Can AI Be Charged With a Crime? The ChatGPT Investigation Explained + Why AI Scams Are Surging
SmartHER NewsShow Notes
Can AI be held responsible for a crime?
In this episode, Jenna breaks down a surprising move by Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, who announced a criminal investigation into OpenAI and ChatGPT following a tragic shooting at Florida State University.
At the center of the case: a new legal theory — if an AI chatbot "aids, abets, or counsels" a crime, could a company be held criminally liable?
Jenna explains how this idea challenges long-standing internet protections under Section 230, and why more state-level cases are testing the limits of tech accountability.
You'll also hear:
OpenAI's response and what the company says it did Why this case could reshape how we view AI: tool vs. participant Key takeaways from a Capitol Hill hearing on AI-driven scams, fraud, and cybercrime How criminals are already using AI for phishing, deepfakes, ransomware, and more The growing debate: innovation vs. public safety
Plus: Jenna walks through the three biggest questions this story raises — and why they matter right now.
00:00 Cold Open Chat 00:09 Florida AG Investigation 01:50 Section 230 Explained 03:00 Aiding And Abetting Theory 04:47 OpenAI Response And Other Cases 06:08 Is AI Search Or Partner 07:11 Capitol Hill AI Crime Hearing 11:45 Three Big Questions 13:40 Guardrails And Alcohol Analogy 15:13 Closing Thoughts Rita Peters
More from SmartHER News
Some describe this exchange as the "most viral moment" fo the 2026 election cycle.
The latest on a rare owl nest in NYC, the shortest White House press secretary tenure in recorded history and how much the war in the Middle East has cost the average American household. Your news update in 15 minutes! Quick. Concise. Nonpartisan. SmartHER.
What do the cases of Lindsay Clancy, Nolan Wells and Cornell have in common? They highlight the importance of a legal procedure often forgotten in our justice system that's critical to whether or not a case heads to court: a grand jury. Join a wide-ranging conversation with attorney and founder of Unbiased, Jordan Berman, who uses her legal expertise to explain the importance of the grand jury process, why it matters and what it means in these 3 stories. 00:00 The Missing Link in Three Legal Cases 00:57 Finding Common Ground in Nonpartisan News 03:20 Meet Jordan Berman, Founder of Unbiased 06:12 What Gets Lost in the Headlines 08:37 Why Grand Juries Matter 09:45 Inside the Grand Jury Process 14:15 Nolan Wells: What No Indictment Means 18:29 Lindsay Clancy: Indictment vs. Trial 22:32 Cornell: The Decision Not to Pursue Charges 30:07 How Media Coverage Shapes Public Opinion 33:04 Ilhan Omar: Questions About the Search Warrant 37:17 What We Don't See Behind the Headlines
Your catch-up on news after a holiday weekend! **As we published this report, news broke of Ambassador Guilfoyle's resignation.
What does justice look like—and who decides? Jenna and podcast host Mary Katharine Ham discuss Christa Pike's case in Tennessee and the broader questions it raises about the death penalty, including the time between sentencing and execution. They also reflect on three years since the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks on Israel, the changing Middle East and the words news organizations use to tell these stories. Along the way: the court of public opinion, a brief look at media coverage of the Cornell case, and how the information we receive shapes our understanding. Plus, parenting styles, a favorite hydration drink and making more time to read with our kids. Want to go beyond the headline? Become a SmartHER News Insider and join the conversation — with our private community, exclusive podcast feed and more. In this episode: 00:00 Welcome to SmartHER News 01:03 Real Life, Parenting & Consequences 04:34 What Does Justice Look Like? 07:01 Christa Pike & the Death Penalty 12:21 Fort Hood & the Execution Debate 14:45 The Eighth Amendment: Cruel & Unusual Punishment 16:29 Public Opinion, Cornell & Media Coverage 19:57 Three Years After Oct. 7 23:49 How the Media Describes Hamas 26:51 Israeli Politics & the Language of War 28:52 The Nova Exhibition & Remembering the Victims 32:01 Marco Rubio's Speech in Greece 35:24 Iran & the Ripple Effects Across the Middle East 37:08 Something SmartHER: Hydration 39:49 Less Scrolling, More Reading 43:11 Wrap-Up Show Notes: Jocko Fuel Hydrate (commissionable link)