Theology Girls Podcast

Episode 27: Why are Women Leaving the Church with Kimberly MacNeill

Theology Girls Podcast

Show Notes

This week on the podcast, Katy shares a powerful conversation with Pastor Kimberly MacNeill about why women are leaving the church and attending less than ever before. They discuss hyper masculinity in our Sunday services, sexual abuse scandals, and the lack of a female presence in church leadership as what may be contributing to this phenomenon, as well as provide advice for ministry leaders who seek to elevate the voices of women.

Make sure you check out our bonus Substack episode for paid subscribers where Katy and Kim “re-imagine” what the church might look like if they looked to Jesus’s example of leadership, rather than power and authority.

Books and Resources:

The Blue Parakeet: Rethinking How You Read the Bible by Scot McKnight A Church Called Tov: Forming a Goodness Culture That Resists Abuses of Power and Promotes Healing by Scot McNight and Laura Barringer Jesus and Women: In the First Century and Now by Kristi McLelland The Junia Project Together in Ministry: Women and Men in Flourishing Partnerships by Rob Dixon

Here is the article Kimberly referenced regarding most worship songs being written by men

Don’t forget rate, review and subscribe anywhere you listen and follow us on Instagram @thetheologgirls

More from Theology Girls Podcast

Oct 20, 2026

If you grew up hearing that the gifts of the Spirit ended with the book of Acts, this episode asks what happened in between.

Oct 13, 2026

In the first episode of Weird Women, we start in a prayer room in St. Louis and with worship leader Chante Rivers, who tells the story of singing “How Great Is Our God” in the middle of the unrest in Ferguson, Missouri in 2014. From there we go back to the first recorded worship leader in Scripture: Miriam, the prophetess who led Israel in song at the Red Sea. Dr. Christopher Hays of Fuller Theological Seminary walks us through the female prophets of the Hebrew Bible, including a scholarly case that Miriam’s song may be older than Moses’.

Oct 9, 2026

Today we are sharing the recording from Theology Girls Live on October 2nd with Tara Beth Leach. Tara Beth and Katy discuss what it’s like to be a female pastor, what women’s leadership looked like in scripture and where the church has lost their way. They also discuss challenges female leaders face and Tara Beth offers encouragement for women who feel called to lead.

Oct 6, 2026

Today we’re sharing a special conversation with author, theologian, professor, and podcaster, Nijay Gupta. Nijay is the author of many books, including, “Tell Her Story” which released in 2023, as well as upcoming books “Fierce and Faithful” that he wrote with Carmen Joy Imes that launches on October 27th, as well as “God Spoke Through Her” which will be released in the spring. Katy and Nijay chat about his authorship, what it was like to write a book for children as well as lesser known female Bible characters, why soft complementarianism is sometimes counterintuitive and the special call women have on their lives in our current cultural moment.

Oct 2, 2026

Weird Women is coming.

See all episodes →