The Horseshoe Hangover

2026 Ep07: Did the Colts players fail the Job Interview?

The Horseshoe Hangover

Show Notes

In this episode of Horseshoe Hangover, we break down a frustrating preseason performance where several Colts backups were handed a golden opportunity—and showed up like someone walking into a job interview completely unprepared. Preseason is supposed to be where depth players prove they belong, but instead, the Colts walked away with even more questions. We dive into the concerning lack of depth along the offensive line and at cornerback, and what those weaknesses could mean once the regular season begins and injuries inevitably hit. We also tackle the Colts' kicking battle and debate what should carry more weight when making the final decision: consistent performance on the practice field or delivering when the lights come on in an actual game? The starters might grab the headlines, but this episode is all about the guys fighting for roster spots—and whether the Colts have enough behind their starters to survive a 17-game season.

More from The Horseshoe Hangover

Oct 23, 2026

https://linktr.ee/horseshoehangover [email protected] Removing the Stench of the Ballard Era: What's Next for the Colts?The Chris Ballard era is OVER, and it's time to disinfect the Indianapolis Colts organization!With Ballard out, Carlie Irsay-Gordon has an opportunity to reshape the future of this franchise. But while the on-field product has been disappointing, is there a strong culture behind the scenes worth building around?Everything is on the table, Colts Nation! It's time to use your imagination because nothing should be off-limits!🏈 Blow it up or build around the stars? Could Jonathan Taylor (JT28) be traded? Or should the Colts build their foundation around JT28 and Quenton Nelson (Q56), giving the next GM two cornerstone players to work with?🏈 Is Brian Flores auditioning for his next job? With the Vikings coming to town, could this matchup double as a sideline interview for Flores? If the next GM decides to move on from Shane Steichen, should Flores be a serious head coaching candidate?🏈 The players feel the heat! With Ballard fired, Colts players are acknowledging their responsibility. But will that accountability finally translate into better effort and results on Sundays?🏈 Carlie's next chapter! The Colts may have a strong internal culture, but can Carlie find the leadership needed to restore the winning standard established during the Manning era?The Ballard era is history. The excuses are running out. And the future of this franchise is wide open!All this and more on this week's Horseshoe Hangover Podcast!Colts Nation, let us know what YOU would do! Don't forget to like, subscribe, and drop your thoughts in the comments!#ColtsNation #ForTheShoe #HorseshoeHangover #IndianapolisColts #NFL

Oct 20, 2026

COLTS HIT ROCK BOTTOM! BALLARD FIRED! ISPEYTON MANNING THE ANSWER?

Oct 16, 2026

Twitter /X : @SOUTHBOUNDUKPOD (3) Southbound - YouTube

Oct 13, 2026

Do you have questions for Chris and Tom? Send them our waythrough the Horseshoe Hangover Mailbag! We want to hear from Colts Nation! [email protected]

Oct 9, 2026

The Colts are heading to Pittsburgh, and there is NO shortage of storylines heading into this Week 5 showdown!Chris and Tom are back on Horseshoe Hangover to break down everything surrounding the Colts and Steelers!Carlie Irsay: The Blue-Collar Billionaire? We dive into her hands-on approach to ownership, why she's roaming the sidelines, and what separates her from other NFL owners.Sauce Gardner Gets Real! Sauce admits he's embarrassed by his recent performance. Can the All-Pro corner bounce back and prove he's still one of the NFL's elite?Mutiny in Pittsburgh? Aaron Rodgers and Mike McCarthy are butting heads, emotions are boiling over, and the Steelers seem to have some serious internal drama. Is Pittsburgh starting to unravel?Daniel "Cinderella" Jones! Has Daniel Jones turned into the NFL's Cinderella story, or is the clock about to strike midnight in Pittsburgh?Colts vs. Steelers Preview! We break down the keys to victory, the matchups that matter, and whether Indianapolis can finally overcome its Pittsburgh curse.Weekly NFL Pick'ems! Chris and Tom make their picks, debate the biggest games, and predict who's walking away victorious in Week 5!Colts Nation, is Cinderella Jones the real deal, or are we about to watch the glass slipper shatter?Like, subscribe, and drop your predictions in the comments! We love hearing from Colts Nation!#Colts #ForTheShoe #NFL #ColtsVsSteelers #CarlieIrsay

See all episodes →