to remember the person he was before his name became associated with a tragedy. Because behind every true-crime case is a real person. This is Joshua McCabe Bailey’s story, his life, his murder, and the people left behind. Continuing Josh’s Legacy In Josh’s memory, Josh’s Hope Foundation is a nonprofit organization dedicated to helping young adults living with mental illness, like Joshua. If Josh’s story has touched you and you would like to support the work being done in his memory, donations can be made through Josh’s Hope Foundation: joshshopefoundation.org 🎙️ Chasing the Dark: Where True Crime Meets the Paranormal Content Warning: This episode discusses murder, death, grief, mental illness, and violent crime. Listener discretion is advised.
The Boys Who Vanished: The Wineville Chicken Coop Murders | Chasing the Dark
The Villisca axe murders remain one of America’s most chilling unsolved crimes. On the night of June 9th, 1912, eight people — the Moore family and two young houseguests — were killed in their sleep in a quiet home in Villisca, Iowa. More than a hundred years later, the case is still unsolved, and the Villisca axe murder house is now considered one of the most haunted locations in the Midwest. This episode of Chasing the Dark covers the full true crime story and the paranormal activity people report inside the house today. We sit with both threads of that night: the 1912 crime that was never solved, and the darkness people say never left the house on East Second Street. We walk through the town as it was, the family as they were, and the unbearable, deliberate calm of what was done after midnight — the covered faces, the sealed windows, the locked doors. We follow the contaminated crime scene and the investigation that was lost before it began, the suspects whose names never went away — state senator Frank F. Jones, William Mansfield, and the Reverend George Kelly — and the traveling-killer theory that links Villisca to a cluster of railroad-adjacent family murders around 1912. Then we cross into the paranormal: the EVP recordings, the cold spots, the footsteps, and the reports from inside the Villisca axe murder house — alongside the honest, skeptical counter-explanations. And we sit with the detail that unsettles people most: why the haunting, if it is one, seems to retrace the exact path the killer walked. This is a story about a family. Josiah and Sarah Moore. Their children — Herman, Mary Katherine, Arthur Boyd, and Paul Vernon. And two girls who only meant to stay the night, Lena and Ina Stillinger. We tell it the way we tell every story here: carefully, honestly, and with their names kept attached to who they actually were.
Do demons actually exist — or are we filling the dark with something we can't name?