Summary
In a recent episode of the podcast "Stuff Matters," host Ed Conway dives into the complexities of global conflicts, using everyday objects as metaphors to explore significant issues. His latest discussion centers on the revived tensions between the USA and Iran, framed by a recent ceasefire collapse. The episode features an interview with defense analyst Professor Michael Clarke, who critiques former President Donald Trump's proposal to act as a "guardian angel" for the Strait of Hormuz while attempting to impose a 20% toll on ships passing through. Clarke argues that such a plan is impractical and unrealistic, emphasizing that it is illegal to charge fees on international waterways unless specified by treaty.
Clarke elaborates on the military capabilities of the U.S. in the region, noting that while America has positioned two carrier battle groups and other military assets near the Strait, the prospect of sustaining a military presence is fraught with potential losses that could be politically damaging. He believes that Trump’s comments represent a form of posturing given the ineffective nature of the U.S. military strategy to deter Iranian aggression, pointing to ongoing Iranian attacks on tankers as evidence.
Historically, both Iran and Iraq have attempted to close the Gulf during the 1980s, which complicates current geopolitical dynamics. Clarke highlights the advancements in weaponry since then, including drones and cruise missiles, which empower Iran to maintain a level of threat in the Strait. He asserts that even with U.S. military presence, the safety of tankers cannot be guaranteed.
The conversation also touches on the implications of Trump's stance and how it reflects inconsistent U.S. foreign policy that could weaken America's standing on the global stage. As countries seek alternatives to the Strait of Hormuz—through development of new ports and pipelines—Clarke warns that Iran's leverage in the global economy may diminish over the next several years.
In conclusion, the podcast provides a nuanced look at the intersection of military strategy, international law, and economic implications of U.S. foreign policy, particularly reflecting on the realities of the ongoing conflict with Iran.
Show Notes
Rip up the Memorandum of Understanding, the ceasefire is well and truly over. Iran and the United States are once more at war – with oil tankers targeted and the Strait of Hormuz firmly shut. Donald Trump's response? He insists the US will take control of the disputed waterway and act as a "guardian angel" for all ships passing through. Originally, he wanted to charge a 20% toll for the privilege, before backtracking on what seemed like an unworkable claim. But is the US still in danger of being dragged deeper into a long-term conflict with Iran that could have repercussions for the region – and the global economy – for years to come? Niall Paterson is joined by Sky's military analyst Professor Michael Clarke.
More from This Is Why
People are surviving on plants, have no power and hardly any water in Oleshky, a Ukrainian city occupied by Russia since the first days of the 2022 full-scale invasion.
There's been a rush to buy Sally Rooney's books after she said she can no longer sell them in the UK. Rooney, known for best-selling novels Normal People and Conversations with Friends, said the decision was made with her publisher over her support for the banned group Palestine Action A month after the group was proscribed by the UK government as a terrorist organisation, Rooney said she would donate the earnings from her UK work to them. The Irish author, seen as one of the most important writers of her generation, has been backed by hundreds of writers and public figures who have signed an open letter to the government. Mhari Aurora speaks to Helen Brown, who writes about culture for the Telegraph, about what is behind Rooney's decision.
PHP. The three little letters few people realised were so vital for most of the websites in the world. But a vulnerability in a piece of programming virtually all of us had never heard of has affected everyone from small businesses to major governments. Millions of cyberattacks have followed in the wake of the problem being made public. But the fact is, your personal information – from email addresses to bank details – was already at risk. AI is increasingly both poacher and gamekeeper – discovering the vulnerability in the first place but also playing a vital role in cybersecurity. So, is it time to rethink our online lives? Gareth Barlow speaks to Sky’s technology correspondent Rowland Manthorpe. Have you got a question for the show? Email us: [email protected]
Winter is coming. So, a decision to finally allow drilling at the controversial Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea should be welcome. Well, not by environmental campaigners – who've accused the government of backtracking on its net zero commitments. And even supporters of North Sea expansion have admitted opening Jackdaw won’t reduce energy bills, even though it could start helping to supply homes within months. Why, then, has Andy Burnham invested so much political capital in giving the go-ahead? Gareth Barlow is joined by Sky’s science and technology editor Tom Clarke and business correspondent Paul Kelso. Have you got a question for the show? Email us: [email protected]
Europe’s leaders are joining the fight for the Far North – but is it already too late? The European Union has announced a new security strategy for the Arctic. Yet Russia and China already appear to have a huge advantage in the region. Moscow is exploring new trade routes through its shadow fleet, and – with Beijing’s help – the race is on to exploit the Arctic’s reserves of rare earth minerals. Will the UK, US and Canada join Europe’s belated response? Or, as the ice melts, is too late to stop a new cold war from heating up? Gareth Barlow speaks to Sky’s military analyst, Robert Clark. There is more exclusive military analysis and content on the new Sky News Defence Insider app. Sky News Defence Insider is a subscription app designed for audiences seeking deeper insight into defence, security and global affairs. Download and subscribe here. Have you got a question for the show? Email us: [email protected] Paid subscription required for full access. UK only. 18+. T&Cs apply.